hehaiguang1123
a6f05ab2d5
- Phase 0: AGENTS.md cleanup (dedup quotes, renumber sections, merge qmd) - Phase 1: typed relations (manage-relations.py, graph-search.py, check-staleness.py, detect-conflicts.py) - Phase 2: frontmatter validator, weekly lint, knowledge promotion, git hooks - Fix .gitignore to track tools/ and .githooks/ - Fix git remote URL (remove plaintext token) - New wiki pages: 504 pages, 34 raw sources
1941 lines
333 KiB
HTML
1941 lines
333 KiB
HTML
<!DOCTYPE html>
|
||
<html lang="en" class="grade-c">
|
||
<head>
|
||
<title>AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting | Scientific Reports</title>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" href="https://www.nature.com/srep.rss"/>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<link rel="preconnect" href="https://cmp.nature.com" crossorigin>
|
||
|
||
<meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge">
|
||
<meta name="applicable-device" content="pc,mobile">
|
||
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1.0,maximum-scale=5,user-scalable=yes">
|
||
<meta name="360-site-verification" content="5a2dc4ab3fcb9b0393241ffbbb490480" />
|
||
|
||
<script data-test="dataLayer">
|
||
window.dataLayer = [{"content":{"category":{"contentType":"article","legacy":{"webtrendsPrimaryArticleType":"research","webtrendsSubjectTerms":"applied-physics;learning-and-memory;mathematics-and-computing;physics;psychology","webtrendsContentCategory":null,"webtrendsContentCollection":"AI in Education","webtrendsContentGroup":"Scientific Reports","webtrendsContentGroupType":null,"webtrendsContentSubGroup":"Article","status":null}},"article":{"doi":"10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6"},"attributes":{"cms":null,"deliveryPlatform":"oscar","copyright":{"open":true,"legacy":{"webtrendsLicenceType":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/"}}},"contentInfo":{"authors":["Greg Kestin","Kelly Miller","Anna Klales","Timothy Milbourne","Gregorio Ponti"],"publishedAt":1748908800,"publishedAtString":"2025-06-03","title":"AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting","legacy":null,"publishedAtTime":null,"documentType":"aplusplus","subjects":"Applied physics,Learning and memory,Mathematics and computing,Physics,Psychology"},"journal":{"pcode":"srep","title":"scientific reports","volume":"15","issue":"1","id":41598,"publishingModel":"Open Access"},"authorization":{"status":true},"features":[{"name":"furtherReadingSection","present":true}],"collection":{"id":"jcejfhfjic"}},"page":{"category":{"pageType":"article"},"attributes":{"template":"mosaic","featureFlags":[{"name":"download-collection-test","active":false},{"name":"download-issue-test","active":false},{"name":"nature-onwards-journey","active":false}],"testGroup":null},"search":null},"privacy":{},"version":"1.0.0","product":null,"session":null,"user":null,"backHalfContent":true,"country":"SG","hasBody":true,"uneditedManuscript":false,"twitterId":["o3xnx","o43y9","o3ef7"],"baiduId":"d38bce82bcb44717ccc29a90c4b781ea","japan":false}];
|
||
window.dataLayer.push({
|
||
ga4MeasurementId: 'G-ERRNTNZ807',
|
||
ga360TrackingId: 'UA-71668177-1',
|
||
twitterId: ['3xnx', 'o43y9', 'o3ef7'],
|
||
baiduId: 'd38bce82bcb44717ccc29a90c4b781ea',
|
||
ga4ServerUrl: 'https://sgtm.nature.com',
|
||
imprint: 'nature'
|
||
});
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
(function(w, d) {
|
||
w.config = w.config || {};
|
||
w.config.mustardcut = false;
|
||
|
||
|
||
if (w.matchMedia && w.matchMedia('only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark)').matches) {
|
||
w.config.mustardcut = true;
|
||
d.classList.add('js');
|
||
d.classList.remove('grade-c');
|
||
d.classList.remove('no-js');
|
||
}
|
||
})(window, document.documentElement);
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<style>@media only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark) { .c-card--major .c-card__title,.u-h1,.u-h2,h1,h2,h2.app-access-wall__title{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-weight:700}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,.c-card__title,.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h3,.u-h4,h3,h4,h5,h6{letter-spacing:-.0117156rem}html{line-height:1.15;text-size-adjust:100%;box-sizing:border-box;font-size:100%;height:100%;overflow-y:scroll}body{background:#eee;color:#222;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.76;margin:0;min-height:100%}details,main{display:block}h1{font-size:2em;margin:.67em 0}a,sup{vertical-align:baseline}a{background-color:transparent;color:#069;overflow-wrap:break-word;text-decoration:underline .0625rem;text-decoration-skip-ink:auto;text-underline-offset:.08em;word-break:break-word}b{font-weight:bolder}sup{font-size:75%;line-height:0;position:relative;top:-.5em}img{border:0;height:auto;max-width:100%;vertical-align:middle}button,input,select{font-family:inherit;font-size:100%;line-height:1.15;margin:0}button,input{overflow:visible}button,select{text-transform:none}[type=submit],button{appearance:button}[type=checkbox]{box-sizing:border-box;padding:0}summary{display:list-item}[hidden]{display:none}button{border-radius:0;cursor:pointer}h1{font-size:min(max(1.5rem,4vw),2rem);font-weight:700;letter-spacing:min(max(-.0117156rem,4vw),-.0390625rem);line-height:min(max(1.6rem,4vw),2.25rem)}.c-card--major .c-card__title,.u-h1,.u-h2,button,h1,h2,h2.app-access-wall__title{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}.c-card--major .c-card__title,.u-h2,h2{font-size:min(max(1.25rem,3.5vw),1.5rem);font-weight:700;letter-spacing:-.0117156rem;line-height:min(max(1.4rem,3.5vw),1.6rem)}.u-h3{letter-spacing:-.0117156rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,.c-card__title,.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h3,.u-h4,h3,h4,h5,h6{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:min(max(1.125rem,3vw),1.25rem);font-weight:700;line-height:1.4rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h4,h3,h4,h5,h6{letter-spacing:-.0117156rem}.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h4{font-size:min(max(1rem,2.5vw),1.125rem)}input+label{padding-left:.5em}nav ol,nav ul{list-style:none none}p:empty{display:none}.app-cta-group{display:flex;flex-direction:column;gap:0 16px;width:100%}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.app-cta-group{align-items:baseline;flex-direction:row}}.app-cta-group>*{flex:1 1 auto}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.app-cta-group>*{flex:0 1 auto}}.c-nature-box{background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #d5d5d5;border-radius:2px;box-shadow:0 0 5px 0 rgba(51,51,51,.1);line-height:1.3;margin-bottom:24px;padding:16px 16px 3px}.c-nature-box__text{font-size:1rem;margin-bottom:16px}.c-nature-box--access-to-pdf{display:none}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-nature-box--mobile{display:none}}.c-nature-box .c-pdf-download{margin-bottom:16px!important}.c-nature-box svg+.c-article__button-text{margin-left:8px}.c-nature-box--version{background-color:#eee}.c-nature-box__wrapper{transform:translateZ(0)}.c-nature-box__wrapper--placeholder{min-height:165px}.sans-serif{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}.article-page{background:#fff}p{overflow-wrap:break-word;word-break:break-word}.c-article-header{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;margin-bottom:40px}.c-article-identifiers{color:#6f6f6f;display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3;list-style:none;padding:0}.c-article-identifiers__item{list-style:none;margin-right:8px;padding-right:8px}.c-article-identifiers__item:last-child{margin-right:0;padding-right:0}.c-article-title{font-size:1.5rem;line-height:1.25;margin:0 0 16px}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-article-title{font-size:1.875rem;line-height:1.2}}.c-article-author-list{display:inline;font-size:1rem;list-style:none;margin:0 8px 0 0;padding:0;width:100%}.c-article-author-list__item{display:inline;padding-right:0}.c-article-author-list svg{margin-left:4px}.c-article-author-list__show-more{display:none;margin-right:4px}.c-article-author-list__button,.js .c-article-author-list__item--hide,.js .c-article-author-list__show-more{display:none}.js .c-article-author-list--long .c-article-author-list__show-more,.js .c-article-author-list--long+.c-article-author-list__button{display:inline}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.js .c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen{display:none}.js .c-article-author-list--short .c-article-author-list__show-more,.js .c-article-author-list--short+.c-article-author-list__button{display:inline}}#uptodate-client,.js .c-article-author-list--expanded .c-article-author-list__show-more{display:none!important}.js .c-article-author-list--expanded .c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen{display:inline!important}.c-article-author-list__button,.c-button-author-list{background:#ebf1f5;border:4px solid #ebf1f5;border-radius:20px;color:#666;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4;padding:2px 11px 2px 8px;text-decoration:none}.c-article-author-list__button svg,.c-button-author-list svg{margin:1px 4px 0 0}.c-article-author-list__button:hover,.c-button-author-list:hover{background:#069;border-color:transparent;color:#fff}.c-article-info-details{font-size:1rem;margin-bottom:8px;margin-top:16px}.c-article-info-details__cite-as{border-left:1px solid #6f6f6f;margin-left:8px;padding-left:8px}.c-article-metrics-bar{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3}.c-article-metrics-bar__wrapper{margin:16px 0}.c-article-metrics-bar__item{align-items:baseline;border-right:1px solid #6f6f6f;margin-right:8px}.c-article-metrics-bar__item:last-child{border-right:0}.c-article-metrics-bar__count{font-weight:700;margin:0}.c-article-metrics-bar__label{color:#626262;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;margin:0 10px 0 5px}.c-article-metrics-bar__details{margin:0}.c-article-main-column{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;margin-right:8.6%;width:60.2%}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-article-main-column{margin-right:0;width:100%}}.c-article-extras{float:left;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;width:31.2%}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-article-extras{display:none}}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__title,.c-article-section__title{border-bottom:2px solid #d5d5d5;font-size:1.25rem;margin:0;padding-bottom:8px}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__title,.c-article-section__title{font-size:1.5rem;line-height:1.24}}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__title{margin-bottom:8px}.c-article-body p{margin-bottom:24px;margin-top:0}.c-article-section{clear:both}.c-article-section__content{margin-bottom:40px;padding-top:8px}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-article-section__content{padding-left:0}}.c-article-authors-search{margin-bottom:24px;margin-top:0}.c-article-authors-search__item,.c-article-authors-search__title{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}.c-article-authors-search__title{color:#626262;font-size:1.05rem;font-weight:700;margin:0;padding:0}.c-article-authors-search__item{font-size:1rem}.c-article-authors-search__text{margin:0}.c-code-block{border:1px solid #fff;font-family:monospace;margin:0 0 24px;padding:20px}.c-code-block__heading{font-weight:400;margin-bottom:16px}.c-code-block__line{display:block;overflow-wrap:break-word;white-space:pre-wrap}.c-article-share-box__no-sharelink-info{font-size:.813rem;font-weight:700;margin-bottom:24px;padding-top:4px}.c-article-share-box__only-read-input{border:1px solid #d5d5d5;box-sizing:content-box;display:inline-block;font-size:.875rem;font-weight:700;height:24px;margin-bottom:8px;padding:8px 10px}.c-article-share-box__button--link-like{background-color:transparent;border:0;color:#069;cursor:pointer;font-size:.875rem;margin-bottom:8px;margin-left:10px}.c-article-editorial-summary__container{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__content p:last-child{margin-bottom:0}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__content--less{max-height:9.5rem;overflow:hidden}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button.active,.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button.hover,.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button:active,.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button:hover{text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-skip-ink:auto}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button{background-color:#fff;border:0;color:#069;font-size:.875rem;margin-bottom:16px}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__collection-label{font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__collection-title{line-height:1.3}.c-reading-companion{clear:both;min-height:389px}.c-reading-companion__sticky{max-width:389px}.c-reading-companion__scroll-pane{margin:0;min-height:200px;overflow:hidden auto}.c-reading-companion__tabs{display:flex;flex-flow:row;font-size:1rem;list-style:none;margin:0 0 8px;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__tabs>li{flex-grow:1}.c-reading-companion__tab{background-color:#eee;border:1px solid #d5d5d5;border-image:initial;border-left-width:0;color:#0067c5;font-size:1rem;padding:8px 8px 8px 15px;text-align:left;width:100%}.c-reading-companion__tabs li:first-child .c-reading-companion__tab{border-left-width:1px}.c-reading-companion__tab--active{background-color:#fff;border-bottom:1px solid #fff;color:#222;font-weight:700}.c-reading-companion__sections-list{list-style:none;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__figures-list,.c-reading-companion__references-list{list-style:none;min-height:389px;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__sections-list{margin:0 0 8px;min-height:50px}.c-reading-companion__section-item{font-size:1rem;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__section-item a{display:block;line-height:1.5;overflow:hidden;padding:8px 0 8px 16px;text-overflow:ellipsis;white-space:nowrap}.c-reading-companion__figure-item{border-top:1px solid #d5d5d5;font-size:1rem;padding:16px 8px 16px 0}.c-reading-companion__figure-item:first-child{border-top:none;padding-top:8px}.c-reading-companion__reference-item{border-top:1px solid #d5d5d5;font-size:1rem;padding:8px 8px 8px 16px}.c-reading-companion__reference-item:first-child{border-top:none}.c-reading-companion__reference-item a{word-break:break-word}.c-reading-companion__reference-citation{display:inline}.c-reading-companion__reference-links{font-size:.813rem;font-weight:700;list-style:none;margin:8px 0 0;padding:0;text-align:right}.c-reading-companion__reference-links>a{display:inline-block;padding-left:8px}.c-reading-companion__reference-links>a:first-child{display:inline-block;padding-left:0}.c-reading-companion__figure-title{display:block;margin:0 0 8px}.c-reading-companion__figure-links{display:flex;justify-content:space-between;margin:8px 0 0}.c-reading-companion__figure-links>a{align-items:center;display:flex}.c-reading-companion__figure-full-link svg{height:.8em;margin-left:2px}.c-reading-companion__panel{border-top:none;display:none;margin-top:0;padding-top:0}.c-cod,.c-reading-companion__panel--active{display:block}.c-cod{font-size:1rem;width:100%}.c-cod__form{background:#ebf0f3}.c-cod__prompt{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;margin:0 0 24px}.c-cod__label{display:block;margin:0 0 4px}.c-cod__row{display:flex;margin:0 0 16px}.c-cod__row:last-child{margin:0}.c-cod__input{border:1px solid #d5d5d5;border-radius:2px;flex:1 1 auto;margin:0;padding:13px}.c-cod__input--submit{background-color:#069;border:1px solid #069;color:#fff;flex-shrink:1;margin-left:8px;transition:background-color .2s ease-out,color .2s ease-out}.c-cod__input--submit-single{flex-basis:100%;flex-shrink:0;margin:0}.c-cod__input--submit:focus,.c-cod__input--submit:hover{background-color:#fff;color:#069}.c-pdf-download__link .u-icon{padding-top:2px}.c-pdf-download{display:flex;margin-bottom:24px;max-height:48px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-pdf-download{max-height:none}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-pdf-download{max-height:48px}}.c-pdf-download__link{display:flex;flex:1 1 0%}.c-pdf-download__link:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-pdf-download__text{padding-right:4px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-pdf-download__text{text-transform:capitalize}}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-pdf-download__text{padding-right:8px}}.c-context-bar--sticky .c-pdf-download{display:block;margin-bottom:0;white-space:nowrap}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-pdf-download .u-sticky-visually-hidden{border:0;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);height:1px;margin:-100%;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute!important;width:1px}}.c-pdf-container{display:flex;justify-content:flex-end}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download{display:flex;flex-basis:100%}}.c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download+.c-pdf-download{margin-left:16px}.c-article-extras .c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download{width:100%}.c-article-extras .c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download+.c-pdf-download{margin-left:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-context-bar--sticky .c-pdf-download__link{align-items:center;flex:1 1 183px}}@media only screen and (max-width:320px){.c-context-bar--sticky .c-pdf-download__link{padding:16px}}.article-page--commercial .c-article-main-column .c-pdf-button__container .c-pdf-download{display:none}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.article-page--commercial .c-article-main-column .c-pdf-button__container .c-pdf-download{display:block}}.c-recommendations-column-switch .c-meta{margin-top:auto}.c-context-bar{box-shadow:0 0 10px 0 rgba(51,51,51,.2);position:relative;width:100%}.c-context-bar__container{margin:0 auto;max-width:1280px;padding:0 16px}.c-context-bar__title{display:none}.app-researcher-popup__link.hover,.app-researcher-popup__link.visited,.app-researcher-popup__link:hover,.app-researcher-popup__link:visited,.c-article-metrics__heading a,.c-article-metrics__posts .c-card__title a{color:inherit}.c-article-authors-search__list{align-items:center;display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:16px;justify-content:center}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-article-authors-search__list{justify-content:normal}}.c-article-authors-search__text{align-items:center;display:flex;flex-flow:column wrap;font-size:14px;justify-content:center}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-article-authors-search__text{flex-direction:row;font-size:16px}}.c-article-authors-search__links-text{font-weight:700;margin-right:8px;text-align:center}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-article-authors-search__links-text{text-align:left}}.c-article-authors-search__list-item--left{flex:1 1 100%}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-article-authors-search__list-item--left{flex-basis:auto}}.c-article-authors-search__list-item--right{flex:1 1 auto}.c-article-identifiers{margin:0}.c-article-identifiers__item{border-right:2px solid #cedbe0;color:#222;font-size:14px}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-article-identifiers__item{font-size:16px}}.c-article-identifiers__item:last-child{border-right:none}.c-article-metrics__posts .c-card__title{font-size:1.05rem}.c-article-metrics__posts .c-card__title+span{color:#6f6f6f;font-size:1rem}.app-author-list{color:#222;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.app-author-list>li,.c-breadcrumbs>li,.c-footer__links>li,.js .app-author-list,.u-list-comma-separated>li,.u-list-inline>li{display:inline}.app-author-list>li:not(:first-child):not(:last-child):before{content:", "}.app-author-list>li:not(:only-child):last-child:before{content:" & "}.app-author-list--compact{font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4}.app-author-list--truncated>li:not(:only-child):last-child:before{content:" ... "}.js .app-author-list__hide{display:none;visibility:hidden}.js .app-author-list__hide:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}.c-ad{text-align:center}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-ad{padding:8px}}.c-ad--728x90{background-color:#ccc;display:none}.c-ad--728x90 .c-ad__inner{min-height:calc(1.5em + 94px)}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.js .c-ad--728x90{display:none}.js .u-show-following-ad+.c-ad--728x90{display:block}}.c-ad__label{color:#333;font-weight:400;line-height:1.5;margin-bottom:4px}.c-ad__label,.c-meta{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem}.c-meta{color:inherit;line-height:1.4;list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.c-meta--large{font-size:1rem}.c-meta--large .c-meta__item{margin-bottom:8px}.c-meta__item{display:inline-block;margin-bottom:4px}.c-meta__item:not(:last-child){border-right:1px solid #d5d5d5;margin-right:4px;padding-right:4px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-meta__item--block-sm-max{display:block}.c-meta__item--block-sm-max:not(:last-child){border-right:none;margin-right:0;padding-right:0}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-meta__item--block-at-lg{display:block}.c-meta__item--block-at-lg:not(:last-child){border-right:none;margin-right:0;padding-right:0}}.c-meta__type{font-weight:700;text-transform:none}.c-skip-link{background:#069;color:#fff;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;inset:0 0 auto;padding:8px;position:absolute;text-align:center;transform:translateY(-100%);z-index:9999}@media (prefers-reduced-motion:reduce){.c-skip-link{transition:top .3s ease-in-out}}@media print{.c-skip-link{display:none}}.c-skip-link:link{color:#fff}.c-status-message{align-items:center;box-sizing:border-box;display:flex;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;position:relative;width:100%}.c-card__summary>p:last-child,.c-status-message :last-child{margin-bottom:0}.c-status-message--boxed{background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #eee;border-radius:2px;line-height:1.4;padding:16px}.c-status-message__heading{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;font-weight:700}.c-status-message__icon{display:inline-block;fill:currentcolor;flex:0 0 auto;height:1.5em;margin-right:8px;transform:translate(0);vertical-align:text-top;width:1.5em}.c-status-message__icon--top{align-self:flex-start}.c-status-message--info .c-status-message__icon{color:#003f8d}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--info{border-bottom:4px solid #003f8d}.c-status-message--error .c-status-message__icon{color:#c40606}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--error{border-bottom:4px solid #c40606}.c-status-message--success .c-status-message__icon{color:#00b8b0}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--success{border-bottom:4px solid #00b8b0}.c-status-message--warning .c-status-message__icon{color:#edbc53}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--warning{border-bottom:4px solid #edbc53}.c-breadcrumbs{color:#000;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.c-breadcrumbs__link{color:#666}svg.c-breadcrumbs__chevron{fill:#888;height:10px;margin:4px 4px 0;width:10px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-breadcrumbs .c-breadcrumbs__item{display:none}.c-breadcrumbs .c-breadcrumbs__item:last-child,.c-breadcrumbs .c-breadcrumbs__item:nth-last-child(2){display:inline}}.c-card{background-color:transparent;border:0;box-shadow:none;display:flex;flex-direction:column;font-size:14px;min-width:0;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:relative}.c-card--no-shape{background:0 0;border:0;box-shadow:none}.c-card__image{display:flex;justify-content:center;overflow:hidden;padding-bottom:56.25%;position:relative}@supports (aspect-ratio:1/1){.c-card__image{aspect-ratio:var(--card--image-aspect-ratio,16/9);padding-bottom:0}}.c-card__image img{left:0;min-height:100%;min-width:100%;position:absolute}@supports ((-o-object-fit:cover) or (object-fit:cover)){.c-card__image img{height:100%;object-fit:cover;width:100%}}.c-card__body{flex:1 1 auto;padding:16px}.c-card--no-shape .c-card__body{padding:0}.c-card--no-shape .c-card__body:not(:first-child){padding-top:16px}.c-card__title{letter-spacing:-.01875rem;margin-bottom:8px;margin-top:0}[lang=de] .c-card__title{hyphens:auto}.c-card__summary{line-height:1.4}.c-card__summary>p{margin-bottom:5px}.c-card__summary a{text-decoration:underline}.c-card__link:not(.c-card__link--no-block-link):before{content:"";inset:0;position:absolute}.c-card--flush .c-card__body{padding:0}.c-card--major{font-size:1rem}.c-card--dark{background-color:#29303c;border-width:0;color:#e3e4e5}.c-card--dark .c-card__title{color:#fff}.c-card--dark .c-card__link,.c-card--dark .c-card__summary a{color:inherit}.c-header{background-color:#fff;border-bottom:5px solid #000;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:16px}.c-header__row{padding:0;position:relative}.c-header__row:not(:last-child){border-bottom:1px solid #eee}.c-header__split{align-items:center;display:flex;justify-content:space-between}.c-header__logo-container{flex:1 1 0px;line-height:0;margin:8px 24px 8px 0}.c-header__logo{transform:translateZ(0)}.c-header__logo img{max-height:32px}.c-header__container{margin:0 auto;max-width:1280px}@media print{.c-header__menu{display:none}}.c-header__menu{align-items:center;display:flex;flex:0 1 auto;flex-wrap:wrap;font-weight:700;gap:8px;line-height:1.4;list-style:none;margin:0 -4px;padding:0}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-header__menu--hide-lg-max{display:none;visibility:hidden}}.c-header__menu--global{font-weight:400;justify-content:flex-end}.c-header__menu--global svg{display:none;visibility:hidden}.c-header__menu--global svg:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__menu--global svg{display:block;visibility:visible}}.c-header__menu--journal{font-size:.875rem;margin:8px 0 8px -8px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__menu--journal{flex-wrap:nowrap;font-size:1rem}}.c-header__item{padding-bottom:0;padding-top:0;position:static}.c-header__item--pipe{border-left:2px solid #eee;padding-left:8px}.c-header__item--padding{padding-bottom:8px;padding-top:8px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__item--dropdown-menu{position:relative}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-header__item--hide-lg{display:none;visibility:hidden}}@media only screen and (max-width:767px){.c-header__item--hide-md-max{display:none;visibility:hidden}.c-header__item--hide-md-max:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}}.c-header__link{align-items:center;color:inherit;display:inline-flex;gap:4px;padding:8px;white-space:nowrap}.c-header__link svg{transition-duration:.2s}.c-header__show-text{display:none;visibility:hidden}.has-tethered .c-header__heading--js-hide:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__show-text{display:inline;visibility:visible}}.c-header__show-text-sm{display:inline;visibility:visible}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__show-text-sm{display:none;visibility:hidden}.c-header__show-text-sm:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}}@media print{.c-header__dropdown{display:none}}.c-header__dropdown{background-color:#000;border-bottom:1px solid #2f2f2f;color:#eee;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.2;padding:16px 0}.c-header__heading{display:inline-block;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1.25rem;font-weight:400;line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:8px}.c-header__heading--keyline{border-top:1px solid;border-color:#2f2f2f;margin-top:16px;padding-top:16px;width:100%}.c-header__list{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:0 16px;list-style:none;margin:0 -8px}.c-header__flush{margin:0 -8px}.c-header__visually-hidden{border:0;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);height:1px;margin:-100%;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute!important;width:1px}.c-header__search-form{margin-bottom:8px}.c-header__search-layout{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:16px}.c-header__search-layout>:first-child{flex:999 1 auto}.c-header__search-layout>*{flex:1 1 auto}.c-header__search-layout--max-width{max-width:720px}.c-header__search-button{align-items:center;background-color:transparent;background-image:none;border:1px solid #fff;border-radius:2px;color:#fff;cursor:pointer;display:flex;font-family:sans-serif;font-size:1rem;justify-content:center;line-height:1.15;margin:0;padding:8px 16px;position:relative;text-decoration:none;transition:.25s,color .25s,border-color .25s;width:100%}.c-header__input,.c-header__select{border:1px solid;border-radius:3px;box-sizing:border-box;font-size:1rem;padding:8px 16px;width:100%}.c-header__select{appearance:none;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg height='16' viewBox='0 0 16 16' width='16' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cpath d='m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z' fill='%23333' fill-rule='evenodd' transform='matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)'/%3E%3C/svg%3E");background-position:right .7em top 50%;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:1em;box-shadow:0 1px 0 1px rgba(0,0,0,.04);display:block;margin:0;max-width:100%;min-width:150px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__menu--journal .c-header__item--dropdown-menu:last-child .c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{left:auto;right:0}}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-header__menu--journal .c-header__item--dropdown-menu:last-child .c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{left:0;right:auto}}.c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{border-bottom:0;border-radius:0 0 2px 2px;left:0;position:absolute;top:100%;transform:translateY(5px);width:100%;z-index:1}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{transform:translateY(8px);width:auto}}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{min-width:225px}}.c-header__dropdown--full-width.has-tethered{padding:32px 0 24px;transform:none;width:100%}.has-tethered .c-header__heading--js-hide{display:none;visibility:hidden}.has-tethered .c-header__list--js-stack{flex-direction:column}.has-tethered .c-header__item--keyline,.has-tethered .c-header__list~.c-header__list .c-header__item:first-child{border-top:1px solid #d5d5d5;margin-top:8px;padding-top:8px}.c-header__item--snid-account-widget{display:flex}.c-header__container{padding:0 4px}.c-header__list{padding:0 12px}.c-header__menu .c-header__link{font-size:14px}.c-header__item--snid-account-widget .c-header__link{padding:8px}.c-header__menu--journal{margin-left:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__container{padding:0 16px}.c-header__menu--journal{margin-left:-8px}.c-header__menu .c-header__link{font-size:16px}.c-header__link--search{gap:13px}}.u-button{align-items:center;background-color:transparent;background-image:none;border-radius:2px;cursor:pointer;display:inline-flex;font-family:sans-serif;font-size:1rem;justify-content:center;line-height:1.3;margin:0;padding:8px;position:relative;text-decoration:none;transition:.25s,color .25s,border-color .25s;width:auto}.u-button svg,.u-button--primary svg{fill:currentcolor}.u-button{border:1px solid #069;color:#069}.u-button--primary{background-color:#069;background-image:none;border:1px solid #069;color:#fff}.u-button--full-width{display:flex;width:100%}.u-display-none{display:none}.js .u-js-hide,.u-hide{display:none;visibility:hidden}.u-hide:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}.u-visually-hidden{border:0;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);height:1px;margin:-100%;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute!important;width:1px}@media print{.u-hide-print{display:none}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.u-hide-at-lg{display:none;visibility:hidden}.u-hide-at-lg:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}}.u-clearfix:after,.u-clearfix:before{content:"";display:table}.u-clearfix:after{clear:both}.u-color-open-access{color:#b74616}.u-float-left{float:left}.u-icon{display:inline-block;fill:currentcolor;height:1em;transform:translate(0);vertical-align:text-top;width:1em}.u-full-height{height:100%}.u-link-inherit{color:inherit}.u-list-reset{list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.u-text-bold{font-weight:700}.u-container{margin:0 auto;max-width:1280px;padding:0 16px}.u-justify-content-space-between{justify-content:space-between}.u-mt-32{margin-top:32px}.u-mb-8{margin-bottom:8px}.u-mb-16{margin-bottom:16px}.u-mb-24{margin-bottom:24px}.u-mb-32{margin-bottom:32px}.u-mb-48{margin-bottom:48px}.u-pa-16{padding:16px}html *,html :after,html :before{box-sizing:inherit}.c-article-section__title,.c-article-title{font-weight:700}.c-card__title{line-height:1.4em}.c-article__button{background-color:#069;border:1px solid #069;border-radius:2px;color:#fff;display:flex;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:16px;padding:13px;transition:background-color .2s ease-out,color .2s ease-out}.c-article__button,.c-article__button:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-article__button--inverted,.c-article__button:hover{background-color:#fff;color:#069}.c-article__button--inverted:hover{background-color:#069;color:#fff}.c-header__link{text-decoration:inherit}.grade-c-hide{display:block}.c-pdf-download__link{padding:13px 24px} } </style>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<link data-test="critical-css-handler" data-inline-css-source="critical-css" rel="stylesheet" href="/static/css/enhanced-article-8977e6e825.css" media="print" onload="this.media='only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark)';this.onload=null">
|
||
|
||
<noscript>
|
||
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/static/css/enhanced-article-8977e6e825.css" media="only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark)">
|
||
</noscript>
|
||
|
||
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/static/css/article-print-58da41a5fd.css" media="print">
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/apple-touch-icon-f39cb19454.png>
|
||
<link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="48x48" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon-48x48-b52890008c.png>
|
||
<link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="32x32" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon-32x32-3fe59ece92.png>
|
||
<link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="16x16" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon-16x16-951651ab72.png>
|
||
<link rel="manifest" href=/static/manifest.json crossorigin="use-credentials">
|
||
<link rel="mask-icon" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/safari-pinned-tab-619cea1bcb.svg color="#000000">
|
||
<link rel="shortcut icon" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon.ico>
|
||
<meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#000000">
|
||
<meta name="msapplication-config" content=/static/browserconfig.xml>
|
||
<meta name="theme-color" content="#000000">
|
||
<meta name="application-name" content="Nature">
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
(function () {
|
||
if ( typeof window.CustomEvent === "function" ) return false;
|
||
function CustomEvent ( event, params ) {
|
||
params = params || { bubbles: false, cancelable: false, detail: null };
|
||
var evt = document.createEvent( 'CustomEvent' );
|
||
evt.initCustomEvent( event, params.bubbles, params.cancelable, params.detail );
|
||
return evt;
|
||
}
|
||
|
||
CustomEvent.prototype = window.Event.prototype;
|
||
|
||
window.CustomEvent = CustomEvent;
|
||
})();
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
(function (w, d, s) {
|
||
var urlParams = new URLSearchParams(w.location.search);
|
||
if (urlParams.get('gptAdsTest') !== null) {
|
||
d.addEventListener('sncc:initialise', function (e) {
|
||
var t = d.createElement(s);
|
||
var h = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
|
||
t.src = 'https://' + (e.detail.C03 ? 'securepubads.g.doubleclick' : 'pagead2.googlesyndication') + '.net/tag/js/gpt.js';
|
||
t.async = false;
|
||
t.onload = function () {
|
||
var n = d.createElement(s);
|
||
n.src = 'https://fed-libs.nature.com/production/gpt-ads-gtm.min.js';
|
||
n.async = false;
|
||
h.insertAdjacentElement('afterend', n);
|
||
};
|
||
h.insertAdjacentElement('afterend', t);
|
||
})
|
||
}
|
||
})(window, document, 'script');
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
<!-- Google Tag Manager -->
|
||
<script data-test="gtm-head">
|
||
window.initGTM = function() {
|
||
if (window.config.mustardcut) {
|
||
(function (w, d, s, l, i) {
|
||
w[l] = w[l] || [];
|
||
w[l].push({'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(), event: 'gtm.js'});
|
||
var f = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],
|
||
j = d.createElement(s),
|
||
dl = l != 'dataLayer' ? '&l=' + l : '';
|
||
j.async = true;
|
||
j.src = 'https://sgtm.nature.com/gtm.js?id=' + i + dl;
|
||
f.parentNode.insertBefore(j, f);
|
||
})(window, document, 'script', 'dataLayer', 'GTM-MRVXSHQ');
|
||
}
|
||
}
|
||
</script>
|
||
<!-- End Google Tag Manager -->
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
(function(w,d,t) {
|
||
function cc() {
|
||
var h = w.location.hostname;
|
||
if (h === 'preview-www.nature.com') return;
|
||
var e = d.createElement(t),
|
||
s = d.getElementsByTagName(t)[0];
|
||
e.setAttribute('crossorigin', 'anonymous');
|
||
if (h === 'nature.com' || h.endsWith('.nature.com')) {
|
||
e.src = 'https://cmp.nature.com/production_live/en/consent-bundle-8-102.js';
|
||
e.setAttribute('onload', "initGTM(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-MRVXSHQ')");
|
||
} else {
|
||
e.src = '/static/js/cookie-consent-es5-bundle-0b812e7bd9.js';
|
||
e.setAttribute('data-consent', h);
|
||
}
|
||
s.insertAdjacentElement('afterend', e);
|
||
}
|
||
cc();
|
||
})(window,document,'script');
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script id="js-position0">
|
||
(function(w, d) {
|
||
w.idpVerifyPrefix = 'https://verify.nature.com';
|
||
w.ra21Host = 'https://wayf.springernature.com';
|
||
var moduleSupport = (function() {
|
||
return 'noModule' in d.createElement('script');
|
||
})();
|
||
|
||
if (w.config.mustardcut === true) {
|
||
w.loader = {
|
||
index: 0,
|
||
registered: [],
|
||
scripts: [
|
||
|
||
{src: '/static/js/global-article-es6-bundle-54b91fc987.js', test: 'global-article-js', module: true},
|
||
{src: '/static/js/global-article-es5-bundle-010ea37a83.js', test: 'global-article-js', nomodule: true},
|
||
{src: '/static/js/shared-es6-bundle-3aa6baa481.js', test: 'shared-js', module: true},
|
||
{src: '/static/js/shared-es5-bundle-8fc015859c.js', test: 'shared-js', nomodule: true},
|
||
{src: '/static/js/header-150-es6-bundle-a3d441cf1b.js', test: 'header-150-js', module: true},
|
||
{src: '/static/js/header-150-es5-bundle-5080ac4398.js', test: 'header-150-js', nomodule: true}
|
||
|
||
].filter(function (s) {
|
||
if (s.src === null) return false;
|
||
if (moduleSupport && s.nomodule) return false;
|
||
return !(!moduleSupport && s.module);
|
||
}),
|
||
|
||
register: function (value) {
|
||
this.registered.push(value);
|
||
},
|
||
|
||
ready: function () {
|
||
if (this.registered.length === this.scripts.length) {
|
||
this.registered.forEach(function (fn) {
|
||
if (typeof fn === 'function') {
|
||
setTimeout(fn, 0);
|
||
}
|
||
});
|
||
this.ready = function () {};
|
||
}
|
||
},
|
||
|
||
insert: function (s) {
|
||
var t = d.getElementById('js-position' + this.index);
|
||
if (t && t.insertAdjacentElement) {
|
||
t.insertAdjacentElement('afterend', s);
|
||
} else {
|
||
d.head.appendChild(s);
|
||
}
|
||
++this.index;
|
||
},
|
||
|
||
createScript: function (script, beforeLoad) {
|
||
var s = d.createElement('script');
|
||
s.id = 'js-position' + (this.index + 1);
|
||
s.setAttribute('data-test', script.test);
|
||
if (beforeLoad) {
|
||
s.defer = 'defer';
|
||
s.onload = function () {
|
||
if (script.noinit) {
|
||
loader.register(true);
|
||
}
|
||
if (d.readyState === 'interactive' || d.readyState === 'complete') {
|
||
loader.ready();
|
||
}
|
||
};
|
||
} else {
|
||
s.async = 'async';
|
||
}
|
||
s.src = script.src;
|
||
return s;
|
||
},
|
||
|
||
init: function () {
|
||
this.scripts.forEach(function (s) {
|
||
loader.insert(loader.createScript(s, true));
|
||
});
|
||
|
||
d.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function () {
|
||
loader.ready();
|
||
var conditionalScripts;
|
||
|
||
conditionalScripts = [
|
||
{match: 'div[data-pan-container]', src: '/static/js/pan-zoom-es6-bundle-9055a10868.js', test: 'pan-zoom-js', module: true },
|
||
{match: 'div[data-pan-container]', src: '/static/js/pan-zoom-es5-bundle-9055a10868.js', test: 'pan-zoom-js', nomodule: true },
|
||
{match: 'math,span.mathjax-tex', src: '/static/js/math-es6-bundle-46c5b808b1.js', test: 'math-js', module: true},
|
||
{match: 'math,span.mathjax-tex', src: '/static/js/math-es5-bundle-46c5b808b1.js', test: 'math-js', nomodule: true}
|
||
];
|
||
|
||
|
||
if (conditionalScripts) {
|
||
conditionalScripts.filter(function (script) {
|
||
return !!document.querySelector(script.match) && !((moduleSupport && script.nomodule) || (!moduleSupport && script.module));
|
||
}).forEach(function (script) {
|
||
loader.insert(loader.createScript(script));
|
||
});
|
||
}
|
||
}, false);
|
||
}
|
||
};
|
||
loader.init();
|
||
}
|
||
})(window, document);
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<meta name="access" content="Yes">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<link rel="search" href="https://www.nature.com/search">
|
||
<link rel="search" href="https://www.nature.com/opensearch/opensearch.xml" type="application/opensearchdescription+xml" title="nature.com">
|
||
<link rel="search" href="https://www.nature.com/opensearch/request" type="application/sru+xml" title="nature.com">
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script type="application/ld+json">{"mainEntity":{"headline":"AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting","description":"Advances in generative artificial intelligence show great potential for improving education. Yet little is known about how this new technology should be used and how effective it can be compared to current best practices. Here we report a randomized, controlled trial measuring college students’ learning and their perceptions when content is presented through an AI-powered tutor compared with an active learning class. The novel design of the custom AI tutor is informed by the same pedagogical best practices as employed in the in-class lessons. We find that students learn significantly more in less time when using the AI tutor, compared with the in-class active learning. They also feel more engaged and more motivated. These findings offer empirical evidence for the efficacy of a widely accessible AI-powered pedagogy in significantly enhancing learning outcomes, presenting a compelling case for its broad adoption in learning environments.","datePublished":"2025-06-03T00:00:00Z","dateModified":"2025-06-03T00:00:00Z","pageStart":"1","pageEnd":"10","license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/","sameAs":"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6","keywords":["Applied physics","Learning and memory","Mathematics and computing","Physics","Psychology","Science","Humanities and Social Sciences","multidisciplinary"],"image":["https://media.springernature.com/lw1200/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig1_HTML.png","https://media.springernature.com/lw1200/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig2_HTML.png","https://media.springernature.com/lw1200/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig3_HTML.png"],"isPartOf":{"name":"Scientific Reports","issn":["2045-2322"],"volumeNumber":"15","@type":["Periodical","PublicationVolume"]},"publisher":{"name":"Nature Publishing Group UK","logo":{"url":"https://www.springernature.com/app-sn/public/images/logo-springernature.png","@type":"ImageObject"},"@type":"Organization"},"author":[{"name":"Greg Kestin","affiliation":[{"name":"Harvard University","address":{"name":"Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"email":"Kestin@fas.Harvard.edu","@type":"Person"},{"name":"Kelly Miller","affiliation":[{"name":"Harvard University","address":{"name":"School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"},{"name":"Anna Klales","affiliation":[{"name":"Harvard University","address":{"name":"Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"},{"name":"Timothy Milbourne","affiliation":[{"name":"Harvard University","address":{"name":"Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"},{"name":"Gregorio Ponti","affiliation":[{"name":"Harvard University","address":{"name":"Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"}],"isAccessibleForFree":true,"@type":"ScholarlyArticle"},"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"WebPage"}</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<link rel="canonical" href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-97652-6">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<meta name="journal_id" content="41598"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.title" content="AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.source" content="Scientific Reports 2025 15:1"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.format" content="text/html"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.publisher" content="Nature Publishing Group"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.date" content="2025-06-03"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.type" content="OriginalPaper"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.language" content="En"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.copyright" content="2025 The Author(s)"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.rights" content="2025 The Author(s)"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.rightsAgent" content="journalpermissions@springernature.com"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.description" content="Advances in generative artificial intelligence show great potential for improving education. Yet little is known about how this new technology should be used and how effective it can be compared to current best practices. Here we report a randomized, controlled trial measuring college students’ learning and their perceptions when content is presented through an AI-powered tutor compared with an active learning class. The novel design of the custom AI tutor is informed by the same pedagogical best practices as employed in the in-class lessons. We find that students learn significantly more in less time when using the AI tutor, compared with the in-class active learning. They also feel more engaged and more motivated. These findings offer empirical evidence for the efficacy of a widely accessible AI-powered pedagogy in significantly enhancing learning outcomes, presenting a compelling case for its broad adoption in learning environments."/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.issn" content="2045-2322"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.publicationName" content="Scientific Reports"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.publicationDate" content="2025-06-03"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.volume" content="15"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.number" content="1"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.section" content="OriginalPaper"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.startingPage" content="17458"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.endingPage" content=""/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.copyright" content="2025 The Author(s)"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.rightsAgent" content="journalpermissions@springernature.com"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta name="prism.doi" content="doi:10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_pdf_url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-97652-6.pdf"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_fulltext_html_url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_journal_title" content="Scientific Reports"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_journal_abbrev" content="Sci Rep"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_publisher" content="Nature Publishing Group"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_issn" content="2045-2322"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_title" content="AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_volume" content="15"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_issue" content="1"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_online_date" content="2025/06/03"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_firstpage" content="17458"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_lastpage" content=""/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_article_type" content="Article"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_fulltext_world_readable" content=""/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_language" content="en"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.identifier" content="doi:10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta name="DOI" content="10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta name="size" content="110462"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_doi" content="10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_springer_api_url" content="http://api.springer.com/xmldata/jats?q=doi:10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6&api_key="/>
|
||
<meta name="description" content="Advances in generative artificial intelligence show great potential for improving education. Yet little is known about how this new technology should be used and how effective it can be compared to current best practices. Here we report a randomized, controlled trial measuring college students’ learning and their perceptions when content is presented through an AI-powered tutor compared with an active learning class. The novel design of the custom AI tutor is informed by the same pedagogical best practices as employed in the in-class lessons. We find that students learn significantly more in less time when using the AI tutor, compared with the in-class active learning. They also feel more engaged and more motivated. These findings offer empirical evidence for the efficacy of a widely accessible AI-powered pedagogy in significantly enhancing learning outcomes, presenting a compelling case for its broad adoption in learning environments."/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.creator" content="Kestin, Greg"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.creator" content="Miller, Kelly"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.creator" content="Klales, Anna"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.creator" content="Milbourne, Timothy"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.creator" content="Ponti, Gregorio"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.subject" content="Applied physics"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.subject" content="Learning and memory"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.subject" content="Mathematics and computing"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.subject" content="Physics"/>
|
||
<meta name="dc.subject" content="Psychology"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Singer, N. Will chatbots teach your children? New York Times
|
||
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-education-tutoring.html
|
||
|
||
(2024)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Forero, M. G. & Herrera-Suárez, H. J. ChatGPT in the classroom: boon or bane for physics students’ academic performance? Preprint at
|
||
arXiv:2312.02422
|
||
|
||
(2023)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Kumar, H., Rothschild, D. M., Goldstein, D. G., & Hofman, J. M. Math education with large language models: peril or promise? SSRN
|
||
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4641653
|
||
|
||
(2023)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Sweller, J. Cognitive load theory. In The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Cognition in Education (eds Mestre, J. P. & Ross, B. H.) 37–76 (Elsevier Academic Press, 2011)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res.; citation_title=Could an artificial-intelligence agent pass an introductory physics course?; citation_author=G Kortemeyer; citation_volume=19; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2023; citation_doi=10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.19.010132; citation_id=CR5"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Phys. Rev. Spec. Top.-Phys. Educ. Res.; citation_title=Barriers to the use of research-based instructional strategies: The influence of both individual and situational characteristics; citation_author=C Henderson, MH Dancy; citation_volume=3; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_doi=10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.3.020102; citation_id=CR6"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Science; citation_title=Anatomy of STEM teaching in North American universities; citation_author=M Stains, J Harshman, MK Barker, SV Chasteen, R Cole, SE DeChenne-Peters, MK Eagan, JM Esson, JK Knight, FA Laski, M Levis-Fitzgerald; citation_volume=359; citation_issue=6383; citation_publication_date=2018; citation_pages=1468-1470; citation_doi=10.1126/science.aap8892; citation_id=CR7"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Science; citation_title=Scientific teaching; citation_author=J Handelsman; citation_volume=304; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=521-522; citation_doi=10.1126/science.1096022; citation_id=CR8"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. J. Phys.; citation_title=Interactive-engagement vs. traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses; citation_author=RR Hake; citation_volume=66; citation_publication_date=1998; citation_pages=64-74; citation_doi=10.1119/1.18809; citation_id=CR9"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. J. Phys.; citation_title=Peer instruction: Ten years of experience and results; citation_author=CH Crouch, E Mazur; citation_volume=69; citation_publication_date=2001; citation_pages=970-977; citation_doi=10.1119/1.1374249; citation_id=CR10"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Science; citation_title=Improved learning in a large-enrollment physics class; citation_author=L Deslauriers, E Schelew, C Wieman; citation_volume=332; citation_publication_date=2011; citation_pages=862-864; citation_doi=10.1126/science.1201783; citation_id=CR11"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.; citation_title=Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics; citation_author=S Freeman; citation_volume=111; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=8410-8415; citation_doi=10.1073/pnas.1319030111; citation_id=CR12"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Rep. Prog. Phys.; citation_title=Teaching and physics education research: Bridging the gap; citation_author=JM Fraser; citation_volume=77; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_doi=10.1088/0034-4885/77/3/032401; citation_id=CR13"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Phys. Rev. ST Phys. Educ. Res.; citation_title=Comparing the force and motion conceptual evaluation and the force concept inventory; citation_author=RK Thornton, D Kuhl, K Cummings, J Marx; citation_volume=5; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_doi=10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.5.010105; citation_id=CR14"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Educ. Res.; citation_title=The 2 sigma problem: The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring; citation_author=BS Bloom; citation_volume=13; citation_issue=6; citation_publication_date=1984; citation_pages=4-16; citation_doi=10.3102/0013189X013006004; citation_id=CR15"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_title=Mindset: The New Psychology of Success; citation_publication_date=2006; citation_id=CR16; citation_author=CS Dweck; citation_publisher=Random house"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Psychol.; citation_title=What can be learned from growth mindset controversies?; citation_author=DS Yeager, CS Dweck; citation_volume=75; citation_issue=9; citation_publication_date=2020; citation_pages=1269; citation_doi=10.1037/amp0000794; citation_id=CR17"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Phys. Teach.; citation_title=Force concept inventory; citation_author=D Hestenes, M Wells, G Swackhamer; citation_volume=30; citation_issue=3; citation_publication_date=1992; citation_pages=141-158; citation_doi=10.1119/1.2343497; citation_id=CR18"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Rev. Educ. Res.; citation_title=School engagement: Potential of the concept, state of the evidence; citation_author=JA Fredricks, PC Blumenfeld, AH Paris; citation_volume=74; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=59-109; citation_doi=10.3102/00346543074001059; citation_id=CR19"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry; citation_title=The role of tutoring in problem-solving; citation_author=D Wood, JS Bruner, G Ross; citation_volume=17; citation_issue=2; citation_publication_date=1976; citation_pages=89-100; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1469-7610.1976.tb00381.x; citation_id=CR20"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Rev. Educ. Res.; citation_title=Focus on formative feedback; citation_author=VJ Shute; citation_volume=78; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=153-189; citation_doi=10.3102/0034654307313795; citation_id=CR21"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Tatum, B. C. & Lenel, J. C. A Comparison of self-paced and lecture/discussion methods in an accelerated learning format. J. Res. Innov. Teach. 5(1), (2012)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=BioData Min.; citation_title=ChatGPT and large language models in academia: Opportunities and challenges; citation_author=JG Meyer, RJ Urbanowicz, PCN Martin, K O'Connor, R Li, P-C Peng, TJ Bright, N Tatonetti, KJ Won, G Gonzalez-Hernandez, JH Moore; citation_volume=16; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2023; citation_pages=20-20; citation_doi=10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9; citation_id=CR23"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Nye, M. et al. Show your work: Scratchpads for intermediate computation with language models.
|
||
arXiv:2112.00114
|
||
|
||
(2021)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Krupp, L., Steinert, S., Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, M., Avila, K. E., Lukowicz, P., Kuhn, J., Küchemann, S., & Karolus, J., Unreflected acceptance—investigating the negative consequences of ChatGPT-assisted problem solving in physics education. In HHAI 2024: Hybrid Human AI Systems for the Social Good, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications, Vol. 386, 199–212. IOS Press (2024)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="Clark, R. C. & Mayer, R. E. e-Learning and the science of instruction. In E-learning and the Science of Instruction: Proven Guidelines for Consumers and Designers of Multimedia Learning. Center for Creative Leadership (2011)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Phys. Teach.; citation_title=Do they stay fixed?; citation_author=GE Francis, JP Adams, EJ Noonan; citation_volume=36; citation_publication_date=1998; citation_pages=488-490; citation_doi=10.1119/1.879933; citation_id=CR27"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. J. Phys.; citation_title=Improving the preparation of K-12 teachers through physics education research; citation_author=LC McDermott, PRL Heron, PS Shaffer, MS Stetzer; citation_volume=74; citation_publication_date=2006; citation_pages=763-767; citation_doi=10.1119/1.2209244; citation_id=CR28"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. J. Phys.; citation_title=Comparing large lecture mechanics curricula using the Force Concept Inventory: A five thousand student study; citation_author=MD Caballero; citation_volume=80; citation_issue=7; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=638-644; citation_doi=10.1119/1.3703517; citation_id=CR29"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. J. Phys.; citation_title=Interactive-engagement versus traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses; citation_author=RR Hake; citation_volume=66; citation_publication_date=1998; citation_pages=64-74; citation_doi=10.1119/1.18809; citation_id=CR30"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=AIP Conf. Proc.; citation_title=Correlating student beliefs with student learning using the Colorado learning attitudes about science survey; citation_author=KK Perkins, WK Adams, SJ Pollock, ND Finkelstein, CE Wieman; citation_volume=790; citation_publication_date=2005; citation_pages=61-64; citation_doi=10.1063/1.2084701; citation_id=CR31"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="McCarty, L. S. & Deslauriers, L. Transforming a large university physics course to student-centered learning, without sacrificing content: A case study. In The Routledge International Handbook of Student-Centered Learning and Teaching in Higher Education, 186–200 (Routledge, 2020)."/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res.; citation_title=Increasing the effectiveness of active learning using deliberate practice: A homework transformation; citation_author=K Miller, K Callaghan, LS McCarty, L Deslauriers; citation_volume=17; citation_issue=1; citation_publication_date=2021; citation_pages=010129; citation_doi=10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010129; citation_id=CR33"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.; citation_title=Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics; citation_author=S Freeman, SL Eddy, M McDonough, MK Smith, N Okoroafor, H Jordt, MP Wenderoth; citation_volume=111; citation_issue=23; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=8410-8415; citation_doi=10.1073/pnas.1319030111; citation_id=CR34"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.; citation_title=Measuring actual learning versus feeling of learning in response to being actively engaged in the classroom; citation_author=L Deslauriers, LS McCarty, K Miller, K Callaghan, G Kestin; citation_volume=116; citation_issue=39; citation_publication_date=2019; citation_pages=19251-19257; citation_doi=10.1073/pnas.1821936116; citation_id=CR35"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author" content="Kestin, Greg"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author_institution" content="Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author" content="Miller, Kelly"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author_institution" content="School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author" content="Klales, Anna"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author_institution" content="Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author" content="Milbourne, Timothy"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author_institution" content="Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author" content="Ponti, Gregorio"/>
|
||
<meta name="citation_author_institution" content="Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA"/>
|
||
<meta name="access_endpoint" content="https://www.nature.com/platform/readcube-access"/>
|
||
<meta name="twitter:site" content="@SciReports"/>
|
||
<meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/>
|
||
<meta name="twitter:image:alt" content="Content cover image"/>
|
||
<meta name="twitter:title" content="AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting"/>
|
||
<meta name="twitter:description" content="Scientific Reports - AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting"/>
|
||
<meta name="twitter:image" content="https://media.springernature.com/full/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig1_HTML.png"/>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<meta property="og:url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-97652-6"/>
|
||
<meta property="og:type" content="article"/>
|
||
<meta property="og:site_name" content="Nature"/>
|
||
<meta property="og:title" content="AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting - Scientific Reports"/>
|
||
<meta property="og:image" content="https://media.springernature.com/m685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig1_HTML.png"/>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
window.eligibleForRa21 = 'false';
|
||
</script>
|
||
</head>
|
||
<body class="article-page">
|
||
|
||
<div class="position-relative cleared z-index-50 background-white" data-test="top-containers">
|
||
<a class="c-skip-link" href="#content">Skip to main content</a>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-grade-c-banner u-hide">
|
||
<div class="c-grade-c-banner__container">
|
||
|
||
<p>Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain
|
||
the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in
|
||
Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles
|
||
and JavaScript.</p>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="u-hide u-show-following-ad"></div>
|
||
|
||
<aside class="c-ad c-ad--728x90">
|
||
<div class="c-ad__inner" data-container-type="banner-advert">
|
||
<p class="c-ad__label">Advertisement</p>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div id="div-gpt-ad-top-1"
|
||
class="div-gpt-ad advert leaderboard js-ad text-center hide-print grade-c-hide"
|
||
data-ad-type="top"
|
||
data-test="top-ad"
|
||
data-pa11y-ignore
|
||
data-gpt
|
||
data-gpt-unitpath="/285/scientific_reports/article"
|
||
data-gpt-sizes="728x90"
|
||
data-gpt-targeting="type=article;pos=top;artid=s41598-025-97652-6;doi=10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6;subjmeta=1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766;kwrd=Applied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology">
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
window.SN = window.SN || {};
|
||
window.SN.libs = window.SN.libs || {};
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads = window.SN.libs.ads || {};
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig = window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig || {};
|
||
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig['top'] = {
|
||
'pos': 'top',
|
||
'type': 'article',
|
||
'path': 's41598-025-97652-6'
|
||
};
|
||
|
||
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig['kwrd'] = 'Applied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology';
|
||
|
||
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig['subjmeta'] = '1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766';
|
||
|
||
|
||
</script>
|
||
<noscript>
|
||
<a href="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?iu=/285/scientific_reports/article&sz=728x90&c=574858763&t=pos%3Dtop%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41598-025-97652-6%26doi%3D10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6%26subjmeta%3D1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766%26kwrd%3DApplied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology">
|
||
<img data-test="gpt-advert-fallback-img"
|
||
src="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ad?iu=/285/scientific_reports/article&sz=728x90&c=574858763&t=pos%3Dtop%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41598-025-97652-6%26doi%3D10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6%26subjmeta%3D1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766%26kwrd%3DApplied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology"
|
||
alt="Advertisement"
|
||
width="728"
|
||
height="90"></a>
|
||
</noscript>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</aside>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<header class="c-header" id="header" data-header data-track-component="nature-150-split-header" style="border-color:#cedde4">
|
||
<div class="c-header__row">
|
||
<div class="c-header__container">
|
||
<div class="c-header__split">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-header__logo-container">
|
||
|
||
<a href="/srep"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="home" data-track-label="image">
|
||
<picture class="c-header__logo">
|
||
<source srcset="https://media.springernature.com/full/nature-cms/uploads/product/srep/header-d3c533c187c710c1bedbd8e293815d5f.svg" media="(min-width: 875px)">
|
||
<img src="https://media.springernature.com/full/nature-cms/uploads/product/srep/header-d3c533c187c710c1bedbd8e293815d5f.svg" height="32" alt="Scientific Reports">
|
||
</picture>
|
||
</a>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<ul class="c-header__menu c-header__menu--global">
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--padding c-header__item--hide-md-max">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link" href="https://www.nature.com/siteindex" data-test="siteindex-link"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="open nature research index" data-track-label="link">
|
||
<span>View all journals</span>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--padding c-header__item--pipe">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link c-header__link--search"
|
||
href="#search-menu"
|
||
data-header-expander
|
||
data-test="search-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="open search tray" data-track-label="button">
|
||
<svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="22" width="22" viewBox="0 0 18 18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="M16.48 15.455c.283.282.29.749.007 1.032a.738.738 0 01-1.032-.007l-3.045-3.044a7 7 0 111.026-1.026zM8 14A6 6 0 108 2a6 6 0 000 12z"/></svg><span>Search</span>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--padding c-header__item--snid-account-widget c-header__item--pipe">
|
||
|
||
<a class="c-header__link eds-c-header__link" id="identity-account-widget" data-track="click_login" data-track-context="header" href='https://idp.nature.com/auth/personal/springernature?redirect_uri=https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-97652-6?error=cookies_not_supported&code=28e792cb-5ff6-47a6-8fb2-b8a5645728da'><span class="eds-c-header__widget-fragment-title">Log in</span></a>
|
||
|
||
</li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-header__row">
|
||
<div class="c-header__container" data-test="navigation-row">
|
||
<div class="c-header__split">
|
||
<ul class="c-header__menu c-header__menu--journal">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--dropdown-menu" data-test="explore-content-button">
|
||
<a href="#explore"
|
||
class="c-header__link"
|
||
data-header-expander
|
||
data-test="menu-button--explore"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="open explore expander" data-track-label="button">
|
||
<span class="c-header__show-text-sm">Content</span>
|
||
<span class="c-header__show-text">Explore content</span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" width="16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--dropdown-menu">
|
||
<a href="#about-the-journal"
|
||
class="c-header__link"
|
||
data-header-expander
|
||
data-test="menu-button--about-the-journal"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="open about the journal expander" data-track-label="button">
|
||
<span>About <span class="c-header__show-text">the journal</span></span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" width="16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--dropdown-menu" data-test="publish-with-us-button">
|
||
<a href="#publish-with-us"
|
||
class="c-header__link c-header__link--dropdown-menu"
|
||
data-header-expander
|
||
data-test="menu-button--publish"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="open publish with us expander" data-track-label="button">
|
||
<span>Publish <span class="c-header__show-text">with us</span></span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" width="16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
<ul class="c-header__menu c-header__menu--hide-lg-max">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item" data-test="alert-link">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://journal-alerts.springernature.com/subscribe?journal_id=41598"
|
||
rel="nofollow"
|
||
data-track="nav_sign_up_for_alerts"
|
||
data-track-action="Sign up for alerts"
|
||
data-track-label="link (desktop site header)"
|
||
data-track-external>
|
||
<span>Sign up for alerts</span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="18" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m4 10h2.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-3.08578644l-1.12132034 1.1213203c-.18753638.1875364-.29289322.4418903-.29289322.7071068v.1715729h14v-.1715729c0-.2652165-.1053568-.5195704-.2928932-.7071068l-1.7071068-1.7071067v-3.4142136c0-2.76142375-2.2385763-5-5-5-2.76142375 0-5 2.23857625-5 5zm3 4c0 1.1045695.8954305 2 2 2s2-.8954305 2-2zm-5 0c-.55228475 0-1-.4477153-1-1v-.1715729c0-.530433.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.4142135l1.41421356-1.4142136v-3c0-3.3137085 2.6862915-6 6-6s6 2.6862915 6 6v3l1.4142136 1.4142136c.3750727.3750727.5857864.8837805.5857864 1.4142135v.1715729c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1h-4c0 1.6568542-1.3431458 3-3 3-1.65685425 0-3-1.3431458-3-3z" fill="#222"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--pipe">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/srep.rss"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="rss feed"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
<span>RSS feed</span>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</header>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<nav class="u-mb-16" aria-label="breadcrumbs">
|
||
<div class="u-container">
|
||
<ol class="c-breadcrumbs" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/BreadcrumbList">
|
||
<li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb0" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="c-breadcrumbs__link"
|
||
href="/" itemprop="item"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="breadcrumb" data-track-category="header" data-track-label="link:nature"><span itemprop="name">nature</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="1">
|
||
<svg class="c-breadcrumbs__chevron" role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="10" viewBox="0 0 10 10" width="10"
|
||
xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
|
||
<path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z"
|
||
fill="#666" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/>
|
||
</svg>
|
||
</li><li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb1" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="c-breadcrumbs__link"
|
||
href="/srep" itemprop="item"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="breadcrumb" data-track-category="header" data-track-label="link:scientific reports"><span itemprop="name">scientific reports</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="2">
|
||
<svg class="c-breadcrumbs__chevron" role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="10" viewBox="0 0 10 10" width="10"
|
||
xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
|
||
<path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z"
|
||
fill="#666" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/>
|
||
</svg>
|
||
</li><li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb2" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="c-breadcrumbs__link"
|
||
href="/srep/articles?type=article" itemprop="item"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="breadcrumb" data-track-category="header" data-track-label="link:articles"><span itemprop="name">articles</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="3">
|
||
<svg class="c-breadcrumbs__chevron" role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="10" viewBox="0 0 10 10" width="10"
|
||
xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
|
||
<path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z"
|
||
fill="#666" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/>
|
||
</svg>
|
||
</li><li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb3" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem">
|
||
<span itemprop="name">article</span><meta itemprop="position" content="4"></li>
|
||
</ol>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</nav>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="u-container u-mt-32 u-mb-32 u-clearfix" id="content" data-component="article-container" data-container-type="article">
|
||
<main class="c-article-main-column u-float-left js-main-column" data-track-component="article body">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-context-bar u-hide"
|
||
id="js-enable-context-bar"
|
||
data-test="context-bar"
|
||
data-context-bar
|
||
aria-hidden="true">
|
||
<div class="c-context-bar__container" data-track-context="sticky banner">
|
||
<div class="c-context-bar__title">
|
||
AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div class="c-context-bar__cta-container">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-pdf-download u-clear-both js-pdf-download">
|
||
<a href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6.pdf" class="u-button u-button--full-width u-button--primary u-justify-content-space-between c-pdf-download__link" data-article-pdf="true" data-readcube-pdf-url="true" data-test="download-pdf" data-draft-ignore="true" data-track="content_download" data-track-type="article pdf download" data-track-action="download pdf" data-track-label="link" data-track-external download>
|
||
<span class="c-pdf-download__text">Download PDF</span>
|
||
<svg aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" width="16" height="16" class="u-icon"><use xlink:href="#icon-download"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<article lang="en">
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-pdf-button__container u-mb-8 u-hide-at-lg js-context-bar-sticky-point-mobile">
|
||
<div class="c-pdf-container" data-track-context="article body">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="app-cta-group">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-pdf-download u-clear-both js-pdf-download">
|
||
<a href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6.pdf" class="u-button u-button--full-width u-button--primary u-justify-content-space-between c-pdf-download__link" data-article-pdf="true" data-readcube-pdf-url="true" data-test="download-pdf" data-draft-ignore="true" data-track="content_download" data-track-type="article pdf download" data-track-action="download pdf" data-track-label="link" data-track-external download>
|
||
<span class="c-pdf-download__text">Download PDF</span>
|
||
<svg aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" width="16" height="16" class="u-icon"><use xlink:href="#icon-download"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-header">
|
||
<header>
|
||
<ul class="c-article-identifiers" data-test="article-identifier">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-identifiers__item" data-test="article-category">Article</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-identifiers__item">
|
||
<a href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/open-science/about/the-fundamentals-of-open-access-and-open-research" data-track="click" data-track-action="open access" data-track-label="link" class="u-color-open-access" data-test="open-access">Open access</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-identifiers__item">Published: <time datetime="2025-06-03">03 June 2025</time></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
|
||
<h1 class="c-article-title" data-test="article-title" data-article-title="">AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting</h1>
|
||
<ul class="c-article-author-list c-article-author-list--short" data-test="authors-list" data-component-authors-activator="authors-list"><li class="c-article-author-list__item"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" data-track-index="1_5" data-track-context="researcher popup with no profile" href="#auth-Greg-Kestin-Aff1" data-author-popup="auth-Greg-Kestin-Aff1" data-author-search="Kestin, Greg" data-corresp-id="c1">Greg Kestin<svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-mail-medium"></use></svg></a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff1">1</a></sup><sup class="u-js-hide"> <a href="#na1">na1</a></sup>, </li><li class="c-article-author-list__item"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" data-track-index="2_5" data-track-context="researcher popup with no profile" href="#auth-Kelly-Miller-Aff2" data-author-popup="auth-Kelly-Miller-Aff2" data-author-search="Miller, Kelly">Kelly Miller</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff2">2</a></sup><sup class="u-js-hide"> <a href="#na1">na1</a></sup>, </li><li class="c-article-author-list__item c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" data-track-index="3_5" data-track-context="researcher popup with no profile" href="#auth-Anna-Klales-Aff1" data-author-popup="auth-Anna-Klales-Aff1" data-author-search="Klales, Anna">Anna Klales</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff1">1</a></sup>, </li><li class="c-article-author-list__item c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" data-track-index="4_5" data-track-context="researcher popup with no profile" href="#auth-Timothy-Milbourne-Aff1" data-author-popup="auth-Timothy-Milbourne-Aff1" data-author-search="Milbourne, Timothy">Timothy Milbourne</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff1">1</a></sup> & </li><li class="c-article-author-list__show-more" aria-label="Show all 5 authors for this article" title="Show all 5 authors for this article">…</li><li class="c-article-author-list__item"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" data-track-index="5_5" data-track-context="researcher popup with no profile" href="#auth-Gregorio-Ponti-Aff1" data-author-popup="auth-Gregorio-Ponti-Aff1" data-author-search="Ponti, Gregorio">Gregorio Ponti</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff1">1</a></sup> </li></ul><button aria-expanded="false" class="c-article-author-list__button"><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-down-medium"></use></svg><span>Show authors</span></button>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<p class="c-article-info-details" data-container-section="info">
|
||
|
||
<a data-test="journal-link" href="/srep" data-track="click" data-track-action="journal homepage" data-track-category="article body" data-track-label="link"><i data-test="journal-title">Scientific Reports</i></a>
|
||
|
||
<b data-test="journal-volume"><span class="u-visually-hidden">volume</span> 15</b>, Article number: <span data-test="article-number">17458</span> (<span data-test="article-publication-year">2025</span>)
|
||
<a href="#citeas" class="c-article-info-details__cite-as u-hide-print" data-track="click" data-track-action="cite this article" data-track-label="link">Cite this article</a>
|
||
</p>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-metrics-bar__wrapper u-clear-both">
|
||
<ul class="c-article-metrics-bar u-list-reset">
|
||
|
||
<li class=" c-article-metrics-bar__item" data-test="access-count">
|
||
<p class="c-article-metrics-bar__count">113k <span class="c-article-metrics-bar__label">Accesses</span></p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-metrics-bar__item" data-test="citation-count">
|
||
<p class="c-article-metrics-bar__count">59 <span class="c-article-metrics-bar__label">Citations</span></p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-metrics-bar__item" data-test="altmetric-score">
|
||
<p class="c-article-metrics-bar__count">748 <span class="c-article-metrics-bar__label">Altmetric</span></p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-metrics-bar__item">
|
||
<p class="c-article-metrics-bar__details"><a href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6/metrics" data-track="click" data-track-action="view metrics" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Metrics <span class="u-visually-hidden">details</span></a></p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
</header>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="u-js-hide" data-component="article-subject-links">
|
||
<h3 class="c-article__sub-heading">Subjects</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-article-subject-list">
|
||
<li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/applied-physics" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Applied physics</a></li><li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/learning-and-memory" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Learning and memory</a></li><li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/mathematics-and-computing" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Mathematics and computing</a></li><li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/physics" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Physics</a></li><li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/psychology" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Psychology</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-body">
|
||
<section aria-labelledby="Abs1" data-title="Abstract" lang="en"><div class="c-article-section" id="Abs1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Abs1">Abstract</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Abs1-content"><p>Advances in generative artificial intelligence show great potential for improving education. Yet little is known about how this new technology should be used and how effective it can be compared to current best practices. Here we report a randomized, controlled trial measuring college students’ learning and their perceptions when content is presented through an AI-powered tutor compared with an active learning class. The novel design of the custom AI tutor is informed by the same pedagogical best practices as employed in the in-class lessons. We find that students learn significantly more in less time when using the AI tutor, compared with the in-class active learning. They also feel more engaged and more motivated. These findings offer empirical evidence for the efficacy of a widely accessible AI-powered pedagogy in significantly enhancing learning outcomes, presenting a compelling case for its broad adoption in learning environments.</p></div></div></section>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<section aria-labelledby="inline-recommendations" data-title="Inline Recommendations" class="c-article-recommendations" data-track-component="inline-recommendations">
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-recommendations-title" id="inline-recommendations">Similar content being viewed by others</h3>
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-list">
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-list__item">
|
||
<article class="c-article-recommendations-card" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/ScholarlyArticle">
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-card__img"><img src="https://media.springernature.com/w215h120/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41539-025-00320-7/MediaObjects/41539_2025_320_Fig1_HTML.png" loading="lazy" alt=""></div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-card__main">
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-recommendations-card__heading" itemprop="name headline">
|
||
<a class="c-article-recommendations-card__link"
|
||
itemprop="url"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-025-00320-7?fromPaywallRec=false"
|
||
data-track="select_recommendations_1"
|
||
data-track-context="inline recommendations"
|
||
data-track-action="click recommendations inline - 1"
|
||
data-track-label="10.1038/s41539-025-00320-7">A systematic review of AI-driven intelligent tutoring systems (ITS) in K-12 education
|
||
</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
<div class="c-article-meta-recommendations" data-test="recommendation-info">
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__item-type">Article</span>
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__access-type">Open access</span>
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__date">14 May 2025</span>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</article>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-list__item">
|
||
<article class="c-article-recommendations-card" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/ScholarlyArticle">
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-card__img"><img src="https://media.springernature.com/w215h120/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1057%2Fs41599-024-03839-z/MediaObjects/41599_2024_3839_Fig1_HTML.png" loading="lazy" alt=""></div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-card__main">
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-recommendations-card__heading" itemprop="name headline">
|
||
<a class="c-article-recommendations-card__link"
|
||
itemprop="url"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-024-03839-z?fromPaywallRec=false"
|
||
data-track="select_recommendations_2"
|
||
data-track-context="inline recommendations"
|
||
data-track-action="click recommendations inline - 2"
|
||
data-track-label="10.1057/s41599-024-03839-z">Development of an artificial intelligence curriculum design for children in Taiwan and its impact on learning outcomes
|
||
</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
<div class="c-article-meta-recommendations" data-test="recommendation-info">
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__item-type">Article</span>
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__access-type">Open access</span>
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__date">04 October 2024</span>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</article>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-list__item">
|
||
<article class="c-article-recommendations-card" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/ScholarlyArticle">
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-card__img"><img src="https://media.springernature.com/w215h120/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-026-39237-5/MediaObjects/41598_2026_39237_Fig1_HTML.png" loading="lazy" alt=""></div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-recommendations-card__main">
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-recommendations-card__heading" itemprop="name headline">
|
||
<a class="c-article-recommendations-card__link"
|
||
itemprop="url"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-39237-5?fromPaywallRec=false"
|
||
data-track="select_recommendations_3"
|
||
data-track-context="inline recommendations"
|
||
data-track-action="click recommendations inline - 3"
|
||
data-track-label="10.1038/s41598-026-39237-5">Evaluating AI-powered learning assistants in engineering higher education with implications for student engagement, ethics, and policy
|
||
</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
<div class="c-article-meta-recommendations" data-test="recommendation-info">
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__item-type">Article</span>
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__access-type">Open access</span>
|
||
<span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__date">06 February 2026</span>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</article>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</section>
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
|
||
window.dataLayer.push({
|
||
recommendations: {
|
||
recommender: 'semantic',
|
||
model: 'e5',
|
||
policy_id: null,
|
||
timestamp: 1776308752,
|
||
embedded_user: 'null'
|
||
}
|
||
});
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="main-content" >
|
||
|
||
<section data-title="Introduction"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec1">Introduction</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec1-content"><p>With their human-like conversational style and knowledge drawn from extremely large data sets, generative artificial intelligence (GAI) chatbots have inspired visions of expert tutors available on demand through every smartphone<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 1" title="Singer, N. Will chatbots teach your children? New York Times 
 https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-education-tutoring.html
 
 (2024)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR1" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e446">1</a></sup>. The President of the United States, at the time of this investigation in 2023, pledged to “shape AI’s potential to transform education by creating resources to support educators deploying AI-enabled educational tools, such as personalized tutoring in schools.”<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 1" title="Singer, N. Will chatbots teach your children? New York Times 
 https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-education-tutoring.html
 
 (2024)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR1" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e450">1</a></sup> Despite this recent excitement, previous studies show mixed results on the effectiveness of learning, even with the most advanced AI models<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 2" title="Forero, M. G. & Herrera-Suárez, H. J. ChatGPT in the classroom: boon or bane for physics students’ academic performance? Preprint at 
 arXiv:2312.02422
 
 (2023)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR2" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e454">2</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 3" title="Kumar, H., Rothschild, D. M., Goldstein, D. G., & Hofman, J. M. Math education with large language models: peril or promise? SSRN 
 https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4641653
 
 (2023)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR3" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e457">3</a></sup>. While these models can answer technical questions, their unguided use lets students complete assignments without engaging in critical thinking. After all, AI chatbots are generally designed to be helpful, not to promote learning. They are not trained to follow pedagogical best practices (e.g., facilitating active learning, managing cognitive load<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 4" title="Sweller, J. Cognitive load theory. In The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Cognition in Education (eds Mestre, J. P. & Ross, B. H.) 37–76 (Elsevier Academic Press, 2011)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR4" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e461">4</a></sup>,<sup><a href="#Fn1"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>1</a></sup> and promoting a growth mindset).<sup><a href="#Fn2"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>2</a></sup> Another well-known flaw of AI tutors is their uncanny confidence when giving an incorrect answer or when marking a correct reply as incorrect<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 5" title="Kortemeyer, G. Could an artificial-intelligence agent pass an introductory physics course?. Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res. 19(1), 010132 (2023)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR5" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e476">5</a></sup>.<sup><a href="#Fn3"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>3</a></sup> As reported here, a carefully designed AI tutoring system, using the best current GAI technology and deployed appropriately, can not only overcome these challenges but also address significant known pedagogical challenges in an accessible way that can offer world-class education to any community or learning environment with an internet connection.</p><p>Although passive lectures are among the least effective modes of instruction, they remain in wide use in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) courses<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Henderson, C. & Dancy, M. H. Barriers to the use of research-based instructional strategies: The influence of both individual and situational characteristics. Phys. Rev. Spec. Top.-Phys. Educ. Res. 3(2), 020102 (2007)." href="#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e496">6</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Stains, M. et al. Anatomy of STEM teaching in North American universities. Science 359(6383), 1468–1470 (2018)." href="#ref-CR7" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e496_1">7</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 8" title="Handelsman, J. et al. Scientific teaching. Science 304, 521–522 (2004)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR8" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e499">8</a></sup>. Passive lectures have several long-known issues: 1. They move too quickly for some students and too slowly for others because the teacher controls the pace of instruction; 2. Students do not receive personalized feedback to their questions as they arise; and 3. They fail to maintain consistent student engagement. Active learning pedagogies,<sup><a href="#Fn4"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>4</a></sup> such as peer instruction, small-group activities, or a flipped classroom structure, have demonstrated significant improvements over passive lectures<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Hake, R. R. Interactive-engagement vs. traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses. Am. J. Phys. 66, 64–74 (1998)." href="#ref-CR9" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e516">9</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Crouch, C. H. & Mazur, E. Peer instruction: Ten years of experience and results. Am. J. Phys. 69, 970–977 (2001)." href="#ref-CR10" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e516_1">10</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Deslauriers, L., Schelew, E., & Wieman, C. Improved learning in a large-enrollment physics class. Science 332, 862–864 (2011)." href="#ref-CR11" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e516_2">11</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Freeman, S. et al. Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 111, 8410–8415 (2014)." href="#ref-CR12" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e516_3">12</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Fraser, J. M. et al. Teaching and physics education research: Bridging the gap. Rep. Prog. Phys. 77, 032401 (2014)." href="#ref-CR13" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e516_4">13</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 14" title="Thornton, R. K., Kuhl, D., Cummings, K. & Marx, J. Comparing the force and motion conceptual evaluation and the force concept inventory. Phys. Rev. ST Phys. Educ. Res. 5, 010105 (2009)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR14" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e519">14</a></sup>. However, any approach that involves one teacher working with many students will suffer, at least in part, from the same three problems that plague passive lectures.</p><p>Working with an expert personal tutor is generally regarded as the most efficient form of education<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 15" title="Bloom, B. S. The 2 sigma problem: The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring. Educ. Res. 13(6), 4–16 (1984)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR15" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e526">15</a></sup>. A tutor can guide the student while providing personalized feedback and answering questions as they arise. Expert tutors will adapt their approach to a student’s individual ability, pace, and specific needs. They offer a more focused and efficient learning experience, managing the student’s cognitive load. In addition, personalized instruction can foster a growth mindset, which has been shown to promote students’ persistence in the face of difficulties<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="Dweck, C. S. Mindset: The New Psychology of Success (Random House, 2006)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e530">16</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 17" title="Yeager, D. S. & Dweck, C. S. What can be learned from growth mindset controversies?. Am. Psychol. 75(9), 1269 (2020)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR17" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e533">17</a></sup>. While the advantages of personalized instruction are clear, this model of education cannot scale to meet the needs of a large number of students<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 15" title="Bloom, B. S. The 2 sigma problem: The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring. Educ. Res. 13(6), 4–16 (1984)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR15" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e537">15</a></sup>.</p><p>What if an AI tutor could mimic the learning experience one would get from an expert (human) tutor? It could address the unique needs of each individual through timely feedback while adopting what is known from the science of how students learn best. This is the focus of our work. Through a design that involves targeted, content-rich prompt engineering, we developed an online tutor that uses GAI and best practices from pedagogy and educational psychology to promote learning in undergraduate science education. We conducted a randomized controlled experiment in a large undergraduate physics course (<i>N</i> = 194) at Harvard University, with a student population broadly representative of those found across a range of institutions, to measure the difference between 1) how much students learn and 2) students’ perceptions of the learning experience when identical material is presented through an AI tutor compared with an active learning classroom.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Results"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec2-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec2">Results</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec2-content"><p>In this study, students were divided into two groups, each experiencing two lessons, each with distinct teaching methodologies, in consecutive weeks. During, the first week, group 1 engaged with an AI-supported lesson at home while group 2 participated in an active learning lesson in class. The conditions were reversed the following week. To establish baseline knowledge, students from both groups completed a pre-test prior to each lesson, focusing on surface tension in the first week and fluid flow in the second. Following each lesson, students completed post-tests to measure content mastery and answered four questions aimed at gauging their learning experience, including engagement, enjoyment, motivation, and growth mindset.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec3">Learning gains: post-test scores</h3><p>Learning gains were measured by comparing the post-test scores of the AI group and the in-class active learning group to the pre-test scores of the two groups combined. Students in the AI group exhibited a higher median (M) post-score (M = 4.5, N = 142) compared to those in the in-class active learning group (M = 3.5, N = 174). The median learning gains for students, relative to the pre-test baseline (M = 2.75, N = 316), in the AI-tutored group were over double<sup><a href="#Fn5"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>5</a></sup> those for students in the in-class active learning group. We conducted a two-sample rank-sum (Mann–Whitney) test to compare the distribution of post-scores of the two groups. The analysis revealed a statistically significant difference (z = -5.6, <i>p</i> < 10<sup>–8</sup>). Figure <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#Fig1">1</a> shows mean aggregate results (weeks 1 and 2 combined)<sup><a href="#Fn6"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>6</a></sup> of the learning gains for the group taught with in-class active learning compared to the group taught with the AI tutor.</p><div class="c-article-section__figure js-c-reading-companion-figures-item" data-test="figure" data-container-section="figure" id="figure-1" data-title="Fig. 1"><figure><figcaption><b id="Fig1" class="c-article-section__figure-caption" data-test="figure-caption-text">Fig. 1</b></figcaption><div class="c-article-section__figure-content"><div class="c-article-section__figure-item"><picture class="c-article-section__figure-picture"><img aria-describedby="figure-1-desc" src="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig1_HTML.png" alt="Fig. 1" loading="lazy" width="685" height="604"></picture><div class="c-article-section__figure-link"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="article-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6/figures/1" data-track-dest="link:Figure1 Full size image" aria-label="Full size image figure 1" rel="nofollow"><span>Full size image</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></div><div class="c-article-section__figure-description" data-test="bottom-caption" id="figure-1-desc"><p>Comparison of learning gains: A comparison of mean post-test performance between students taught with the in-class active learning and students taught with the AI tutor. Dotted line represents students’ mean baseline knowledge before the lesson (i.e., the pre-test scores of both groups). Error bars show one standard error of the mean.</p></div></div></figure></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec4">Time on task</h3><p>During a 75-minute period, the in-class students spent 15 minutes taking the pre- and post-tests; we assume 60 minutes spent on learning. For students in the AI group, we tracked their use of the AI tutor platform to measure how long they spent on the material, the distribution for which is shown in Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#Fig2">2</a>. 70% of students in the AI group spent less than 60 minutes on task, while 30% spent more than 60 minutes on task. The median time on task for students in the AI group was 49 minutes.</p><div class="c-article-section__figure js-c-reading-companion-figures-item" data-test="figure" data-container-section="figure" id="figure-2" data-title="Fig. 2"><figure><figcaption><b id="Fig2" class="c-article-section__figure-caption" data-test="figure-caption-text">Fig. 2</b></figcaption><div class="c-article-section__figure-content"><div class="c-article-section__figure-item"><picture class="c-article-section__figure-picture"><img aria-describedby="figure-2-desc" src="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig2_HTML.png" alt="Fig. 2" loading="lazy" width="685" height="399"></picture><div class="c-article-section__figure-link"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="article-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6/figures/2" data-track-dest="link:Figure2 Full size image" aria-label="Full size image figure 2" rel="nofollow"><span>Full size image</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></div><div class="c-article-section__figure-description" data-test="bottom-caption" id="figure-2-desc"><p>AI tutor time on task: Total time students in the AI group spent interacting with the tutor. Dotted line denotes the length of the in-class active learning lesson (60 minutes).</p></div></div></figure></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec5">Learning gains: linear regression model</h3><p>We constructed a linear regression model (Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#MOESM1">S1</a>) to better understand how the type of instruction (in-class active learning versus AI tutor) contributed to students’ mastery of the subject matter as measured by their post-test scores. This model includes the following sets of controls. First, we controlled for background measures of physics proficiency: specific content knowledge (pre-test score), broader proficiency in the course material (midterm exam before the study), and prior conceptual understanding of physics (Force Concept Inventory or FCI)<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 18" title="Hestenes, D., Wells, M. & Swackhamer, G. Force concept inventory. Phys. Teach. 30(3), 141–158 (1992)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR18" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e644">18</a></sup>. Second, we controlled for students’ prior experience with ChatGPT. Third, we controlled for factors inherent to the crossover study design: the class topic (surface tension vs fluids) and the version of the pre/post tests (A vs B). Finally, we controlled for time on task. Given that our experiment is a crossover design in which each student experiences both conditions, this model clusters at the student level.</p><p>Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#MOESM1">S1</a> shows that, controlling for all these factors, the students in the AI group performed substantially better on the post-test compared with those in the in-class active learning group. We show this to be a highly significant (<i>p</i> < 10<sup>–8</sup>) result with a large effect size. While the linear regression suggests an effect size of 0.63, this is an underestimation due to ceiling effect; a quantile regression allows us to provide an estimate of the effect size that avoids ceiling effect in the post-test scores. Such an analysis provides an effect size in the range of 0.73 to 1.3 standard deviations.</p><p>Notably, there was no correlation between the time on task and students’ post-test scores, despite quite a wide range of times measured for the AI group (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#Fig2">2</a>). As discussed further below, students’ ability to pace themselves with the AI tutor is an advantage of personalized instruction compared with in-class learning.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec6">AI tutor: students’ perceptions of learning</h3><p>Figure <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#Fig3">3</a> shows students’ average level of agreement with four statements about their perceptions of learning, broken down between the two groups (in-class active learning vs. AI tutor). Students rated their level of agreement on a 5-point Likert scale, with 1 representing “strongly disagree” and 5 representing “strongly agree.” In responding to the first statement, relating to engagement, the students in the AI group agreed more strongly (Mean = 4.1, SD = 0.98) than those in the in-class active learning group (Mean = 3.6, SD = 0.92), t(311) = − 4.5, <i>p</i> < 0.0001. Likewise, in responding to the second statement, relating to motivation, students in the AI group agreed more strongly (Mean = 3.4, SD = 1.0) than those in the in-class active learning group (Mean = 3.1, SD = 0.86), t(311) = -3.4, <i>p</i> < 0.001. Students’ average level of agreement with the remaining two statements (relating enjoyment to growth mindset) were not statistically significantly different between the two groups. To summarize, Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#Fig3">3</a> shows that, on average, students in the AI group felt significantly more engaged and more motivated during the AI class session than the students in the in-class active learning group, and the degree to which both groups enjoyed the lesson and reported a growth mindset was comparable.</p><div class="c-article-section__figure js-c-reading-companion-figures-item" data-test="figure" data-container-section="figure" id="figure-3" data-title="Fig. 3"><figure><figcaption><b id="Fig3" class="c-article-section__figure-caption" data-test="figure-caption-text">Fig. 3</b></figcaption><div class="c-article-section__figure-content"><div class="c-article-section__figure-item"><picture class="c-article-section__figure-picture"><img aria-describedby="figure-3-desc" src="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_Fig3_HTML.png" alt="Fig. 3" loading="lazy" width="685" height="401"></picture><div class="c-article-section__figure-link"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="article-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6/figures/3" data-track-dest="link:Figure3 Full size image" aria-label="Full size image figure 3" rel="nofollow"><span>Full size image</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></div><div class="c-article-section__figure-description" data-test="bottom-caption" id="figure-3-desc"><p>Student perception of learning experiences: Level of agreement to statements about perceptions of learning experiences, comparing students taught by in-class active learning and students taught with the AI tutor. Error bars show 1 standard error of the mean. Asterisks above the bars denote <i>P</i>-values generated by dependent t-tests (***<i>p</i> < 0.001).</p></div></div></figure></div></div></div></section><section data-title="Discussion"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec7-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec7">Discussion</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec7-content"><p>We have found that when students interact with our AI tutor, at home, on their own, they learn significantly more than when they engage with the same content during an in-class active learning lesson, while spending less time on task. This finding underscores the transformative potential of AI tutors in authentic educational settings. In order to realize this potential for improving STEM outcomes, student-AI interactions must be carefully designed to follow research-based best practices.</p><p>The extensive pedagogical literature supports a set of best practices that foster students’ learning, applicable to both human instructors and digital learning platforms. Key practices include (i) facilitating active learning<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 11" title="Deslauriers, L., Schelew, E., & Wieman, C. Improved learning in a large-enrollment physics class. Science 332, 862–864 (2011)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR11" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e722">11</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 19" title="Fredricks, J. A., Blumenfeld, P. C. & Paris, A. H. School engagement: Potential of the concept, state of the evidence. Rev. Educ. Res. 74(1), 59–109. 
 https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543074001059
 
 (2004)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR19" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e725">19</a></sup>, (ii) managing cognitive load<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 4" title="Sweller, J. Cognitive load theory. In The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Cognition in Education (eds Mestre, J. P. & Ross, B. H.) 37–76 (Elsevier Academic Press, 2011)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR4" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e729">4</a></sup>, (iii) promoting a growth mindset<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 15" title="Bloom, B. S. The 2 sigma problem: The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring. Educ. Res. 13(6), 4–16 (1984)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR15" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e733">15</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="Dweck, C. S. Mindset: The New Psychology of Success (Random House, 2006)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e736">16</a></sup>, (iv) scaffolding content<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 20" title="Wood, D., Bruner, J. S., & Ross, G. The role of tutoring in problem-solving. J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry 17(2), 89–100 (1976)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR20" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e740">20</a></sup>, (v) ensuring accuracy of information and feedback, (vi) delivering such feedback and information in a targeted and timely fashion<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 21" title="Shute, V. J. Focus on formative feedback. Rev. Educ. Res. 78(1), 153–189 (2008)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR21" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e744">21</a></sup>, and (vii) allowing for self-pacing<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 22" title="Tatum, B. C. & Lenel, J. C. A Comparison of self-paced and lecture/discussion methods in an accelerated learning format. J. Res. Innov. Teach. 5(1), (2012)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR22" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e749">22</a></sup>. We aimed to design an AI system that conforms to these practices to the fullest extent current technology allows, thus establishing a model for future educational AI applications.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec8">Designing successful student-AI interactions</h3><p>A subset of the best practices (i-iii) were incorporated into the AI pedagogy by careful engineering of the AI tutor’s system prompt. We designed the AI tutor with a system prompt with guidelines (Supplementary Material <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#MOESM1">1</a>) to facilitate active engagement, manage cognitive load, and promote a growth mindset. However, we found that a system prompt could not reliably provide enough structure to scaffold problems with multiple parts (iv), as the AI tutor would occasionally discuss parts out of sequence or that were not immediately relevant. For this reason, the AI platform was designed to guide students sequentially through each part of each problem in the lesson, mirroring the approach taken by the instructor during the in-class active learning (see screenshot of AI tutor platform in Figure S1).</p><p>The occurrence of inaccurate “hallucinations” by the current generation of large language models (LLMs) poses a significant challenge for their use in education<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 23" title="Meyer, J. G. et al. ChatGPT and large language models in academia: Opportunities and challenges. BioData Min. 16(1), 20–20. 
 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9
 
 (2023)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR23" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e766">23</a></sup>. Thus, we avoided relying solely on GPT-4 to generate solutions for these activities. Given that LLMs proceed by next-token prediction, accuracy in complex math or science problems is enhanced when the system generates, or is provided with, detailed step-by-step solutions<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 24" title="Nye, M. et al. Show your work: Scratchpads for intermediate computation with language models. 
 arXiv:2112.00114
 
 (2021)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR24" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e770">24</a></sup>. Therefore, we enriched our prompts with comprehensive, step-by-step answers, guiding the AI tutor to deliver accurate and high-quality explanations (v) to students. As a result, 83% of students reported that the AI tutor’s explanations were as good as, or better than, those from human instructors in the class.</p><p>While best practices (i-v) can be readily adhered to in a classroom setting, the remaining best practices (vi-vii) cannot. Providing timely feedback that targets the specific needs of individual students (vi) and self-pacing (vii) are difficult to achieve and impossible to maintain in a typical classroom. We believe that the increased learning from structured AI tutoring is largely due to its ability to offer personalized feedback on demand—just as one-on-one tutoring from a (human) expert is superior to classroom instruction<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 15" title="Bloom, B. S. The 2 sigma problem: The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring. Educ. Res. 13(6), 4–16 (1984)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR15" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e777">15</a></sup>. In addition, interactions with the AI tutor are self-paced (vii), as indicated by the distribution of times in Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#Fig2">2</a>. Students who need more time to build conceptual understanding or to fill gaps in their knowledge can take that time, instead of having to synchronously follow the pace of the in-class lesson. Students who are familiar with the material or have underlying skills, however, can move through the activities in less time than required for the in-class lesson. We measured the students’ perception of pace during the control condition (in-class active learning) on the days the experiment took place. Notably, the 3.8% of students who found the pace of class “too fast” all spent more than the median time (49 minutes) on the AI lesson, while the 2.2% who found the pace of the in-class lesson “too slow” all spent less than the median time on the AI lesson.</p><p>Our results contrast with previous studies that have shown limitations of AI-powered instruction. Krupp et al. (2023) observed limited reflection among students using ChatGPT without guidance<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 25" title="Krupp, L., Steinert, S., Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, M., Avila, K. E., Lukowicz, P., Kuhn, J., Küchemann, S., & Karolus, J., Unreflected acceptance—investigating the negative consequences of ChatGPT-assisted problem solving in physics education. In HHAI 2024: Hybrid Human AI Systems for the Social Good, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications, Vol. 386, 199–212. IOS Press (2024)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR25" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e787">25</a></sup>, while Forero (2023) reported a decline in student performance when AI interactions lacked structure and did not encourage critical thinking<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 2" title="Forero, M. G. & Herrera-Suárez, H. J. ChatGPT in the classroom: boon or bane for physics students’ academic performance? Preprint at 
 arXiv:2312.02422
 
 (2023)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR2" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e791">2</a></sup>. These previous approaches did not adhere to the same research-based best practices that informed our approach. Our success suggests that thoughtful implementation of AI-based tutoring could lead to significant improvements to current pedagogy and enhanced learning gains for a broad range of subjects in a format that is accessible in any environment with an internet connection.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec9">Implications for personal AI tutors in education</h3><p>How might an AI tutoring system, such as the one we have deployed, integrate into current pedagogical best practices, given its effectiveness in terms of learning gains and student perceptions?</p><p>Existing pedagogies often fail to meet students’ individual needs, especially in classrooms where students have a wide range of prior knowledge. Here, we have shown the advantage of using asynchronous AI tutoring as students’ first substantial engagement with challenging material. AI could be used to effectively teach introductory material to students before class, which allows precious class time to be spent developing higher-order skills such as advanced problem solving, project-based learning, and group work. Instructors can assess these skills in person, which avoids the problematic use of AI as a shortcut on assessments such as homework, papers, and projects. As in a “flipped classroom” approach, an AI tutor should not replace in-person teaching—rather, it should be used to bring all students up to a level where they can achieve the maximum benefit from their time in class.</p><p>That said, beyond the initial introduction of material, AI tutors like the ones employed here could serve an extremely wide range of purposes, such as assisting with homework, offering study guidance, and providing remedial lessons for underprepared students. Yet our results show that, with today’s GAI technology, pedagogical best practices must be explicitly and carefully built into each such application. As seen in previous studies<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 2" title="Forero, M. G. & Herrera-Suárez, H. J. ChatGPT in the classroom: boon or bane for physics students’ academic performance? Preprint at 
 arXiv:2312.02422
 
 (2023)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR2" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e809">2</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 25" title="Krupp, L., Steinert, S., Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, M., Avila, K. E., Lukowicz, P., Kuhn, J., Küchemann, S., & Karolus, J., Unreflected acceptance—investigating the negative consequences of ChatGPT-assisted problem solving in physics education. In HHAI 2024: Hybrid Human AI Systems for the Social Good, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications, Vol. 386, 199–212. IOS Press (2024)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR25" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e812">25</a></sup>, instructors should avoid using AI in situations where students are likely to use it as a crutch to circumvent critical thinking. We advise against the notion that AI, solely due to its efficacy in enhancing teaching and learning, should entirely supplant in-class instructional methods. Our demonstration illustrates how AI can bolster student learning beyond the confines of the classroom. We advocate harnessing this capability to enable instructors to use in-class sessions for activities and projects that foster advanced cognitive skills such as critical thinking and content synthesis.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec10">Context, limitations, and future directions</h3><p>Our AI tutoring approach was applied in a setting where students were engaging substantially with material in particular subject areas for the first time. Our lessons were comprised of activities focused on learning objectives categorized at the understanding, applying, and analyzing levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy<sup><a href="#Fn7"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>7</a></sup>—as were the associated pre- and post-test questions<sup><a href="#Fn8"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>8</a></sup>. This stage of learning, characterized by a meaningful degree of information delivery, appears to be particularly well suited for current generative AI tutors. The significant gains and positive affect observed in this study may also depend on several factors: a heterogeneous student population requiring varying instructional paces, integration of high-quality instructional videos,<sup><a href="#Fn9"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>9</a></sup> a large language model capable of closely following complex prompts (e.g., GPT-4), expert-crafted, question-specific prompts written by instructors experienced with the content, a carefully structured framework designed to scaffold and guide student interactions, and content that lends itself to such a format. While the advantages of the experimental condition are widely generalizable and our findings have broad implications, we do not presume that structured AI tutoring will always outperform in-class active learning in all contexts, for example, those requiring complex synthesis of multiple concepts and higher-order critical thinking.</p><p>Compelling directions for future work include exploring other contexts throughout the learning process where AI tutoring may be successfully implemented, such as in homework, recitation, exam studying, pre-class assignments, and laboratory. Valuable follow-up studies could also explicitly examine the details of such combinations throughout an entire course. This would also allow for systematic integration of well-established retention enhancing strategies (e.g., spacing) and could provide insights into other novel phenomena that may arise from prolonged and varied use of AI in education, such as potential impact on collaboration skills. Given that the current AI tutor implementation mirrors well-established in-class active learning pedagogies and generates comparable affect<sup><a href="#Fn10"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>10</a></sup>—with its primary difference (besides personalization) being the medium of delivery, which typically does not impact learning on its own<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 26" title="Clark, R. C. & Mayer, R. E. e-Learning and the science of instruction. In E-learning and the Science of Instruction: Proven Guidelines for Consumers and Designers of Multimedia Learning. Center for Creative Leadership (2011)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR26" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e852">26</a></sup>—it is reasonable to expect findings from in-class active learning approaches to carry over. Nonetheless, studies that explicitly replicate known in-class active learning results<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 27" title="Francis, G. E., Adams, J. P. & Noonan, E. J. Do they stay fixed?. Phys. Teach. 36, 488–490 (1998)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR27" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e856">27</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 28" title="McDermott, L. C., Heron, P. R. L., Shaffer, P. S., & Stetzer, M. S. Improving the preparation of K-12 teachers through physics education research. Am. J. Phys. 74, 763–767 (2006)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR28" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e859">28</a></sup> would be valuable for confirming and refining the details of this transferability. Such research could include explorations of the qualities that constitute effective system prompts and behaviors for AI tutors in various situations (e.g., determining when the AI tutor should openly provide answers versus guiding students to reflect on their own responses).</p><p>Generative AI technology is developing very rapidly, allowing for expansion of the capabilities and application of AI tutoring. While accuracy of our AI tutor relied on pre-written answers, as generative AI models improve in scientific reasoning<sup><a href="#Fn11"><span class="u-visually-hidden">Footnote </span>11</a></sup>, studies could explore whether such efficacy could be achieved without a provided solution. Also, in our approach, feedback was provided in response to student input, but multimodality would allow AI systems to interpret images (or audio) of a student’s work and more proactively provide feedback. Investigations could explore whether holistic monitoring of a student’s process could provide feedback on issues with thinking that may not be addressed by current pedagogies (in or out of the classroom) in which students typically receive targeted feedback only when they ask a question.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Conclusion"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec11-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec11">Conclusion</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec11-content"><p>We have built an AI-based tutor, engineered with appropriate prompts and scaffolding, that helps students learn significantly more in less time and feel more engaged and motivated compared with in-class active learning. This study confirms the feasibility and effectiveness of AI tutors in educational settings, and suggests design principles to guide future development of these tools. As the prompts described here can be adapted to any subject matter, this approach can provide students, in a wide range of disciplines, on-demand AI-powered support.</p><p>These results and principles provide a blueprint for highly effective AI-powered learning frameworks that are engaging and suggest a pathway for widely accessible education on which policymakers, technologists, and educators can collaborate. It also serves as a foundation for a series of explorations of the use of AI in educational settings.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Methods"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec12-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec12">Methods</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec12-content"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec13">Study population</h3><p>The present study took place during the Fall 2023 semester in Physical Sciences 2 (PS2), which is an introductory physics class for the life sciences and is Harvard’s largest physics class (<i>N</i> = 233). Students were randomly assigned to two groups, respecting the constraint that students who regularly worked together in class during peer instruction were placed in the same group in order to maximize the effectiveness of their in-class learning. The demographics of the two groups were comparable (see table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#MOESM1">S2A</a>), as were previous measures of their physics background knowledge (see Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#MOESM1">S2B</a>). Note that FCI pretest scores are comparable to those of students at other universities<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 29" title="Caballero, M. D. et al. Comparing large lecture mechanics curricula using the Force Concept Inventory: A five thousand student study. Am. J. Phys. 80(7), 638–644 (2012)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR29" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e904">29</a></sup>. Of the 233 enrolled students, 194 were eligible for inclusion in the study. Eligibility was based on students’ consent, participation in both in-class and AI-tutored instruction, and completion of all pre-tests and post-tests.</p><p>We note that the results hold for students with both lower and higher performance abilities than typical students at various institutions, as assessed by the widely recognized FCI test. They also hold for all degrees of scientific attitudes—from non-expert to expert—as gauged by the CLASS survey. Typical pre-instruction FCI scores in educational institutions range from aproximately 30% to 50%<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 30" title="Hake, R. R. Interactive-engagement versus traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses. Am. J. Phys. 66, 64–74 (1998)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR30" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e911">30</a></sup>. In this study, significant subpopulations span this range. The subpopulations of students with pre-instruction FCI scores below 40% and those above 40% both showed significantly better post-test performance with AI tutoring compared to in-class active learning (<i>p</i> < 0.001). This improvement was similarly observed in students below and above the 65% benchmark<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 31" title="Perkins, K. K., Adams, W. K., Pollock, S. J., Finkelstein, N. D., & Wieman, C. E. Correlating student beliefs with student learning using the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey. AIP Conf. Proc. 790, 61–64 (2005)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR31" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e918">31</a></sup> in scientific attitudes on the CLASS.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec14">Course setting</h3><p>The course (PS2) meets twice per week for 75 minutes each. The study took place during one of the two meeting of the class during the ninth and tenth weeks of the course. All in-class lessons employed research-based best practices for in-class active learning<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 32" title="McCarty, L. S. & Deslauriers, L. Transforming a large university physics course to student-centered learning, without sacrificing content: A case study. In The Routledge International Handbook of Student-Centered Learning and Teaching in Higher Education, 186–200 (Routledge, 2020)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR32" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e930">32</a></sup>. Each class involves a series of activities that teach physics concepts and problem-solving skills. First the instructor introduces an activity, then students work through the activity in self-selected groups with support and guidance from course staff, and finally the instructor provides targeted feedback to address students’ questions and difficulties.</p><p>This instructional approach has proved to be a successful implementation of active learning, and has been shown to offer a significant improvement over passive lectures <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 33" title="Miller, K., Callaghan, K., McCarty, L. S. & Deslauriers, L. Increasing the effectiveness of active learning using deliberate practice: A homework transformation. Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res. 17(1), 010129 (2021)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR33" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e937">33</a></sup>. We note that the authors and instructors represented in the literature demonstrating this in-class active learning approach to be effective and superior to passive instruction overlap with those of the present study. Similar active learning approaches have been shown to increase learning across a wide range of STEM fields<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 34" title="Freeman, S. et al. Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 111(23), 8410–8415 (2014)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR34" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e941">34</a></sup>. Although active learning pedagogies may elicit negative perceptions from students<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 35" title="Deslauriers, L., McCarty, L. S., Miller, K., Callaghan, K. & Kestin, G. Measuring actual learning versus feeling of learning in response to being actively engaged in the classroom. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 116(39), 19251–19257 (2019)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR35" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e945">35</a></sup>, both course instructors, as well as their presentations in the course, achieved student evaluation scores above the departmental and division averages. The active learning pedagogy, optimized over the years to cater to the vast majority of the student population, ensures minimal inactivity by strategically allowing instructors to intervene and adjust the class dynamically based on real-time observations of student engagement and performance<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 32" title="McCarty, L. S. & Deslauriers, L. Transforming a large university physics course to student-centered learning, without sacrificing content: A case study. In The Routledge International Handbook of Student-Centered Learning and Teaching in Higher Education, 186–200 (Routledge, 2020)." href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#ref-CR32" id="ref-link-section-d108446142e949">32</a></sup>.</p><p>To verify the active learning emphasis of the class, students were asked the following question at the end of the semester: “Compared to the in-class time in other STEM classes you have taken at Harvard, to what extent does the typical PS2 in-class time use active learning strategies (i.e., provide the opportunity to discuss and work on problems in class as opposed to passively listening).” The overwhelming majority of students (89%) indicated that PS2 used more active learning compared to other STEM courses.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec15">Study design</h3><p>The present study was approved by the Harvard University IRB (study no. IRB23-0797) and followed a crossover design. The design allowed for control of all aspects of the lessons that were not of interest. The crossover design is summarized in Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6#MOESM1">S3</a>. For each of two lessons, each student: 1) took a pre-class quiz that established their baseline knowledge of the content for that lesson; 2) engaged in either the active classroom lesson (control condition) or the AI tutor lesson (experimental condition); and 3) took a post-class quiz as a test of learning. The content and worksheet for the control and experimental conditions were identical. The introductions for each activity were also identical, varying only by the format of presentation: live and in-person for the control group and over pre-recorded video for the experimental group.</p><p>Given the crossover design, all students experienced both conditions once during the study. The structure of the experimental condition differed from the control condition in that all interactions and feedback were with an AI tutor, rather than with peer-instruction followed by instructor feedback. Students in the experimental condition worked through the handout, asking questions and confirming answers with the AI tutor, called “PS2 Pal.” Students were given equal participation credit for both conditions as well as for the associated pre- and post-test. Students were told that their performance on the pre- and post-tests would not impact their course grade in any way but were told that in order to receive participation credit they needed to demonstrate that they had made an honest effort in completing the tests.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec16">Additional controls</h3><p>In addition to using a crossover design we rigorously controlled for potential bias and other unwanted influences. To prevent the specific test questions from influencing the teaching or AI tutor design, the tests were constructed by a separate team member from those involved in designing the AI or teaching the lessons. To prevent details of the lessons or AI prompts from influencing the test of learning, the tests were written based on the learning goals for the lesson and not the specific lesson content.</p><p>The lesson topics were chosen such that the result would be optimally generalizable. These topics were independent of each other, had little dependence on previous course content, and required no special knowledge beyond high-school level mathematics. The topics were also chosen to minimize the influence of potential prior knowledge of the material—over 90% of the students reported that they had not studied these topics in depth before this course.</p><p>To ensure that the effect was independent of the particular instructor, the two lessons were taught by different instructors (i.e., each of the course’s two co-instructors). We note that the two instructors received student evaluations on their teaching that exceeded the departmental and divisional means.</p><p>To make sure that the study design did not impact the effectiveness of in-person instruction during the experiment, students in class learned from the same instructors, with the same student:staff ratio, and in the same peer-instruction groups as they had throughout the course. As mentioned above, keeping students with their peer-instruction groups meant that subjects were randomized at the level of these groups (2–3 students) rather than as individuals. An alternate linear regression model that clusters at the group level (instead of at the level of individual students) has similarly robust results for AI versus in-class instruction (<i>p</i> < 0.001) and negligible changes to the point estimates for the effects of each covariate. With this clustered model, however, it is difficult to interpret factors such as time on task, which varies widely at the individual level under the AI-tutored conditions.</p><p>While the time commitment for preparation of a single AI-supported lesson was very manageable, there was significant overhead. Preparing system prompts for questions and solutions for a particular lesson was done over a few days. Since activities and solutions were already written for the in-class lesson, this time was spent converting the format of the content to a format appropriate for the AI platform as well as engaging in test conversations for each question and iterating. The most significant time commitment involved in preparing the AI-supported lessons was the development of an AI tutor platform software that took pedagogical best practices into consideration (e.g., structured around individual questions embedded in individual assignments), which took several months.</p></div></div></section>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="u-mt-32">
|
||
<section data-title="Data availability"><div class="c-article-section" id="data-availability-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="data-availability">Data availability</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="data-availability-content">
|
||
|
||
<p><a href="https://github.com/HarvardAItutor/Study-Data-v4">https://github.com/HarvardAItutor/Study-Data-v4</a>.</p>
|
||
</div></div></section><section data-title="Notes"><div class="c-article-section" id="notes-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="notes">Notes</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="notes-content"><ol class="c-article-footnote c-article-footnote--listed"><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn1" data-counter="1."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Cognitive load refers to the total amount of mental effort used in the working memory. This concept emphasizes that learners have a limited capacity to process new information and that instructional design should aim to manage cognitive load effectively.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn2" data-counter="2."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Growth mindset refers to the belief that one’s abilities and intelligence can be developed through effort and learning.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn3" data-counter="3."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>“ChatGPT sometimes writes plausible-sounding but incorrect or nonsensical answers.” <a href="https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt#OpenAI">https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt#OpenAI</a>.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn4" data-counter="4."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Active learning “includes any type of instructional activity that engages students in learning, beyond listening, reading, and memorizing” (<a href="https://bokcenter.harvard.edu/active-learning#:~:text=Active%20learning%20includes%20any%20type,listening%2C%20reading%2C%20and%20memorizing">https://bokcenter.harvard.edu/active-learning#:~:text=Active%20learning%20includes%20any%20type,listening%2C%20reading%2C%20and%20memorizing</a>).</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn5" data-counter="5."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Actual learning gains for students in the AI-tutored group are expected to be <i>greater</i> than those represented by metrics presented here due to a ceiling effect in the post-test scores (resulting from the unexpected effectiveness of the AI tutor). Note that measures that are less sensitive to ceiling effect, such as the median, will be <i>more</i> reliable than measures that are more sensitive to ceiling effect, such as straight gain or mean.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn6" data-counter="6."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>While the data is combined, the trend for each weeks’ tests were as observed in the figure, namely post-test scores for the AI group were greater than the in-class active learning group’s scores.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn7" data-counter="7."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Bloom’s Taxonomy is a hierarchical model used to classify educational learning objectives into levels of complexity and specificity. The original taxonomy was revised in 2001 and is as follows: remembering, understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating. Anderson, L. W. & Krathwohl, D. R. <i>A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives</i> (Longman, 2001).</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn8" data-counter="8."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>33% analyzing, 41% applying, 21% understanding, and 4% remembering.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn9" data-counter="9."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Videos were produced at the Harvard University Derek Bok Center production studio, and the instructor (GK) has a decade of experience hosting, writing, and producing videos and documentaries (e.g., via NOVA | PBS).</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn10" data-counter="10."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Equivalent growth mindset and enjoyment, increased engagement and motivation, and improved satisfaction with feedback.</p></div></li><li class="c-article-footnote--listed__item" id="Fn11" data-counter="11."><div class="c-article-footnote--listed__content"><p>Currently, the models with the most advanced scientific reasoning capabilities have longer response times; in the context of AI tutoring, the model choice should take into account efficiency as well as reasoning capabilities.</p></div></li></ol></div></div></section><div id="MagazineFulltextArticleBodySuffix"><section aria-labelledby="Bib1" data-title="References"><div class="c-article-section" id="Bib1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Bib1">References</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Bib1-content"><div data-container-section="references"><ol class="c-article-references" data-track-component="outbound reference" data-track-context="references section"><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="1."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR1">Singer, N. Will chatbots teach your children? <i>New York Times</i> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-education-tutoring.html" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-education-tutoring.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-education-tutoring.html</a> (2024).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="2."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR2">Forero, M. G. & Herrera-Suárez, H. J. ChatGPT in the classroom: boon or bane for physics students’ academic performance? Preprint at <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02422" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02422">arXiv:2312.02422</a> (2023).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="3."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR3">Kumar, H., Rothschild, D. M., Goldstein, D. G., & Hofman, J. M. Math education with large language models: peril or promise? <i>SSRN</i> <a href="https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4641653" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="10.2139/ssrn.4641653">https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4641653</a> (2023).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="4."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR4">Sweller, J. Cognitive load theory. In <i>The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Cognition in Education</i> (eds Mestre, J. P. & Ross, B. H.) 37–76 (Elsevier Academic Press, 2011).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="5."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR5">Kortemeyer, G. Could an artificial-intelligence agent pass an introductory physics course?. <i>Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res.</i> <b>19</b>(1), 010132 (2023).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.19.010132" data-track-item_id="10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.19.010132" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1103%2FPhysRevPhysEducRes.19.010132" aria-label="Article reference 5" data-doi="10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.19.010132">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 5" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Could%20an%20artificial-intelligence%20agent%20pass%20an%20introductory%20physics%20course%3F&journal=Phys.%20Rev.%20Phys.%20Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.1103%2FPhysRevPhysEducRes.19.010132&volume=19&issue=1&publication_year=2023&author=Kortemeyer%2CG">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="6."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR6">Henderson, C. & Dancy, M. H. Barriers to the use of research-based instructional strategies: The influence of both individual and situational characteristics. <i>Phys. Rev. Spec. Top.-Phys. Educ. Res.</i> <b>3</b>(2), 020102 (2007).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.3.020102" data-track-item_id="10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.3.020102" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1103%2FPhysRevSTPER.3.020102" aria-label="Article reference 6" data-doi="10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.3.020102">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2007PRSTP...3b0102H" aria-label="ADS reference 6">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 6" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Barriers%20to%20the%20use%20of%20research-based%20instructional%20strategies%3A%20The%20influence%20of%20both%20individual%20and%20situational%20characteristics&journal=Phys.%20Rev.%20Spec.%20Top.-Phys.%20Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.1103%2FPhysRevSTPER.3.020102&volume=3&issue=2&publication_year=2007&author=Henderson%2CC&author=Dancy%2CMH">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="7."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR7">Stains, M. et al. Anatomy of STEM teaching in North American universities. <i>Science</i> <b>359</b>(6383), 1468–1470 (2018).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1126/science.aap8892" data-track-item_id="10.1126/science.aap8892" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1126%2Fscience.aap8892" aria-label="Article reference 7" data-doi="10.1126/science.aap8892">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2018Sci...359.1468S" aria-label="ADS reference 7">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC1cXnsVWkuro%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 7">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=29599232" aria-label="PubMed reference 7">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6310123" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 7">PubMed Central</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 7" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Anatomy%20of%20STEM%20teaching%20in%20North%20American%20universities&journal=Science&doi=10.1126%2Fscience.aap8892&volume=359&issue=6383&pages=1468-1470&publication_year=2018&author=Stains%2CM&author=Harshman%2CJ&author=Barker%2CMK&author=Chasteen%2CSV&author=Cole%2CR&author=DeChenne-Peters%2CSE&author=Eagan%2CMK&author=Esson%2CJM&author=Knight%2CJK&author=Laski%2CFA&author=Levis-Fitzgerald%2CM">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="8."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR8">Handelsman, J. et al. Scientific teaching. <i>Science</i> <b>304</b>, 521–522 (2004).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1126/science.1096022" data-track-item_id="10.1126/science.1096022" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1126%2Fscience.1096022" aria-label="Article reference 8" data-doi="10.1126/science.1096022">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2cXjsVGmsrc%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 8">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15105480" aria-label="PubMed reference 8">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 8" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Scientific%20teaching&journal=Science&doi=10.1126%2Fscience.1096022&volume=304&pages=521-522&publication_year=2004&author=Handelsman%2CJ">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="9."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR9">Hake, R. R. Interactive-engagement vs. traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses. <i>Am. J. Phys.</i> <b>66</b>, 64–74 (1998).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.18809" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.18809" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.18809" aria-label="Article reference 9" data-doi="10.1119/1.18809">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1998AmJPh..66...64H" aria-label="ADS reference 9">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 9" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Interactive-engagement%20vs.%20traditional%20methods%3A%20A%20six-thousand-student%20survey%20of%20mechanics%20test%20data%20for%20introductory%20physics%20courses&journal=Am.%20J.%20Phys.&doi=10.1119%2F1.18809&volume=66&pages=64-74&publication_year=1998&author=Hake%2CRR">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="10."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR10">Crouch, C. H. & Mazur, E. Peer instruction: Ten years of experience and results. <i>Am. J. Phys.</i> <b>69</b>, 970–977 (2001).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.1374249" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.1374249" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.1374249" aria-label="Article reference 10" data-doi="10.1119/1.1374249">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2001AmJPh..69..970C" aria-label="ADS reference 10">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 10" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Peer%20instruction%3A%20Ten%20years%20of%20experience%20and%20results&journal=Am.%20J.%20Phys.&doi=10.1119%2F1.1374249&volume=69&pages=970-977&publication_year=2001&author=Crouch%2CCH&author=Mazur%2CE">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="11."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR11">Deslauriers, L., Schelew, E., & Wieman, C. Improved learning in a large-enrollment physics class. <i>Science</i> <b>332</b>, 862–864 (2011).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1126/science.1201783" data-track-item_id="10.1126/science.1201783" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1126%2Fscience.1201783" aria-label="Article reference 11" data-doi="10.1126/science.1201783">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2011Sci...332..862D" aria-label="ADS reference 11">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXlslylsLo%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 11">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=21566198" aria-label="PubMed reference 11">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 11" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Improved%20learning%20in%20a%20large-enrollment%20physics%20class&journal=Science&doi=10.1126%2Fscience.1201783&volume=332&pages=862-864&publication_year=2011&author=Deslauriers%2CL&author=Schelew%2CE&author=Wieman%2CC">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="12."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR12">Freeman, S. et al. Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. <i>Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.</i> <b>111</b>, 8410–8415 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1073/pnas.1319030111" data-track-item_id="10.1073/pnas.1319030111" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1073%2Fpnas.1319030111" aria-label="Article reference 12" data-doi="10.1073/pnas.1319030111">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2014PNAS..111.8410F" aria-label="ADS reference 12">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXnsl2ms7c%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 12">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=24821756" aria-label="PubMed reference 12">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4060654" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 12">PubMed Central</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 12" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Active%20learning%20increases%20student%20performance%20in%20science%2C%20engineering%2C%20and%20mathematics&journal=Proc.%20Natl.%20Acad.%20Sci.%20U.S.A.&doi=10.1073%2Fpnas.1319030111&volume=111&pages=8410-8415&publication_year=2014&author=Freeman%2CS">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="13."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR13">Fraser, J. M. et al. Teaching and physics education research: Bridging the gap. <i>Rep. Prog. Phys.</i> <b>77</b>, 032401 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1088/0034-4885/77/3/032401" data-track-item_id="10.1088/0034-4885/77/3/032401" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1088%2F0034-4885%2F77%2F3%2F032401" aria-label="Article reference 13" data-doi="10.1088/0034-4885/77/3/032401">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2014RPPh...77c2401F" aria-label="ADS reference 13">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=24595011" aria-label="PubMed reference 13">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 13" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Teaching%20and%20physics%20education%20research%3A%20Bridging%20the%20gap&journal=Rep.%20Prog.%20Phys.&doi=10.1088%2F0034-4885%2F77%2F3%2F032401&volume=77&publication_year=2014&author=Fraser%2CJM">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="14."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR14">Thornton, R. K., Kuhl, D., Cummings, K. & Marx, J. Comparing the force and motion conceptual evaluation and the force concept inventory. <i>Phys. Rev. ST Phys. Educ. Res.</i> <b>5</b>, 010105 (2009).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.5.010105" data-track-item_id="10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.5.010105" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1103%2FPhysRevSTPER.5.010105" aria-label="Article reference 14" data-doi="10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.5.010105">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 14" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Comparing%20the%20force%20and%20motion%20conceptual%20evaluation%20and%20the%20force%20concept%20inventory&journal=Phys.%20Rev.%20ST%20Phys.%20Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.1103%2FPhysRevSTPER.5.010105&volume=5&publication_year=2009&author=Thornton%2CRK&author=Kuhl%2CD&author=Cummings%2CK&author=Marx%2CJ">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="15."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR15">Bloom, B. S. The 2 sigma problem: The search for methods of group instruction as effective as one-to-one tutoring. <i>Educ. Res.</i> <b>13</b>(6), 4–16 (1984).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.3102/0013189X013006004" data-track-item_id="10.3102/0013189X013006004" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.3102%2F0013189X013006004" aria-label="Article reference 15" data-doi="10.3102/0013189X013006004">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1984papl.book.....B" aria-label="ADS reference 15">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 15" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%202%20sigma%20problem%3A%20The%20search%20for%20methods%20of%20group%20instruction%20as%20effective%20as%20one-to-one%20tutoring&journal=Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.3102%2F0013189X013006004&volume=13&issue=6&pages=4-16&publication_year=1984&author=Bloom%2CBS">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="16."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR16">Dweck, C. S. <i>Mindset: The New Psychology of Success</i> (Random House, 2006).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 16" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Mindset%3A%20The%20New%20Psychology%20of%20Success&publication_year=2006&author=Dweck%2CCS">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="17."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR17">Yeager, D. S. & Dweck, C. S. What can be learned from growth mindset controversies?. <i>Am. Psychol.</i> <b>75</b>(9), 1269 (2020).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1037/amp0000794" data-track-item_id="10.1037/amp0000794" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1037%2Famp0000794" aria-label="Article reference 17" data-doi="10.1037/amp0000794">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=33382294" aria-label="PubMed reference 17">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8299535" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 17">PubMed Central</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 17" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=What%20can%20be%20learned%20from%20growth%20mindset%20controversies%3F&journal=Am.%20Psychol.&doi=10.1037%2Famp0000794&volume=75&issue=9&publication_year=2020&author=Yeager%2CDS&author=Dweck%2CCS">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="18."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR18">Hestenes, D., Wells, M. & Swackhamer, G. Force concept inventory. <i>Phys. Teach.</i> <b>30</b>(3), 141–158 (1992).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.2343497" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.2343497" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.2343497" aria-label="Article reference 18" data-doi="10.1119/1.2343497">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1992PhTea..30..141H" aria-label="ADS reference 18">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 18" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Force%20concept%20inventory&journal=Phys.%20Teach.&doi=10.1119%2F1.2343497&volume=30&issue=3&pages=141-158&publication_year=1992&author=Hestenes%2CD&author=Wells%2CM&author=Swackhamer%2CG">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="19."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR19">Fredricks, J. A., Blumenfeld, P. C. & Paris, A. H. School engagement: Potential of the concept, state of the evidence. <i>Rev. Educ. Res.</i> <b>74</b>(1), 59–109. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543074001059" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="10.3102/00346543074001059">https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543074001059</a> (2004).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.3102/00346543074001059" data-track-item_id="10.3102/00346543074001059" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.3102%2F00346543074001059" aria-label="Article reference 19" data-doi="10.3102/00346543074001059">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 19" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=School%20engagement%3A%20Potential%20of%20the%20concept%2C%20state%20of%20the%20evidence&journal=Rev.%20Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.3102%2F00346543074001059&volume=74&issue=1&pages=59-109&publication_year=2004&author=Fredricks%2CJA&author=Blumenfeld%2CPC&author=Paris%2CAH">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="20."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR20">Wood, D., Bruner, J. S., & Ross, G. The role of tutoring in problem-solving. <i>J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry</i> <b>17</b>(2), 89–100 (1976).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1469-7610.1976.tb00381.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1469-7610.1976.tb00381.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1469-7610.1976.tb00381.x" aria-label="Article reference 20" data-doi="10.1111/j.1469-7610.1976.tb00381.x">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DyaE283htlGhug%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 20">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=932126" aria-label="PubMed reference 20">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 20" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%20role%20of%20tutoring%20in%20problem-solving&journal=J.%20Child%20Psychol.%20Psychiatry&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1469-7610.1976.tb00381.x&volume=17&issue=2&pages=89-100&publication_year=1976&author=Wood%2CD&author=Bruner%2CJS&author=Ross%2CG">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="21."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR21">Shute, V. J. Focus on formative feedback. <i>Rev. Educ. Res.</i> <b>78</b>(1), 153–189 (2008).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.3102/0034654307313795" data-track-item_id="10.3102/0034654307313795" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.3102%2F0034654307313795" aria-label="Article reference 21" data-doi="10.3102/0034654307313795">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 21" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Focus%20on%20formative%20feedback&journal=Rev.%20Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.3102%2F0034654307313795&volume=78&issue=1&pages=153-189&publication_year=2008&author=Shute%2CVJ">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="22."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR22">Tatum, B. C. & Lenel, J. C. A Comparison of self-paced and lecture/discussion methods in an accelerated learning format. <i>J. Res. Innov. Teach</i>. <b>5</b>(1), (2012).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="23."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR23">Meyer, J. G. et al. ChatGPT and large language models in academia: Opportunities and challenges. <i>BioData Min.</i> <b>16</b>(1), 20–20. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9">https://doi.org/10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9</a> (2023).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="noopener" data-track-label="10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9" data-track-item_id="10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9" aria-label="Article reference 23" data-doi="10.1186/s13040-023-00339-9">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=37443040" aria-label="PubMed reference 23">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10339472" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 23">PubMed Central</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 23" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=ChatGPT%20and%20large%20language%20models%20in%20academia%3A%20Opportunities%20and%20challenges&journal=BioData%20Min.&doi=10.1186%2Fs13040-023-00339-9&volume=16&issue=1&pages=20-20&publication_year=2023&author=Meyer%2CJG&author=Urbanowicz%2CRJ&author=Martin%2CPCN&author=O%27Connor%2CK&author=Li%2CR&author=Peng%2CP-C&author=Bright%2CTJ&author=Tatonetti%2CN&author=Won%2CKJ&author=Gonzalez-Hernandez%2CG&author=Moore%2CJH">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="24."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR24">Nye, M. et al. Show your work: Scratchpads for intermediate computation with language models. <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.00114" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.00114">arXiv:2112.00114</a> (2021).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="25."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR25">Krupp, L., Steinert, S., Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, M., Avila, K. E., Lukowicz, P., Kuhn, J., Küchemann, S., & Karolus, J., Unreflected acceptance—investigating the negative consequences of ChatGPT-assisted problem solving in physics education. In <i>HHAI 2024: Hybrid Human AI Systems for the Social Good, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications</i>, Vol. 386, 199–212. IOS Press (2024).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="26."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR26">Clark, R. C. & Mayer, R. E. e-Learning and the science of instruction. In <i>E-learning and the Science of Instruction: Proven Guidelines for Consumers and Designers of Multimedia Learning</i>. Center for Creative Leadership (2011).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="27."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR27">Francis, G. E., Adams, J. P. & Noonan, E. J. Do they stay fixed?. <i>Phys. Teach.</i> <b>36</b>, 488–490 (1998).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.879933" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.879933" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.879933" aria-label="Article reference 27" data-doi="10.1119/1.879933">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1998PhTea..36..488F" aria-label="ADS reference 27">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 27" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Do%20they%20stay%20fixed%3F&journal=Phys.%20Teach.&doi=10.1119%2F1.879933&volume=36&pages=488-490&publication_year=1998&author=Francis%2CGE&author=Adams%2CJP&author=Noonan%2CEJ">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="28."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR28">McDermott, L. C., Heron, P. R. L., Shaffer, P. S., & Stetzer, M. S. Improving the preparation of K-12 teachers through physics education research. <i>Am. J. Phys.</i> <b>74</b>, 763–767 (2006).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.2209244" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.2209244" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.2209244" aria-label="Article reference 28" data-doi="10.1119/1.2209244">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2006AmJPh..74..763M" aria-label="ADS reference 28">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 28" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Improving%20the%20preparation%20of%20K-12%20teachers%20through%20physics%20education%20research&journal=Am.%20J.%20Phys.&doi=10.1119%2F1.2209244&volume=74&pages=763-767&publication_year=2006&author=McDermott%2CLC&author=Heron%2CPRL&author=Shaffer%2CPS&author=Stetzer%2CMS">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="29."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR29">Caballero, M. D. et al. Comparing large lecture mechanics curricula using the Force Concept Inventory: A five thousand student study. <i>Am. J. Phys.</i> <b>80</b>(7), 638–644 (2012).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.3703517" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.3703517" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.3703517" aria-label="Article reference 29" data-doi="10.1119/1.3703517">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2012AmJPh..80..638C" aria-label="ADS reference 29">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 29" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Comparing%20large%20lecture%20mechanics%20curricula%20using%20the%20Force%20Concept%20Inventory%3A%20A%20five%20thousand%20student%20study&journal=Am.%20J.%20Phys.&doi=10.1119%2F1.3703517&volume=80&issue=7&pages=638-644&publication_year=2012&author=Caballero%2CMD">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="30."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR30">Hake, R. R. Interactive-engagement versus traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses. <i>Am. J. Phys.</i> <b>66</b>, 64–74 (1998).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1119/1.18809" data-track-item_id="10.1119/1.18809" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1119%2F1.18809" aria-label="Article reference 30" data-doi="10.1119/1.18809">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1998AmJPh..66...64H" aria-label="ADS reference 30">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 30" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Interactive-engagement%20versus%20traditional%20methods%3A%20A%20six-thousand-student%20survey%20of%20mechanics%20test%20data%20for%20introductory%20physics%20courses&journal=Am.%20J.%20Phys.&doi=10.1119%2F1.18809&volume=66&pages=64-74&publication_year=1998&author=Hake%2CRR">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="31."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR31">Perkins, K. K., Adams, W. K., Pollock, S. J., Finkelstein, N. D., & Wieman, C. E. Correlating student beliefs with student learning using the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey. <i>AIP Conf. Proc.</i> <b>790</b>, 61–64 (2005).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1063/1.2084701" data-track-item_id="10.1063/1.2084701" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1063%2F1.2084701" aria-label="Article reference 31" data-doi="10.1063/1.2084701">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2005AIPC..790...61P" aria-label="ADS reference 31">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 31" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Correlating%20student%20beliefs%20with%20student%20learning%20using%20the%20Colorado%20learning%20attitudes%20about%20science%20survey&journal=AIP%20Conf.%20Proc.&doi=10.1063%2F1.2084701&volume=790&pages=61-64&publication_year=2005&author=Perkins%2CKK&author=Adams%2CWK&author=Pollock%2CSJ&author=Finkelstein%2CND&author=Wieman%2CCE">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="32."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR32">McCarty, L. S. & Deslauriers, L. Transforming a large university physics course to student-centered learning, without sacrificing content: A case study. In <i>The Routledge International Handbook of Student-Centered Learning and Teaching in Higher Education</i>, 186–200 (Routledge, 2020).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="33."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR33">Miller, K., Callaghan, K., McCarty, L. S. & Deslauriers, L. Increasing the effectiveness of active learning using deliberate practice: A homework transformation. <i>Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res.</i> <b>17</b>(1), 010129 (2021).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010129" data-track-item_id="10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010129" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1103%2FPhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010129" aria-label="Article reference 33" data-doi="10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010129">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 33" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Increasing%20the%20effectiveness%20of%20active%20learning%20using%20deliberate%20practice%3A%20A%20homework%20transformation&journal=Phys.%20Rev.%20Phys.%20Educ.%20Res.&doi=10.1103%2FPhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010129&volume=17&issue=1&publication_year=2021&author=Miller%2CK&author=Callaghan%2CK&author=McCarty%2CLS&author=Deslauriers%2CL">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="34."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR34">Freeman, S. et al. Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. <i>Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.</i> <b>111</b>(23), 8410–8415 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1073/pnas.1319030111" data-track-item_id="10.1073/pnas.1319030111" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1073%2Fpnas.1319030111" aria-label="Article reference 34" data-doi="10.1073/pnas.1319030111">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2014PNAS..111.8410F" aria-label="ADS reference 34">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXnsl2ms7c%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 34">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=24821756" aria-label="PubMed reference 34">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4060654" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 34">PubMed Central</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 34" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Active%20learning%20increases%20student%20performance%20in%20science%2C%20engineering%2C%20and%20mathematics&journal=Proc.%20Natl.%20Acad.%20Sci.&doi=10.1073%2Fpnas.1319030111&volume=111&issue=23&pages=8410-8415&publication_year=2014&author=Freeman%2CS&author=Eddy%2CSL&author=McDonough%2CM&author=Smith%2CMK&author=Okoroafor%2CN&author=Jordt%2CH&author=Wenderoth%2CMP">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="35."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR35">Deslauriers, L., McCarty, L. S., Miller, K., Callaghan, K. & Kestin, G. Measuring actual learning versus feeling of learning in response to being actively engaged in the classroom. <i>Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.</i> <b>116</b>(39), 19251–19257 (2019).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1073/pnas.1821936116" data-track-item_id="10.1073/pnas.1821936116" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1073%2Fpnas.1821936116" aria-label="Article reference 35" data-doi="10.1073/pnas.1821936116">Article</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2019PNAS..11619251D" aria-label="ADS reference 35">ADS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC1MXhvVGgu7fO" aria-label="CAS reference 35">CAS</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=31484770" aria-label="PubMed reference 35">PubMed</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6765278" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 35">PubMed Central</a>
|
||
<a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 35" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Measuring%20actual%20learning%20versus%20feeling%20of%20learning%20in%20response%20to%20being%20actively%20engaged%20in%20the%20classroom&journal=Proc.%20Natl.%20Acad.%20Sci.&doi=10.1073%2Fpnas.1821936116&volume=116&issue=39&pages=19251-19257&publication_year=2019&author=Deslauriers%2CL&author=McCarty%2CLS&author=Miller%2CK&author=Callaghan%2CK&author=Kestin%2CG">
|
||
Google Scholar</a>
|
||
</p></li></ol><p class="c-article-references__download u-hide-print"><a data-track="click" data-track-action="download citation references" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow" href="https://citation-needed.springer.com/v2/references/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6?format=refman&flavour=references">Download references<svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-download-medium"></use></svg></a></p></div></div></div></section></div><section data-title="Acknowledgements"><div class="c-article-section" id="Ack1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Ack1">Acknowledgements</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Ack1-content"><p>Acknowledgments: We wish to thank Logan McCarty for thoughtful comments, conversations, insights, and edits as well as for his general support for the project. Carl Weiman, Chris Stubbs, David Prichard, and Phillip Sadler provided valuable input on this manuscript. We are grateful to Louis Deslauriers for supportively sharing his expertise and insight across many collaborations. Videos included in the AI-supported lessons were recorded through the Harvard University Derek Bok Center’s Learning Lab with support of Marlon Kuzmick, Danielle Duke, and Casey Cann. Demonstration videos were set up and recorded by Harvard’s Natural Sciences Lecture Demonstration Group, Daniel Davis, Allen Crockett, and Daniel Rosenberg. Nene Zhvania helped in transferring content into the AI tutor platform. We also wish to acknowledge ChatGPT, which was used for surface-level grammatical input.</p></div></div></section><section aria-labelledby="author-information" data-title="Author information"><div class="c-article-section" id="author-information-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="author-information">Author information</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="author-information-content"><span class="c-article-author-information__subtitle u-visually-hidden" id="author-notes">Author notes</span><ol class="c-article-author-information__list"><li class="c-article-author-information__item" id="na1"><p>Greg Kestin and Kelly Miller contributed equally to this work.</p></li></ol><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="affiliations">Authors and Affiliations</h3><ol class="c-article-author-affiliation__list"><li id="Aff1"><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__address">Department of Physics, Harvard University, 17 Oxford Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA</p><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__authors-list">Greg Kestin, Anna Klales, Timothy Milbourne & Gregorio Ponti</p></li><li id="Aff2"><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__address">School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, 29 Oxford Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA</p><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__authors-list">Kelly Miller</p></li></ol><div class="u-js-hide u-hide-print" data-test="author-info"><span class="c-article__sub-heading">Authors</span><ol class="c-article-authors-search u-list-reset"><li id="auth-Greg-Kestin-Aff1"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Greg Kestin</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Greg%20Kestin" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text"><span class="c-article-authors-search__links-text">Search author on:</span><span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Greg%20Kestin" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Greg%20Kestin%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Kelly-Miller-Aff2"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Kelly Miller</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Kelly%20Miller" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text"><span class="c-article-authors-search__links-text">Search author on:</span><span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Kelly%20Miller" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Kelly%20Miller%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Anna-Klales-Aff1"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Anna Klales</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Anna%20Klales" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text"><span class="c-article-authors-search__links-text">Search author on:</span><span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Anna%20Klales" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Anna%20Klales%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Timothy-Milbourne-Aff1"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Timothy Milbourne</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Timothy%20Milbourne" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text"><span class="c-article-authors-search__links-text">Search author on:</span><span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Timothy%20Milbourne" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Timothy%20Milbourne%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Gregorio-Ponti-Aff1"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Gregorio Ponti</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Gregorio%20Ponti" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text"><span class="c-article-authors-search__links-text">Search author on:</span><span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Gregorio%20Ponti" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Gregorio%20Ponti%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li></ol></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="contributions">Contributions</h3><p>Conceptualization: G.K., K.M., A.K., T.W.M. Methodology: G.K., K.M., A.K., G.P. Software Conceptualization and Design: G.K. Software Engineering: G.K. Project Administration: G.K. Validation: G.K., K.M. Formal Analysis: G.K., K.M. Investigation: G.K., K.M., T.W.M., G.P. Data Curation: G.K., K.M. Writing—Original Draft: G.K., K.M. Writing—Review & Editing: G.K., K.M., A.K., G.P. Supervision: G.K., K.M.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="corresponding-author">Corresponding author</h3><p id="corresponding-author-list">Correspondence to
|
||
<a id="corresp-c1" aria-label="email Greg Kestin" href="mailto:Kestin@fas.Harvard.edu">Greg Kestin</a>.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Ethics declarations"><div class="c-article-section" id="ethics-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="ethics">Ethics declarations</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="ethics-content">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="FPar1">Competing interests</h3>
|
||
<p>The authors declare no competing interests.</p>
|
||
|
||
</div></div></section><section data-title="Additional information"><div class="c-article-section" id="additional-information-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="additional-information">Additional information</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="additional-information-content"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading">Publisher’s note</h3><p>Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Electronic supplementary material"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec31-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec31">Electronic supplementary material</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec31-content"><div data-test="supplementary-info"><div id="figshareContainer" class="c-article-figshare-container" data-test="figshare-container"></div><p>Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.</p><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM1"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="supplementary material 1." href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6/MediaObjects/41598_2025_97652_MOESM1_ESM.docx" data-supp-info-image="">Supplementary Material 1. (download DOCX <svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-download-medium"></use></svg>)</a></h3></div></div></div></div></section><section data-title="Rights and permissions"><div class="c-article-section" id="rightslink-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="rightslink">Rights and permissions</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="rightslink-content">
|
||
<p><b>Open Access</b> This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, which permits any non-commercial use, sharing, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if you modified the licensed material. You do not have permission under this licence to share adapted material derived from this article or parts of it. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit <a href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" rel="license">http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/</a>.</p>
|
||
<p class="c-article-rights"><a data-track="click" data-track-action="view rights and permissions" data-track-label="link" href="https://s100.copyright.com/AppDispatchServlet?title=AI%20tutoring%20outperforms%20in-class%20active%20learning%3A%20an%20RCT%20introducing%20a%20novel%20research-based%20design%20in%20an%20authentic%20educational%20setting&author=Greg%20Kestin%20et%20al&contentID=10.1038%2Fs41598-025-97652-6&copyright=The%20Author%28s%29&publication=2045-2322&publicationDate=2025-06-03&publisherName=SpringerNature&orderBeanReset=true&oa=CC%20BY-NC-ND">Reprints and permissions</a></p></div></div></section><section aria-labelledby="article-info" data-title="About this article"><div class="c-article-section" id="article-info-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="article-info">About this article</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="article-info-content"><div class="c-bibliographic-information"><div class="u-hide-print c-bibliographic-information__column c-bibliographic-information__column--border"><a data-crossmark="10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6" target="_blank" rel="noopener" href="https://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6" data-track="click" data-track-action="Click Crossmark" data-track-label="link" data-test="crossmark"><img loading="lazy" width="57" height="81" alt="Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark" src=""></a></div><div class="c-bibliographic-information__column"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="citeas">Cite this article</h3><p class="c-bibliographic-information__citation">Kestin, G., Miller, K., Klales, A. <i>et al.</i> AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting.
|
||
<i>Sci Rep</i> <b>15</b>, 17458 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6</p><p class="c-bibliographic-information__download-citation u-hide-print"><a data-test="citation-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="download article citation" data-track-label="link" data-track-external="" rel="nofollow" href="https://citation-needed.springer.com/v2/references/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6?format=refman&flavour=citation">Download citation<svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-download-medium"></use></svg></a></p><ul class="c-bibliographic-information__list" data-test="publication-history"><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Received<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2025-03-25">25 March 2025</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Accepted<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2025-04-07">07 April 2025</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Published<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2025-06-03">03 June 2025</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Version of record<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2025-06-03">03 June 2025</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item c-bibliographic-information__list-item--full-width"><p><abbr title="Digital Object Identifier">DOI</abbr><span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value">https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6</span></p></li></ul><div data-component="share-box"><div class="c-article-share-box u-display-none" hidden=""><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading">Share this article</h3><p class="c-article-share-box__description">Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:</p><button class="js-get-share-url c-article-share-box__button" type="button" id="get-share-url" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-external="" data-track-action="get shareable link">Get shareable link</button><div class="js-no-share-url-container u-display-none" hidden=""><p class="js-c-article-share-box__no-sharelink-info c-article-share-box__no-sharelink-info">Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.</p></div><div class="js-share-url-container u-display-none" hidden=""><p class="js-share-url c-article-share-box__only-read-input" id="share-url" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="select share url"></p><button class="js-copy-share-url c-article-share-box__button--link-like" type="button" id="copy-share-url" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="copy share url" data-track-external="">Copy shareable link to clipboard</button></div><p class="js-c-article-share-box__additional-info c-article-share-box__additional-info">
|
||
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
|
||
</p></div></div><div data-component="article-info-list"></div></div></div></div></div></section>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<section>
|
||
<div class="c-article-section js-article-section" id="further-reading-section" data-test="further-reading-section">
|
||
<h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="further-reading">This article is cited by</h2>
|
||
<div class="c-article-section__content js-collapsible-section" id="further-reading-content">
|
||
<ul class="c-article-further-reading__list" id="further-reading-list">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item">
|
||
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title">
|
||
<a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article"
|
||
data-track-label="link:From AI as a Relational Breaker to a Relational Broker: Comment on Bauer et al. (2025)" href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-025-10106-3">
|
||
From AI as a Relational Breaker to a Relational Broker: Comment on Bauer et al. (2025)
|
||
</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<ul data-test="author-list" class="app-author-list app-author-list--compact u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto">
|
||
<li>Gabriel Velez</li><li>Larry Zhiming Xu</li><li>Jacklynn Fitzgerald</li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
|
||
<p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>Educational Psychology Review</i> (2026)</p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item">
|
||
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title">
|
||
<a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article"
|
||
data-track-label="link:Universities are embracing AI: will students get smarter or stop thinking?" href="https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-025-03340-w">
|
||
Universities are embracing AI: will students get smarter or stop thinking?
|
||
</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<ul data-test="author-list" class="app-author-list app-author-list--compact u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto">
|
||
<li>Helen Pearson</li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
|
||
<p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>Nature</i> (2025)</p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item">
|
||
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title">
|
||
<a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article"
|
||
data-track-label="link:Tacit knowledge in large language models" href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s11138-025-00710-5">
|
||
Tacit knowledge in large language models
|
||
</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<ul data-test="author-list" class="app-author-list app-author-list--compact u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto">
|
||
<li>Janna Lu</li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
|
||
<p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>The Review of Austrian Economics</i> (2025)</p>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</section>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</article>
|
||
</main>
|
||
|
||
<aside class="c-article-extras u-hide-print" aria-label="Article navigation" data-component-reading-companion data-container-type="reading-companion" data-track-component="reading companion">
|
||
<div class="u-mb-48 js-context-bar-sticky-point-desktop" data-track-context="reading companion">
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-pdf-download u-clear-both js-pdf-download">
|
||
<a href="/articles/s41598-025-97652-6.pdf" class="u-button u-button--full-width u-button--primary u-justify-content-space-between c-pdf-download__link" data-article-pdf="true" data-readcube-pdf-url="true" data-test="download-pdf" data-draft-ignore="true" data-track="content_download" data-track-type="article pdf download" data-track-action="download pdf" data-track-label="link" data-track-external download>
|
||
<span class="c-pdf-download__text">Download PDF</span>
|
||
<svg aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" width="16" height="16" class="u-icon"><use xlink:href="#icon-download"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-associated-content__container">
|
||
<section>
|
||
<h2 class="c-article-associated-content__title u-mb-24">Associated content</h2>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-article-associated-content__collection collection u-mb-24">
|
||
<section>
|
||
<p class="c-article-associated-content__collection-label u-sans-serif u-text-bold u-mb-8">Collection</p>
|
||
<h3 class="c-article-associated-content__collection-title u-h3 u-mb-8">
|
||
<a href="https://www.nature.com/collections/jcejfhfjic"
|
||
class="u-link-inherit"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="view collection"
|
||
data-track-category="associated content"
|
||
data-track-label="collection"
|
||
data-test="collection-link">AI in Education</a>
|
||
</h3>
|
||
</section>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</section>
|
||
</div>
|
||
<script>
|
||
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
|
||
window.dataLayer[0] = window.dataLayer[0] || {};
|
||
window.dataLayer[0].content = window.dataLayer[0].content || {};
|
||
window.dataLayer[0].content.associatedContentTypes = "collection";
|
||
window.dataLayer[0].content.collections = "jcejfhfjic";
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-reading-companion">
|
||
<div class="c-reading-companion__sticky" data-component="reading-companion-sticky" data-test="reading-companion-sticky">
|
||
<div class="c-reading-companion__panel c-reading-companion__sections c-reading-companion__panel--active" id="tabpanel-sections">
|
||
<div class="u-lazy-ad-wrapper u-mt-16 u-hide" data-component-mpu>
|
||
<div class="c-ad c-ad--300x250">
|
||
<div class="c-ad__inner">
|
||
<p class="c-ad__label">Advertisement</p>
|
||
|
||
<div id="div-gpt-ad-right-2"
|
||
class="div-gpt-ad advert medium-rectangle js-ad text-center hide-print grade-c-hide"
|
||
data-ad-type="right"
|
||
data-test="right-ad"
|
||
data-pa11y-ignore
|
||
data-gpt
|
||
data-gpt-unitpath="/285/scientific_reports/article"
|
||
data-gpt-sizes="300x250"
|
||
data-gpt-targeting="type=article;pos=right;artid=s41598-025-97652-6;doi=10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6;subjmeta=1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766;kwrd=Applied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology">
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
window.SN = window.SN || {};
|
||
window.SN.libs = window.SN.libs || {};
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads = window.SN.libs.ads || {};
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig = window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig || {};
|
||
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig['right'] = {
|
||
'pos': 'right',
|
||
'type': 'article',
|
||
'path': 's41598-025-97652-6'
|
||
};
|
||
|
||
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig['kwrd'] = 'Applied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology';
|
||
|
||
|
||
window.SN.libs.ads.slotConfig['subjmeta'] = '1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766';
|
||
|
||
|
||
</script>
|
||
<noscript>
|
||
<a href="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?iu=/285/scientific_reports/article&sz=300x250&c=-373998596&t=pos%3Dright%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41598-025-97652-6%26doi%3D10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6%26subjmeta%3D1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766%26kwrd%3DApplied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology">
|
||
<img data-test="gpt-advert-fallback-img"
|
||
src="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ad?iu=/285/scientific_reports/article&sz=300x250&c=-373998596&t=pos%3Dright%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41598-025-97652-6%26doi%3D10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6%26subjmeta%3D1595,25,378,477,631,639,705,766%26kwrd%3DApplied+physics,Learning+and+memory,Mathematics+and+computing,Physics,Psychology"
|
||
alt="Advertisement"
|
||
width="300"
|
||
height="250"></a>
|
||
</noscript>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div class="c-reading-companion__panel c-reading-companion__figures c-reading-companion__panel--full-width" id="tabpanel-figures"></div>
|
||
<div class="c-reading-companion__panel c-reading-companion__references c-reading-companion__panel--full-width" id="tabpanel-references"></div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</aside>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<nav class="c-header__dropdown" aria-labelledby="Explore-content" data-test="Explore-content" id="explore" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header">
|
||
<div class="c-header__container">
|
||
<h2 id="Explore-content" class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--js-hide">Explore content</h2>
|
||
<ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/research-articles"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="research articles"
|
||
data-track-label="link"
|
||
data-test="explore-nav-item">
|
||
Research articles
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/news-and-comment"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="news & comment"
|
||
data-track-label="link"
|
||
data-test="explore-nav-item">
|
||
News & Comment
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/collections"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="collections"
|
||
data-track-label="link"
|
||
data-test="explore-nav-item">
|
||
Collections
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/browse-subjects"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="subjects"
|
||
data-track-label="link"
|
||
data-test="explore-nav-item">
|
||
Subjects
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
<ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://www.facebook.com/scientificreports"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="facebook"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Follow us on Facebook
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://twitter.com/SciReports"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="twitter"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Follow us on X
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--hide-lg">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://journal-alerts.springernature.com/subscribe?journal_id=41598"
|
||
rel="nofollow"
|
||
data-track="nav_sign_up_for_alerts"
|
||
data-track-action="Sign up for alerts"
|
||
data-track-external
|
||
data-track-label="link (mobile dropdown)">Sign up for alerts<svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="18" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m4 10h2.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-3.08578644l-1.12132034 1.1213203c-.18753638.1875364-.29289322.4418903-.29289322.7071068v.1715729h14v-.1715729c0-.2652165-.1053568-.5195704-.2928932-.7071068l-1.7071068-1.7071067v-3.4142136c0-2.76142375-2.2385763-5-5-5-2.76142375 0-5 2.23857625-5 5zm3 4c0 1.1045695.8954305 2 2 2s2-.8954305 2-2zm-5 0c-.55228475 0-1-.4477153-1-1v-.1715729c0-.530433.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.4142135l1.41421356-1.4142136v-3c0-3.3137085 2.6862915-6 6-6s6 2.6862915 6 6v3l1.4142136 1.4142136c.3750727.3750727.5857864.8837805.5857864 1.4142135v.1715729c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1h-4c0 1.6568542-1.3431458 3-3 3-1.65685425 0-3-1.3431458-3-3z" fill="#fff"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--hide-lg">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/srep.rss"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="rss feed"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
<span>RSS feed</span>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</nav>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<nav class="c-header__dropdown" aria-labelledby="About-the-journal" id="about-the-journal" data-test="about-the-journal" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header">
|
||
<div class="c-header__container">
|
||
<h2 id="About-the-journal" class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--js-hide">About the journal</h2>
|
||
<ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/about"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="about scientific reports"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
About Scientific Reports
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/contact"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="contact"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Contact
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/journal-policies"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="journal policies"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Journal policies
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/guide-to-referees"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="guide to referees"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Guide to referees
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/calls-for-papers"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="calls for papers"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Calls for Papers
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/editorschoice"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="editor's choice"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Editor's Choice
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/highlights"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="journal highlights"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Journal highlights
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/open-access"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="open access fees and funding"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
Open Access Fees and Funding
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</nav>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<nav class="c-header__dropdown" aria-labelledby="Publish-with-us-label" id="publish-with-us" data-test="publish-with-us" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header">
|
||
<div class="c-header__container">
|
||
<h2 id="Publish-with-us-label" class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--js-hide">Publish with us</h2>
|
||
<ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack">
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/author-instructions"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="for authors"
|
||
data-track-label="link">
|
||
For authors
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link" data-test="nature-author-services"
|
||
data-track="nav_language_services"
|
||
data-track-context="header publish with us dropdown menu"
|
||
data-track-action="manuscript author services"
|
||
data-track-label="link manuscript author services"
|
||
href="https://authorservices.springernature.com/go/sn/?utm_source=For+Authors&utm_medium=Website_Nature&utm_campaign=Platform+Experimentation+2022&utm_id=PE2022">
|
||
Language editing services
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="/srep/open-access-funding"
|
||
data-test="funding-eligibility-link"
|
||
data-track="click_explore_funding"
|
||
data-track-context="header publish with us"
|
||
data-track-action="funding eligibility">Open access funding</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<li class="c-header__item c-header__item--keyline">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link"
|
||
href="https://author-welcome.nature.com/41598"
|
||
data-track="click_submit_manuscript"
|
||
data-track-context="submit link in Nature header dropdown menu"
|
||
data-track-action="submit manuscript"
|
||
data-track-label="link (publish with us dropdown menu)"
|
||
data-track-external
|
||
data-gtm-criteo="submit-manuscript">Submit manuscript<svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="18" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m15 0c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2v5.5c0 .27614237-.2238576.5-.5.5s-.5-.22385763-.5-.5v-5.5c0-.51283584-.3860402-.93550716-.8833789-.99327227l-.1166211-.00672773h-9v3c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-3v10c0 .5128358.38604019.9355072.88337887.9932723l.11662113.0067277h7.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-7.5c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-10.17157288c0-.53043297.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.41421356l3.82842712-3.82842712c.37507276-.37507276.88378059-.58578644 1.41421356-.58578644zm-.5442863 8.18867991 3.3545404 3.35454039c.2508994.2508994.2538696.6596433.0035959.909917-.2429543.2429542-.6561449.2462671-.9065387-.0089489l-2.2609825-2.3045251.0010427 7.2231989c0 .3569916-.2898381.6371378-.6473715.6371378-.3470771 0-.6473715-.2852563-.6473715-.6371378l-.0010428-7.2231995-2.2611222 2.3046654c-.2531661.2580415-.6562868.2592444-.9065605.0089707-.24295423-.2429542-.24865597-.6576651.0036132-.9099343l3.3546673-3.35466731c.2509089-.25090888.6612706-.25227691.9135302-.00001728zm-.9557137-3.18867991c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-6c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm-8.5-3.587-3.587 3.587h2.587c.55228475 0 1-.44771525 1-1zm8.5 1.587c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-6c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5z" fill="#fff"/></svg>
|
||
</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</nav>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script>
|
||
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
|
||
window.dataLayer.push({
|
||
page: {
|
||
content: {
|
||
fundingWidget: "true",
|
||
}
|
||
}
|
||
});
|
||
</script>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div id="search-menu" class="c-header__dropdown c-header__dropdown--full-width" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header">
|
||
<div class="c-header__container">
|
||
<h2 class="c-header__visually-hidden">Search</h2>
|
||
<form class="c-header__search-form" action="/search" method="get" role="search" autocomplete="off" data-test="inline-search">
|
||
<label class="c-header__heading" for="keywords">Search articles by subject, keyword or author</label>
|
||
<div class="c-header__search-layout c-header__search-layout--max-width">
|
||
<div>
|
||
<input type="text" required="" class="c-header__input" id="keywords" name="q" value="">
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div class="c-header__search-layout">
|
||
<div>
|
||
<label for="results-from" class="c-header__visually-hidden">Show results from</label>
|
||
<select id="results-from" name="journal" class="c-header__select">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<option value="" selected>All journals</option>
|
||
<option value="srep">This journal</option>
|
||
|
||
|
||
</select>
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div>
|
||
<button type="submit" class="c-header__search-button">Search</button>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</form>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-header__flush">
|
||
<a class="c-header__link" href="/search/advanced"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="advanced search" data-track-label="link">
|
||
Advanced search
|
||
</a>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<h3 class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--keyline">Quick links</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-header__list">
|
||
<li><a class="c-header__link" href="/subjects" data-track="click" data-track-action="explore articles by subject" data-track-label="link">Explore articles by subject</a></li>
|
||
<li><a class="c-header__link" href="/naturecareers" data-track="click" data-track-action="find a job" data-track-label="link">Find a job</a></li>
|
||
<li><a class="c-header__link" href="/authors/index.html" data-track="click" data-track-action="guide to authors" data-track-label="link">Guide to authors</a></li>
|
||
<li><a class="c-header__link" href="/authors/editorial_policies/" data-track="click" data-track-action="editorial policies" data-track-label="link">Editorial policies</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<footer class="composite-layer" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Periodical">
|
||
<meta itemprop="publisher" content="Springer Nature">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="u-mt-16 u-mb-16">
|
||
<div class="u-container">
|
||
<div class="u-display-flex u-flex-wrap u-justify-content-space-between">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-meta u-ma-0 u-flex-shrink">
|
||
<p class="c-meta__item c-meta__type u-mt-0">
|
||
<span itemprop="name">
|
||
Scientific Reports
|
||
</span>
|
||
(<i itemprop="alternateName">Sci Rep</i>)
|
||
</p>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<p class="c-meta__item u-mt-0">
|
||
<abbr title="International Standard Serial Number">ISSN</abbr> <span itemprop="issn">2045-2322</span> (online)
|
||
</p>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer">
|
||
<div class="u-hide-print" data-track-component="footer">
|
||
<h2 class="u-visually-hidden">nature.com footer links</h2>
|
||
<div class="c-footer__container">
|
||
<div class="c-footer__grid c-footer__group--separator">
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">About Nature Portfolio</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/npg_/company_info/index.html"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="about us"
|
||
data-track-label="link">About us</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/npg_/press_room/press_releases.html"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="press releases"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Press releases</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://press.nature.com/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="press office"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Press office</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://support.nature.com/support/home"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="contact us"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Contact us</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Discover content</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/siteindex"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="journals a-z"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Journals A-Z</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/subjects"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="article by subject"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Articles by subject</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.protocols.io/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="protocols.io"
|
||
data-track-label="link">protocols.io</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.natureindex.com/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature index"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Index</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Publishing policies</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/authors/editorial_policies"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="Nature portfolio policies"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature portfolio policies</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/nature-research/open-access"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="open access"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Open access</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Author & Researcher services</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/reprints"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="reprints and permissions"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Reprints & permissions</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/authors/research-data"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="data research service"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Research data</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://authorservices.springernature.com/language-editing/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="language editing"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Language editing</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://authorservices.springernature.com/scientific-editing/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="scientific editing"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Scientific editing</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://masterclasses.nature.com/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature masterclasses"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Masterclasses</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://solutions.springernature.com/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="research solutions"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Research Solutions</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Libraries & institutions</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/librarians/tools-services"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="librarian service and tools"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Librarian service & tools</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/librarians/manage-your-account/librarianportal"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="librarian portal"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Librarian portal</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/openresearch/about-open-access/information-for-institutions"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="open research"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Open research</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/librarians/recommend-to-your-library"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="Recommend to library"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Recommend to library</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Advertising & partnerships</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://partnerships.nature.com/product/digital-advertising/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="advertising"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Advertising</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://partnerships.nature.com/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="partnerships and services"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Partnerships & Services</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://partnerships.nature.com/media-kits/" data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="media kits" data-track-label="link">Media kits</a>
|
||
</li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://partnerships.nature.com/product/branded-content-native-advertising/"
|
||
data-track-action="branded content" data-track-label="link">Branded
|
||
content</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Professional development</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/immersive/natureawards/index.html"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature awards"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Awards</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/naturecareers/"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature careers"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Careers</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://conferences.nature.com"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature conferences"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature<span class="u-visually-hidden"> </span>
|
||
Conferences</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__group">
|
||
<h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Regional websites</h3>
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__list">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/natafrica"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature africa"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Africa</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="http://www.naturechina.com"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature china"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature China</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/nindia"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature india"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature India</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.natureasia.com/ja-jp"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature japan"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Japan</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/nmiddleeast"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="nature middle east"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Nature Middle East</a></li>
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div class="c-footer__container">
|
||
<ul class="c-footer__links">
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/privacy"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="privacy policy" data-track-label="link">Privacy
|
||
Policy</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/cookies"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="use of cookies" data-track-label="link">Use
|
||
of cookies</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item">
|
||
<button class="optanon-toggle-display c-footer__link" onclick="javascript:;"
|
||
data-cc-action="preferences" data-track="click" data-track-action="manage cookies"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Your privacy choices/Manage cookies
|
||
</button>
|
||
</li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/legal-notice"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="legal notice" data-track-label="link">Legal
|
||
notice</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link"
|
||
href="https://www.nature.com/info/accessibility-statement" data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-action="accessibility statement" data-track-label="link">Accessibility
|
||
statement</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/terms-and-conditions"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="terms and conditions"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Terms & Conditions</a></li>
|
||
<li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.springernature.com/ccpa"
|
||
data-track="click" data-track-action="california privacy statement"
|
||
data-track-label="link">Your US state privacy rights</a></li>
|
||
|
||
</ul>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-footer__container">
|
||
<a href="https://www.springernature.com/" class="c-footer__link">
|
||
<img src="/static/images/logos/sn-logo-white-c8f7a9c061.svg" alt="Springer Nature" loading="lazy" width="200" height="20"/>
|
||
</a>
|
||
<p class="c-footer__legal" data-test="copyright">© 2026 Springer Nature Limited</p>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div class="u-visually-hidden" aria-hidden="true">
|
||
|
||
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><defs><path id="a" d="M0 .74h56.72v55.24H0z"/></defs><symbol id="icon-access" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M14 8a1 1 0 0 1 1 1v7h2.5a.5.5 0 0 1 .5.5V18H0v-1.5a.5.5 0 0 1 .5-.5H3V9a1 1 0 1 1 2 0v7h8V9a1 1 0 0 1 1-1M6 8l2 1v5l-2 1zm6 0v7l-2-1V9zM9.573.401l7.036 4.925A.92.92 0 0 1 16.081 7H1.92a.92.92 0 0 1-.528-1.674L8.427.401a1 1 0 0 1 1.146 0M9 2.441 5.345 5h7.31z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-account" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M10.238 16.905a7.96 7.96 0 0 0 3.53-1.48c-.874-2.514-2.065-3.936-3.768-4.319V9.83a3.001 3.001 0 1 0-2 0v1.277c-1.703.383-2.894 1.805-3.767 4.319A7.96 7.96 0 0 0 9 17q.629 0 1.238-.095m4.342-2.172a8 8 0 1 0-11.16 0c.757-2.017 1.84-3.608 3.49-4.322a4 4 0 1 1 4.182 0c1.649.714 2.731 2.305 3.488 4.322M9 18A9 9 0 1 1 9 0a9 9 0 0 1 0 18"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-alert" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M4 10h2.5a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1H3.414l-1.121 1.121a1 1 0 0 0-.293.707V13h14v-.172a1 1 0 0 0-.293-.707L14 10.414V7A5 5 0 0 0 4 7zm3 4a2 2 0 1 0 4 0zm-5 0a1 1 0 0 1-1-1v-.172a2 2 0 0 1 .586-1.414L3 10V7a6 6 0 1 1 12 0v3l1.414 1.414A2 2 0 0 1 17 12.828V13a1 1 0 0 1-1 1h-4a3 3 0 0 1-6 0z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-broad" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M7.897 12.028v-7.69l-2.45 2.446c-.387.388-1.009.395-1.385.02a.986.986 0 0 1 0-1.397l4.123-4.118a.99.99 0 0 1 1.398 0l4.123 4.118a.976.976 0 0 1 .016 1.38.99.99 0 0 1-1.401-.002l-2.45-2.447v8.676c0 .541-.437.98-.985.982L.987 14a.987.987 0 1 1 0-1.972z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-down" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m3.283 11.53 4.031 4.176a.943.943 0 0 0 1.367 0l4.031-4.176c.378-.391.384-1.02.016-1.4a.94.94 0 0 0-1.37.003l-2.395 2.482V1L8.956.883C8.901.386 8.493 0 7.998 0s-.903.386-.959.883L7.033 1v11.615l-2.396-2.482c-.379-.393-.986-.4-1.354-.02a1.027 1.027 0 0 0 0 1.417"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-left" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M4.47 3.283.294 7.314a.943.943 0 0 0 0 1.367l4.176 4.031c.391.378 1.02.384 1.4.016a.94.94 0 0 0-.003-1.37L3.385 8.963H15l.117-.007c.497-.055.883-.463.883-.958s-.386-.903-.883-.959L15 7.033H3.385l2.482-2.396c.393-.379.4-.986.02-1.354a1.027 1.027 0 0 0-1.417 0"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-right" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m11.53 12.717 4.176-4.031a.943.943 0 0 0 0-1.367L11.53 3.288c-.391-.378-1.02-.384-1.4-.016a.94.94 0 0 0 .003 1.37l2.482 2.395H1l-.117.007C.386 7.099 0 7.507 0 8.002s.386.903.883.959L1 8.967h11.615l-2.482 2.396c-.393.379-.4.986-.02 1.354a1.027 1.027 0 0 0 1.417 0"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-sub" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M7.897 4.972v7.69l-2.45-2.446c-.387-.388-1.009-.395-1.385-.02a.986.986 0 0 0 0 1.397l4.123 4.118a.99.99 0 0 0 1.398 0l4.123-4.118a.976.976 0 0 0 .016-1.38.99.99 0 0 0-1.401.002l-2.45 2.447V3.986a.98.98 0 0 0-.985-.982L.987 3a.987.987 0 1 0 0 1.972z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-up" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12.717 4.47 8.686.294a.943.943 0 0 0-1.367 0L3.288 4.47c-.378.391-.384 1.02-.016 1.4a.94.94 0 0 0 1.37-.003l2.395-2.482V15l.007.117c.055.497.463.883.958.883s.903-.386.959-.883L8.967 15V3.385l2.396 2.482c.379.393.986.4 1.354.02a1.027 1.027 0 0 0 0-1.417"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-article" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M13 15V2.01q-.002-.011.001-.01H2v13.006c0 .548.446.994.994.994h10.274A2 2 0 0 1 13 15m-12 .006V2C1 1.445 1.447 1 1.999 1H13c.552 0 .999.452.999 1.01V5h3v9.991A2.003 2.003 0 0 1 15.006 17H2.994C1.894 17 1 16.107 1 15.006M14 6v9a1 1 0 0 0 2 0V6zM4 4h7v4H4zm1 1v2h5V5zM4 9h7v1H4zm0 2h7v1H4zm0 2h7v1H4z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-audio" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M13.096 13.559a.503.503 0 0 1-.707 0 .493.493 0 0 1 0-.702A5.41 5.41 0 0 0 13.998 9a5.41 5.41 0 0 0-1.609-3.856.493.493 0 0 1 0-.701.503.503 0 0 1 .708 0A6.4 6.4 0 0 1 15 9a6.4 6.4 0 0 1-1.904 4.559m2.123 2.102a.503.503 0 0 1-.707 0 .493.493 0 0 1 0-.7A8.37 8.37 0 0 0 17 9a8.37 8.37 0 0 0-2.488-5.96c-.195-.193-.195-.507 0-.7s.513-.194.708 0A9.36 9.36 0 0 1 18 9a9.36 9.36 0 0 1-2.78 6.661M1 11.976c-.552 0-1-.444-1-.992V7.016a.996.996 0 0 1 1-.992h2l5.42-3.84a1.005 1.005 0 0 1 1.395.231c.122.169.187.37.187.577v12.016a.996.996 0 0 1-1 .992c-.209 0-.412-.065-.582-.185L3 11.975zm0-.992h2.321l5.68 4.024V2.992l-5.68 4.024h-2.32z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-block" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M0 0h24v24H0z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-book" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M4 13V2h1v11h11V2H3a1 1 0 0 0-1 1v10.268A2 2 0 0 1 3 13zm12 1H3a1 1 0 0 0 0 2h13zm0 3H3a2 2 0 0 1-2-2V3a2 2 0 0 1 2-2h13a1 1 0 0 1 1 1v14a1 1 0 0 1-1 1M7.5 4h6a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-6a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1m1 2h4a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-4a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-broad" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M11 16.995v-7.8l-2.482 2.482c-.392.393-1.022.4-1.403.02a1 1 0 0 1 0-1.417l4.177-4.176a1 1 0 0 1 1.416 0l4.177 4.176a.99.99 0 0 1 .016 1.4 1 1 0 0 1-1.42-.003L13 9.195v8.8c0 .55-.443.995-.998.996L4 18.995a1 1 0 0 1 0-2z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-calendar" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12.5 0c.276 0 .5.215.5.49V1h2c1.107 0 2 .895 2 2v12c0 1.107-.895 2-2 2H3c-1.107 0-2-.895-2-2V3c0-1.107.895-2 2-2h1v1H3c-.554 0-1 .446-1 1v3h14V3c0-.554-.446-1-1-1h-2v1.51a.5.5 0 0 1-.5.49.49.49 0 0 1-.5-.49V.49a.5.5 0 0 1 .5-.49M16 7H2v8c0 .554.446 1 1 1h12c.554 0 1-.446 1-1zM5 13v1H4v-1zm3 0v1H7v-1zm3 0v1h-1v-1zm-6-2v1H4v-1zm3 0v1H7v-1zm6 0v1h-1v-1zm-3 0v1h-1v-1zM8 9v1H7V9zm6 0v1h-1V9zm-3 0v1h-1V9zM5.5 0c.276 0 .5.215.5.49V1h5v1H6v1.51a.5.5 0 0 1-.5.49.49.49 0 0 1-.5-.49V.49A.5.5 0 0 1 5.5 0"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-cart" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="M5 14a2 2 0 1 1 0 4 2 2 0 0 1 0-4m10 0a2 2 0 1 1 0 4 2 2 0 0 1 0-4M5 15a1 1 0 1 0 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0-2m10 0a1 1 0 1 0 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0-2M2.18 0a1 1 0 0 1 .98.804L3.4 2H16.76a1 1 0 0 1 .978 1.21l-1.29 5.986c-.102.468-.544.804-1.058.804H5.143c-.592 0-1.072.448-1.072 1 0 .513.414.936.947.993l.125.007h10.36a.498.498 0 0 1 0 .996L5.142 13C3.959 13 3 12.105 3 11c0-.663.345-1.25.877-1.614l-1.638-8.19a1 1 0 0 1-.02-.195L.5 1a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm14.532 3H3.599l1.205 6.025A2 2 0 0 1 5.143 9h10.27z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-less" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m5 3.414 3.293 3.293a1 1 0 0 0 1.414-1.414l-4-4a1 1 0 0 0-1.414 0l-4 4a1 1 0 0 0 1.414 1.414z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-more" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m5 6.586 3.293-3.293a1 1 0 0 1 1.414 1.414l-4 4a1 1 0 0 1-1.414 0l-4-4a1 1 0 1 1 1.414-1.414z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-right" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M4.706 4.033 2.292 1.637A.953.953 0 0 1 2.273.283a.98.98 0 0 1 1.378 0l4.063 4.031c.381.378.381.99 0 1.367L3.651 9.712a.97.97 0 0 1-1.362.016.96.96 0 0 1 .003-1.37l2.414-2.395L5.693 5z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-circle-fill" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M8 14A6 6 0 1 1 8 2a6 6 0 0 1 0 12"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-circle" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M8 12a4 4 0 1 0 0-8 4 4 0 0 0 0 8m0 2A6 6 0 1 1 8 2a6 6 0 0 1 0 12"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-citation" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M8.636 6a4 4 0 0 1 2.174 7.358 6.23 6.23 0 0 1 3.462 3.641h-1.077a5.22 5.22 0 0 0-2.769-2.718l-.79-.33v-1.023l.63-.41a3 3 0 1 0-3.26 0l.63.41v1.024l-.79.329a5.22 5.22 0 0 0-2.77 2.718H3a6.23 6.23 0 0 1 3.461-3.641A4 4 0 0 1 8.636 6m7.369-5C17.107 1 18 1.894 18 3.003v5.994A2 2 0 0 1 16.005 11L13 10.999v-1h3.005c.549 0 .995-.447.995-1.002V3.003A.997.997 0 0 0 16.005 2H1.995A1 1 0 0 0 1 3.003V9q0 1 1 1l2-.001v1H2c-1 0-2-1-2-2V3.004C0 1.897.893 1 1.995 1zM7.5 4a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-4a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm3 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-1a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm4 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-close" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M2.297 12.277a1.007 1.007 0 0 0 0 1.427 1.006 1.006 0 0 0 1.426 0L8 9.425l4.277 4.277a1.007 1.007 0 0 0 1.427 0 1.006 1.006 0 0 0 0-1.426L9.425 8l4.277-4.277a1.007 1.007 0 0 0 0-1.427 1.006 1.006 0 0 0-1.426 0L8 6.575 3.723 2.297a1.007 1.007 0 0 0-1.427 0 1.006 1.006 0 0 0 0 1.426L6.575 8z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-collections" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M15 4a2 2 0 0 1 2 2v9a2 2 0 0 1-2 2H7a2 2 0 0 1-2-2h1a1 1 0 0 0 .883.993L7 16h8a1 1 0 0 0 .993-.883L16 15V6a1 1 0 0 0-.883-.993L15 5h-1V4zm-4-3a2 2 0 0 1 2 2v9a2 2 0 0 1-2 2H3a2 2 0 0 1-2-2V3a2 2 0 0 1 2-2zm0 1H3a1 1 0 0 0-.993.883L2 3v9a1 1 0 0 0 .883.993L3 13h8a1 1 0 0 0 .993-.883L12 12V3a1 1 0 0 0-.883-.993zM9.5 9a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1h-5a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm0-2a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1h-5a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm0-2a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1h-5a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-compare" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12 3a6 6 0 1 1-3 11.197A6 6 0 1 1 9 3.803a5.96 5.96 0 0 1 3-.803M6 4a5 5 0 1 0 2.085 9.546C6.808 12.446 6 10.817 6 9s.808-3.446 2.084-4.546A5 5 0 0 0 6 4m6 0c-.744 0-1.45.162-2.085.454C11.192 5.554 12 7.183 12 9s-.808 3.446-2.084 4.546A5 5 0 1 0 12 4m-1.416 7H7.416q.236.538.585 1.001h1.998q.35-.463.585-1M11 9H7q.001.515.1 1.001h3.8q.099-.486.1-1.001m-.416-2H7.416A5 5 0 0 0 7.1 8h3.8a5 5 0 0 0-.316-1M9.001 5l-.083.063A5 5 0 0 0 8 6h2a5 5 0 0 0-.999-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-download-file" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M10.005 0c.55 0 1.318.323 1.707.712l4.576 4.576c.393.393.712 1.168.712 1.714v8.99C17 17.1 16.105 18 15.006 18H2.994A1.994 1.994 0 0 1 1 16.005V1.995C1 .893 1.887 0 3 0zm0 1H3c-.557 0-1 .443-1 .995v14.01c0 .55.445.995.994.995h12.012c.546 0 .994-.45.994-1.009V7.002c0-.283-.215-.803-.419-1.007L11.005 1.42c-.204-.204-.719-.419-1-.419M8.5 5c.276 0 .5.216.5.492v6.148l1.746-1.78a.497.497 0 0 1 .7-.006.5.5 0 0 1-.002.702l-2.591 2.591a.5.5 0 0 1-.706 0l-2.59-2.59a.5.5 0 0 1-.004-.704.49.49 0 0 1 .7.007L8 11.64V5.492C8 5.22 8.232 5 8.5 5"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-download" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12.998 13a.999.999 0 1 1 0 2H3.002A1.006 1.006 0 0 1 2 14c0-.557.449-1 1.002-1zM8 1c.552 0 1 .445 1 .996v6.802l2.482-2.482c.392-.393 1.022-.401 1.403-.02a1 1 0 0 1 0 1.417l-4.177 4.178a1 1 0 0 1-1.416 0L3.115 7.713a.99.99 0 0 1-.016-1.4 1 1 0 0 1 1.42.002L7 8.798V1.996C7 1.446 7.444 1 8 1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-editors" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M8.726 2.546A3 3 0 1 0 5.37 7.519l.63.409v1.024l-.79.329A5.22 5.22 0 0 0 2 14.099V15H1v-.901a6.22 6.22 0 0 1 3.825-5.741 4 4 0 1 1 4.976-6.213 5 5 0 0 0-1.075.4M6 17H5v-.901a6.22 6.22 0 0 1 3.825-5.741 4 4 0 1 1 4.349 0A6.22 6.22 0 0 1 17 16.099V17h-1v-.901a5.22 5.22 0 0 0-3.21-4.818l-.79-.33V9.929l.63-.409a3 3 0 1 0-3.26 0l.63.409v1.024l-.79.329A5.22 5.22 0 0 0 6 16.099z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-email" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M16.005 2A2 2 0 0 1 18 4.006v9.988A2 2 0 0 1 16.005 16H1.995A2 2 0 0 1 0 13.994V4.006A2 2 0 0 1 1.995 2zm0 1H1.995A1 1 0 0 0 1 4.006v9.988A1 1 0 0 0 1.995 15h14.01A1 1 0 0 0 17 13.994V4.006A1 1 0 0 0 16.005 3M16 5.557V7l-7 4-7-4V5.557l7 4z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-error" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 0a9 9 0 1 1 0 18A9 9 0 0 1 9 0m2.863 4.711L9 7.574 6.137 4.711a1.007 1.007 0 0 0-1.427 0 1.006 1.006 0 0 0 .001 1.426L7.574 9l-2.863 2.863a1.007 1.007 0 0 0 0 1.427 1.006 1.006 0 0 0 1.426-.001L9 10.426l2.863 2.863a1.007 1.007 0 0 0 1.427 0 1.006 1.006 0 0 0-.001-1.426L10.426 9l2.863-2.863a1.007 1.007 0 0 0 0-1.427 1.006 1.006 0 0 0-1.426.001"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-ethics" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m6.764 1.414.833-.833a1.984 1.984 0 0 1 2.806 0l.833.833A2 2 0 0 0 12.65 2H14a2 2 0 0 1 2 2v1.35a2 2 0 0 0 .586 1.414l.833.833a1.984 1.984 0 0 1 0 2.806l-.833.833A2 2 0 0 0 16 12.65V14a2 2 0 0 1-2 2h-1.35a2 2 0 0 0-1.414.586l-.833.833a1.984 1.984 0 0 1-2.806 0l-.833-.833A2 2 0 0 0 5.35 16H4a2 2 0 0 1-2-2v-1.35a2 2 0 0 0-.586-1.414l-.833-.833a1.984 1.984 0 0 1 0-2.806l.833-.833A2 2 0 0 0 2 5.35V4a2 2 0 0 1 2-2h1.35a2 2 0 0 0 1.414-.586M5.35 3H4a1 1 0 0 0-1 1v1.35a3 3 0 0 1-.879 2.121l-.833.833a.984.984 0 0 0 0 1.392l.833.833A3 3 0 0 1 3 12.65V14a1 1 0 0 0 1 1h1.35a3 3 0 0 1 2.121.879l.833.833a.984.984 0 0 0 1.392 0l.833-.833A3 3 0 0 1 12.65 15H14a1 1 0 0 0 1-1v-1.35a3 3 0 0 1 .879-2.121l.833-.833a.984.984 0 0 0 0-1.392l-.833-.833A3 3 0 0 1 15 5.35V4a1 1 0 0 0-1-1h-1.35a3 3 0 0 1-2.121-.879l-.833-.833a.984.984 0 0 0-1.392 0l-.833.833A3 3 0 0 1 5.35 3m3.587 11.496a1 1 0 0 1-.064.003 5.5 5.5 0 0 1-2.759-.816.5.5 0 0 1 .526-.85 4.5 4.5 0 0 0 2.256.666q.026 0 .052.004L9 13.5a4.5 4.5 0 0 0 3.493-7.338.5.5 0 1 1 .775-.631A5.5 5.5 0 0 1 9 14.5zm1.58-10.784a.5.5 0 0 1-.276.961 4.5 4.5 0 0 0-1.156-.172C6.527 4.5 4.5 6.503 4.5 9c0 .627.128 1.235.373 1.796a.5.5 0 1 1-.917.4A5.5 5.5 0 0 1 3.5 9c0-3.052 2.477-5.5 5.594-5.5.486.009.963.08 1.422.212m-1.977 6.41 2.698-2.946a.5.5 0 0 1 .762.648l-3.016 3.343a.5.5 0 0 1-.693.047L6.36 9.592A.5.5 0 1 1 7 8.824z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-expand"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M7.498 11.918a.997.997 0 0 0-.003-1.411.995.995 0 0 0-1.412-.003l-4.102 4.102v-3.51A1 1 0 0 0 .98 10.09.99.99 0 0 0 0 11.092V17c0 .554.448 1.002 1.002 1.002h5.907c.554 0 1.002-.45 1.002-1.003 0-.539-.45-.978-1.006-.978h-3.51zm3.005-5.835a.997.997 0 0 0 .003 1.412.995.995 0 0 0 1.411.003l4.103-4.103v3.51a1 1 0 0 0 1.001 1.006A.99.99 0 0 0 18 6.91V1.002A1 1 0 0 0 17 0h-5.907a1.003 1.003 0 0 0-1.002 1.003c0 .539.45.978 1.006.978h3.51z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-explore" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 17A8 8 0 1 0 9 1a8 8 0 0 0 0 16m0 1A9 9 0 1 1 9 0a9 9 0 0 1 0 18m0-2.5a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1 5.5 5.5 0 0 0 5.497-5.317.5.5 0 1 1 1 .032A6.5 6.5 0 0 1 9 15.5M8.71 2.506a.5.5 0 1 1 .043 1A5.5 5.5 0 0 0 3.5 9a.5.5 0 0 1-1 0 6.5 6.5 0 0 1 6.21-6.494m1.137 8.048-1.2-1.2a.5.5 0 1 1 .707-.708l1.2 1.2 1.6-4-4.506 1.802-1.803 4.507zM13.95 4.05l-2.67 6.673a1 1 0 0 1-.557.557L4.05 13.95l2.67-6.673a1 1 0 0 1 .557-.557z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-filter" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="M14.974 0C15.54 0 16 .448 16 1c0 .242-.09.476-.254.658L10.052 8v5.5a1 1 0 0 1-.41.8L7.59 15.8a1.044 1.044 0 0 1-1.437-.2 1 1 0 0 1-.205-.6V8L.254 1.658A.98.98 0 0 1 .35.248C.537.087.778 0 1.026 0zM9.052 8.5H6.947v6.491l.012.007.02.002.02-.007 2.054-1.5zM1.026 1l-.015.002L6.843 7.5h2.313l5.836-6.499z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-home" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m9 5-6 6v5h4v-4h4v4h4v-5zm7 6.586V16a1 1 0 0 1-1 1h-5v-4H8v4H3a1 1 0 0 1-1-1v-4.414a1 1 0 0 1-.707-.293l-.586-.586a1 1 0 0 1 0-1.414L9 1l8.293 8.293a1 1 0 0 1 0 1.414l-.586.586a1 1 0 0 1-.707.293M9 2.414 1.414 10l.586.586 7-7 7 7 .586-.586z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-image" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M10.005 0c.55 0 1.318.323 1.707.712l4.576 4.576c.393.393.712 1.168.712 1.714v8.99C17 17.1 16.105 18 15.006 18H2.994A1.994 1.994 0 0 1 1 16.005V1.995C1 .893 1.887 0 3 0zM6.508 10.175l-3.894 6.75a1 1 0 0 0 .38.075h10.603l-2.433-4.215-1.575 2.728zM15.006 17c.546 0 .994-.45.994-1.009V7.002c0-.283-.215-.803-.419-1.007L11.005 1.42c-.204-.204-.719-.419-1-.419H3c-.557 0-1 .443-1 .995v13.99l4.508-7.81 3.081 5.338 1.575-2.729L14.752 17zM12 6a2 2 0 1 1 0 4 2 2 0 0 1 0-4m0 1a1 1 0 1 0 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0-2"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-info" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 0a9 9 0 1 1 0 18A9 9 0 0 1 9 0m0 7H7.5l-.117.007a1 1 0 0 0-.112 1.967l.112.02L7.5 9H8v3h-.5l-.117.007a1 1 0 0 0-.857.764l-.02.112L6.5 13l.007.117a1 1 0 0 0 .764.857l.112.02L7.5 14h3l.117-.007a1 1 0 0 0 .112-1.967l-.112-.02L10.5 12H10V8l-.007-.117a1 1 0 0 0-.764-.857l-.112-.02zm0-3.25a1.25 1.25 0 1 0 0 2.5 1.25 1.25 0 0 0 0-2.5"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-institution" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M7 17v-2h4v2h2v-3H5v3zM4 6.998H2.474a.5.5 0 0 1-.339-.868l1.232-1.132H1V17h3v-2H1v-1h3v-1h1V8.997H4zm10 0v2h-1V13h1v1h3v1h-3v2h3V4.999h-2.37l1.232 1.132a.5.5 0 0 1-.338.868zm3-3a1 1 0 0 1 1 1V18H0V4.998a1 1 0 0 1 1-1h3.455L8.66.131a.5.5 0 0 1 .677 0l4.205 3.865zm-4 3H5v1h8zm-2 6.001h1V9h-1zm-1 0V9H8v4zm-3 0V9H6v4zm8-4a1 1 0 0 1 1 1v2h-2v-2a1 1 0 0 1 1-1m-12 0a1 1 0 0 1 1 1v2H2v-2a1 1 0 0 1 1-1m5.999-7.82L3.757 5.998H14.24zM9 4.998a1 1 0 1 1 0-2 1 1 0 0 1 0 2M8 16v1h2v-1z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-location" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9.395 16.269a32 32 0 0 0 2.333-2.53c1.402-1.702 2.432-3.362 2.936-4.872C14.886 8.2 15 7.574 15 7a6 6 0 0 0-6-6C5.636 1 3 3.602 3 7c0 .574.114 1.199.336 1.867.504 1.51 1.534 3.17 2.936 4.872A32 32 0 0 0 9 16.65zM9 18S2 12 2 7c0-4 3.134-7 7-7a7 7 0 0 1 7 7c0 5-7 11-7 11m0-8a3 3 0 1 1 0-6 3 3 0 0 1 0 6m0-1a2 2 0 1 0 0-4 2 2 0 0 0 0 4"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-minus" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M2 7h12c.552 0 1 .444 1 1 0 .552-.445 1-1 1H2c-.552 0-1-.444-1-1 0-.552.445-1 1-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-newsletter" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m9 11.848 2-1.143V9H7v1.705zm-3-1.714V8h6v2.134l3-1.714V2H3v6.42zM16 4.75l1.53.956a1 1 0 0 1 .47.848V15a2 2 0 0 1-2 2H2a2 2 0 0 1-2-2V6.554a1 1 0 0 1 .47-.848L2 4.75V2a1 1 0 0 1 1-1h12a1 1 0 0 1 1 1zm0 1.18V9l-7 4-7-4V5.93l-1 .624V15a1 1 0 0 0 1 1h14a1 1 0 0 0 1-1V6.554zM6 4h6v1H6zM5 6h8v1H5z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-orcid" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 1a8 8 0 1 1 0 16A8 8 0 0 1 9 1M6.099 6.273H4.68v7.171H6.1zm4.559.025H7.665v7.146h2.91q1.152 0 2.042-.445c.89-.445 1.051-.715 1.373-1.255q.484-.81.484-1.86 0-1.028-.481-1.852a3.3 3.3 0 0 0-1.35-1.278q-.87-.456-1.985-.456m-.19 1.08q1.182 0 1.88.67t.698 1.826q0 1.114-.693 1.803t-1.839.688H9.046V7.378zM5.382 3.667a.79.79 0 0 0-.577.253.8.8 0 0 0-.25.58q0 .336.25.59a.818.818 0 0 0 1.177.004.8.8 0 0 0 .25-.593q0-.351-.25-.593c-.25-.242-.366-.241-.6-.241"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-plus" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M2 7h5V2c0-.552.444-1 1-1 .552 0 1 .445 1 1v5h5c.552 0 1 .444 1 1 0 .552-.445 1-1 1H9v5c0 .552-.444 1-1 1-.552 0-1-.445-1-1V9H2c-.552 0-1-.444-1-1 0-.552.445-1 1-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-print" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M16.005 5H1.995A.997.997 0 0 0 1 6v6c0 .557.443 1 .995 1H3v-3h12v3h1.005c.55 0 .995-.447.995-1V6c0-.557-.443-1-.995-1M14 4V1.998C14 1.45 13.548 1 12.991 1H5.01C4.452 1 4 1.45 4 1.998V4zm1 10v2.002A2.005 2.005 0 0 1 12.991 18H5.01A2 2 0 0 1 3 16.002V14H1.995A1.99 1.99 0 0 1 0 12V6c0-1.105.893-2 1.995-2H3V1.998C3 .894 3.902 0 5.009 0h7.982C14.101 0 15 .898 15 1.998V4h1.005C17.107 4 18 4.887 18 6v6c0 1.105-.893 2-1.995 2zm-1-3H4v5.002c0 .555.447.998 1.009.998h7.982c.557 0 1.009-.45 1.009-.998zm-9 1h8v1H5zm0 2h5v1H5zm9-5a1 1 0 1 1 0-2 1 1 0 0 1 0 2"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-search" viewBox="0 0 22 22"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M21.697 20.261a1.03 1.03 0 0 1 .01 1.448 1.034 1.034 0 0 1-1.448-.01l-4.267-4.267A9.812 9.812 0 0 1 0 9.812a9.812 9.811 0 1 1 17.43 6.182zM9.812 18.222A8.41 8.41 0 1 0 9.81 1.403a8.41 8.41 0 0 0 0 16.82z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-social-facebook" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M6.004 20A2 2 0 0 1 4 18.006V5.994C4 4.893 4.895 4 5.994 4h12.012C19.107 4 20 4.895 20 5.994v12.012A1.99 1.99 0 0 1 17.997 20H15.04v-6.196h2.08l.31-2.415h-2.39V9.848c0-.7.194-1.176 1.196-1.176h1.28v-2.16l-.235-.025c-.344-.032-.95-.07-1.63-.07-1.843 0-3.105 1.125-3.105 3.191v1.781h-2.085v2.415h2.085V20z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-social-twitter" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M18.877 6.874a3.77 3.77 0 0 0 1.625-2.096 7.2 7.2 0 0 1-2.347.917A3.64 3.64 0 0 0 15.463 4.5c-2.04 0-3.693 1.696-3.693 3.786q0 .448.094.862C8.8 8.99 6.076 7.483 4.254 5.191c-.317.56-.5 1.211-.5 1.905 0 1.314.653 2.472 1.643 3.152a3.65 3.65 0 0 1-1.672-.473v.045c0 1.834 1.273 3.366 2.964 3.713a3.5 3.5 0 0 1-.975.133c-.236 0-.471-.023-.694-.067.471 1.507 1.832 2.604 3.45 2.633a7.3 7.3 0 0 1-4.59 1.62q-.446 0-.88-.051A10.3 10.3 0 0 0 8.661 19.5c6.793 0 10.506-5.771 10.506-10.775l-.009-.49A7.5 7.5 0 0 0 21 6.275a7.3 7.3 0 0 1-2.122.596z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-social-youtube" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m10.142 14.397-.001-5.193 4.863 2.606zm9.963-7.927c-.685-.737-1.452-.74-1.804-.783-2.519-.187-6.297-.187-6.297-.187-.008 0-3.786 0-6.305.187-.352.043-1.119.046-1.804.783-.54.56-.715 1.834-.715 1.834S3 9.8 3 11.296v1.402c0 1.496.18 2.991.18 2.991s.176 1.274.715 1.835c.685.736 1.585.713 1.985.79 1.44.142 6.12.186 6.12.186s3.782-.006 6.301-.193c.352-.043 1.119-.047 1.804-.783.539-.561.715-1.835.715-1.835s.18-1.495.18-2.991v-1.402c0-1.496-.18-2.992-.18-2.992s-.176-1.273-.715-1.834"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-subject-medicine" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12.5 8H6a3 3 0 0 0-3 3v1a3 3 0 0 0 3 3h1v-2h-.5a1.5 1.5 0 0 1 0-3H13a3 3 0 0 0 3-3V6a3 3 0 0 0-3-3h-2v2h1.5a1.5 1.5 0 0 1 0 3M7 7V6H3.5a2.5 2.5 0 0 1 0-5h1.028a3 3 0 0 1 1.342.317l1.133.567A2 2 0 0 1 11 2h2a4 4 0 0 1 4 4v1a4 4 0 0 1-4 4h-2v1h2a2 2 0 1 1 0 4h-2a2 2 0 1 1-4 0H6a4 4 0 0 1-4-4v-1a4 4 0 0 1 4-4zm0-2V2.943a2 2 0 0 1-.422-.154L5.422 2.21A2 2 0 0 0 4.528 2H3.5a1.5 1.5 0 0 0 0 3zm4 1v1h1.5a.5.5 0 1 0 0-1zm-1 1V2a1 1 0 1 0-2 0v5zm-2 4v5a1 1 0 0 0 2 0v-5zm3 2v2h2a1 1 0 0 0 0-2zm-4-1v-1h-.5a.5.5 0 1 0 0 1zM3.5 3h1a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1h-1a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-success" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 0a9 9 0 1 1 0 18A9 9 0 0 1 9 0m3.486 4.982-4.718 5.506L5.14 8.465a.99.99 0 0 0-1.423.133 1.06 1.06 0 0 0 .13 1.463l3.407 2.733a1 1 0 0 0 1.387-.133l5.385-6.334a1.06 1.06 0 0 0-.116-1.464.99.99 0 0 0-1.424.119"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-table" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M16.005 2A2 2 0 0 1 18 4.006v9.988A2 2 0 0 1 16.005 16l-4.006-.001L12 16h-1l-.001-.001h-5L6 16H5l-.001-.001L1.995 16A2 2 0 0 1 0 13.994V4.006A2 2 0 0 1 1.995 2zM4.999 7H1v6.994A1 1 0 0 0 1.995 15H5zm6 0h-5v8h5zm5.006-4h-4.006v3H17v1h-5.001v7.999l4.006.001A1 1 0 0 0 17 13.994V4.006A1 1 0 0 0 16.005 3M3.5 12a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-1a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm12 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm-6 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm-6-2a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-1a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm12 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm-6 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm-6-2a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1h-1a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm12 0a.5.5 0 1 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 1 1 0-1zm-6 0a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1h-2a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm1.499-5h-5v3h5zm-6 0H1.995A1 1 0 0 0 1 4.006V6h3.999z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-tick-circle" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12 2c5.523 0 10 4.477 10 10s-4.477 10-10 10S2 17.523 2 12 6.477 2 12 2m0 1a9 9 0 1 0 0 18 9 9 0 0 0 0-18m4.22 5.366c.361-.437.999-.49 1.424-.119s.477 1.028.115 1.465l-6.093 6.944a1 1 0 0 1-1.405.097l-3.897-3.367c-.43-.368-.487-1.023-.13-1.464s.994-.5 1.423-.133l3.111 2.7z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-tick" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M6.768 9.211 3.657 6.628c-.429-.352-1.066-.295-1.423.127s-.3 1.049.13 1.4l3.915 3.24a1 1 0 0 0 1.375-.096l6.105-6.66a.984.984 0 0 0-.115-1.402 1.02 1.02 0 0 0-1.424.113z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-update" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M1 13v1a1 1 0 0 0 1 1h14a1 1 0 0 0 1-1v-1h-1V3H2v10zm16-1h1v2a2 2 0 0 1-2 2H2a2 2 0 0 1-2-2v-2h1V3a1 1 0 0 1 1-1h14a1 1 0 0 1 1 1zm-1 0v1h-4.586l-1 1H7.586l-1-1H2v-1h5l1 1h2l1-1zM3 4h12v7H3zm1 1v5h10V5zm1 1h4v1H5zm0 2h4v1H5z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-upload" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M10.005 0c.55 0 1.318.323 1.707.712l4.576 4.576c.393.393.712 1.168.712 1.714v8.99C17 17.1 16.105 18 15.006 18H2.994A1.994 1.994 0 0 1 1 16.005V1.995C1 .893 1.887 0 3 0zm0 1H3c-.557 0-1 .443-1 .995v14.01c0 .55.445.995.994.995h12.012c.546 0 .994-.45.994-1.009V7.002c0-.283-.215-.803-.419-1.007L11.005 1.42c-.204-.204-.719-.419-1-.419M8.149 5.146a.5.5 0 0 1 .705 0l2.591 2.59c.195.196.19.516.003.704a.49.49 0 0 1-.7-.007l-1.746-1.78V12.8a.501.501 0 0 1-1 0V6.653l-1.747 1.78a.497.497 0 0 1-.7.006.5.5 0 0 1 .003-.702z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-video" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M16.005 2A2 2 0 0 1 18 4.006v9.988A2 2 0 0 1 16.005 16H1.995A2 2 0 0 1 0 13.994V4.006A2 2 0 0 1 1.995 2zm0 1H1.995A1 1 0 0 0 1 4.006v9.988A1 1 0 0 0 1.995 15h14.01A1 1 0 0 0 17 13.994V4.006A1 1 0 0 0 16.005 3m-8.31 2.25L12.3 7.99c.937.557.93 1.464 0 2.017l-4.604 2.74c-.937.557-1.696.165-1.696-.894v-5.71c0-1.05.767-1.446 1.696-.894m-.674.96v5.575c0 .3-.108.245.166.085l4.584-2.675c.305-.178.305-.216 0-.394L7.187 6.126c-.267-.156-.166-.207-.166.084"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-warning" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 11.75a1.25 1.25 0 1 1 0 2.5 1.25 1.25 0 0 1 0-2.5M9.413 4a1 1 0 0 1 1 1l-.003.083-.334 4A1 1 0 0 1 9.08 10h-.16a1 1 0 0 1-.996-.917l-.334-4a1 1 0 0 1 .914-1.08l.041-.002zM9 18A9 9 0 1 1 9 0a9 9 0 0 1 0 18"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-checklist-banner" viewBox="0 0 56.69 56.69"><path d="M0 0h56.69v56.69H0z" style="fill:none"/><clipPath id="b"><use xlink:href="#a" style="overflow:visible"/></clipPath><path d="M21.14 34.46c0-6.77 5.48-12.26 12.24-12.26s12.24 5.49 12.24 12.26-5.48 12.26-12.24 12.26c-6.76-.01-12.24-5.49-12.24-12.26zm19.33 10.66 10.23 9.22s1.21 1.09 2.3-.12l2.09-2.32s1.09-1.21-.12-2.3l-10.23-9.22m-19.29-5.92c0-4.38 3.55-7.94 7.93-7.94s7.93 3.55 7.93 7.94c0 4.38-3.55 7.94-7.93 7.94-4.38-.01-7.93-3.56-7.93-7.94zm17.58 12.99 4.14-4.81" style="clip-path:url(#b);fill:none;stroke:#01324b;stroke-width:2;stroke-linecap:round"/><path d="M8.26 9.75H28.6M8.26 15.98H28.6m-20.34 6.2h12.5m14.42-5.2V4.86s0-2.93-2.93-2.93H4.13s-2.93 0-2.93 2.93v37.57s0 2.93 2.93 2.93h15.01M8.26 9.75H28.6M8.26 15.98H28.6m-20.34 6.2h12.5" style="clip-path:url(#b);fill:none;stroke:#01324b;stroke-width:2;stroke-linecap:round;stroke-linejoin:round"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-down" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="m8 6.586 3.293-3.293a1 1 0 0 1 1.414 1.414l-4 4a1 1 0 0 1-1.414 0l-4-4a1 1 0 0 1 1.414-1.414z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-arrow-right-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m12.728 3.293 7.98 7.99a1 1 0 0 1 .281.561l.011.157c0 .32-.15.605-.384.788l-7.908 7.918a1 1 0 0 1-1.416-1.414L17.576 13H4a1 1 0 0 1 0-2h13.598l-6.285-6.293a1 1 0 0 1-.082-1.32l.083-.095a1 1 0 0 1 1.414.001"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-check-circle-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 1c6.075 0 11 4.925 11 11s-4.925 11-11 11S1 18.075 1 12 5.925 1 12 1m0 2a9 9 0 1 0 0 18 9 9 0 0 0 0-18m5.125 4.72a1 1 0 0 1 .156 1.405l-6 7.5a1 1 0 0 1-1.421.143l-3-2.5a1 1 0 0 1 1.28-1.536l2.217 1.846 5.362-6.703a1 1 0 0 1 1.406-.156Z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-down-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M2 7h5V2c0-.552.444-1 1-1 .552 0 1 .445 1 1v5h5c.552 0 1 .444 1 1 0 .552-.445 1-1 1H9v5c0 .552-.444 1-1 1-.552 0-1-.445-1-1V9H2c-.552 0-1-.444-1-1 0-.552.445-1 1-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-down-small" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="M13.692 5.278a1 1 0 0 1 .03 1.414L9.103 11.51a1.49 1.49 0 0 1-2.188.019L2.278 6.692a1 1 0 0 1 1.444-1.384L8 9.771l4.278-4.463a1 1 0 0 1 1.318-.111z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-right-medium" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M4.706 4.033 2.292 1.637A.953.953 0 0 1 2.273.283a.98.98 0 0 1 1.378 0l4.063 4.031c.381.378.381.99 0 1.367L3.651 9.712a.97.97 0 0 1-1.362.016.96.96 0 0 1 .003-1.37l2.414-2.395L5.693 5z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M4.706 4.033 2.292 1.637A.953.953 0 0 1 2.273.283a.98.98 0 0 1 1.378 0l4.063 4.031c.381.378.381.99 0 1.367L3.651 9.712a.97.97 0 0 1-1.362.016.96.96 0 0 1 .003-1.37l2.414-2.395L5.693 5z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-up-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M2 7h12c.552 0 1 .444 1 1 0 .552-.445 1-1 1H2c-.552 0-1-.444-1-1 0-.552.445-1 1-1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-close-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 1c6.075 0 11 4.925 11 11s-4.925 11-11 11S1 18.075 1 12 5.925 1 12 1m0 2a9 9 0 1 0 0 18 9 9 0 0 0 0-18M8.707 7.293 12 10.585l3.293-3.292a1 1 0 0 1 1.414 1.414L13.415 12l3.292 3.293a1 1 0 0 1-1.414 1.414L12 13.415l-3.293 3.292a1 1 0 1 1-1.414-1.414L10.585 12 7.293 8.707a1 1 0 0 1 1.414-1.414"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-copy-link" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M19.46 8.57a1 1 0 0 1 0-1.414l.833-.833A1.946 1.946 0 0 0 17.54 3.57l-.833.833a1 1 0 0 1-1.414-1.414l.833-.833a3.946 3.946 0 1 1 5.581 5.58l-.833.834a1 1 0 0 1-1.415 0" clip-rule="evenodd"/><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M18.094 5.906a1 1 0 0 1 0 1.414l-1.666 1.667a1 1 0 1 1-1.414-1.414l1.666-1.667a1 1 0 0 1 1.414 0" clip-rule="evenodd"/><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M13.511 6.322a1 1 0 0 1 0 1.415l-.833.833a1.946 1.946 0 1 0 2.752 2.752l.834-.833a1 1 0 0 1 1.414 1.414l-.834.834a3.946 3.946 0 1 1-5.58-5.581l.833-.834a1 1 0 0 1 1.414 0" clip-rule="evenodd"/><path d="M8 20v2h11.462c.674 0 1.32-.269 1.796-.747A2.55 2.55 0 0 0 22 19.455V15a1 1 0 1 0-2 0v4.455a.55.55 0 0 1-.16.387.54.54 0 0 1-.378.158z"/><path d="M4 13H2v6.462c0 .674.269 1.32.747 1.796A2.55 2.55 0 0 0 4.545 22H9a1 1 0 1 0 0-2H4.545a.55.55 0 0 1-.387-.16.54.54 0 0 1-.158-.378zM4 13H2V4.538c0-.674.269-1.32.747-1.796A2.55 2.55 0 0 1 4.545 2H9a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H4.545a.55.55 0 0 0-.387.16.54.54 0 0 0-.158.378z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-download-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12.998 13a.999.999 0 1 1 0 2H3.002A1.006 1.006 0 0 1 2 14c0-.557.449-1 1.002-1zM8 1c.552 0 1 .445 1 .996v6.802l2.482-2.482c.392-.393 1.022-.401 1.403-.02a1 1 0 0 1 0 1.417l-4.177 4.178a1 1 0 0 1-1.416 0L3.115 7.713a.99.99 0 0 1-.016-1.4 1 1 0 0 1 1.42.002L7 8.798V1.996C7 1.446 7.444 1 8 1"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-info-filled-medium" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 0a9 9 0 1 1 0 18A9 9 0 0 1 9 0m0 7H7.5l-.117.007a1 1 0 0 0-.112 1.967l.112.02L7.5 9H8v3h-.5l-.117.007a1 1 0 0 0-.857.764l-.02.112L6.5 13l.007.117a1 1 0 0 0 .764.857l.112.02L7.5 14h3l.117-.007a1 1 0 0 0 .112-1.967l-.112-.02L10.5 12H10V8l-.007-.117a1 1 0 0 0-.764-.857l-.112-.02zm0-3.25a1.25 1.25 0 1 0 0 2.5 1.25 1.25 0 0 0 0-2.5"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-institution-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M11.997 1c-.36 0-.718.09-1.036.265a1 1 0 0 0-.085.052L2.798 6.87a1.7 1.7 0 0 0-.72.897c-.13.389-.098.79.049 1.134C2.42 9.592 3.128 10 3.9 10H5v6h-.5A2.5 2.5 0 0 0 2 18.5v1A2.5 2.5 0 0 0 4.5 22h15a2.5 2.5 0 0 0 2.5-2.5v-1a2.5 2.5 0 0 0-2.5-2.5H19v-6h1.092c.773 0 1.48-.407 1.775-1.1.146-.344.178-.744.048-1.133a1.7 1.7 0 0 0-.72-.897l-8.078-5.553a1 1 0 0 0-.085-.052A2.15 2.15 0 0 0 11.997 1M4.684 8l7.263-4.992a.16.16 0 0 1 .1 0L19.308 8zM17 16v-6h-2v6zm-4 0v-6h-2v6zm-4 0v-6H7v6zm-5 2.5a.5.5 0 0 1 .5-.5h15a.5.5 0 0 1 .5.5v1a.5.5 0 0 1-.5.5h-15a.5.5 0 0 1-.5-.5z" clip-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-mail-medium" viewBox="0 0 22 18"><path d="M19.462 0C20.875 0 22 1.184 22 2.619v12.762C22 16.816 20.875 18 19.462 18H2.538C1.125 18 0 16.816 0 15.381V2.619C0 1.184 1.125 0 2.538 0zM20 5.158l-7.378 6.258a2.55 2.55 0 0 1-3.253-.008L2 5.16v10.222c0 .353.253.619.538.619h16.924c.285 0 .538-.266.538-.619zM19.462 2H2.538c-.264 0-.5.228-.534.542l8.65 7.334c.2.165.492.165.684.007l8.656-7.342-.001-.025c-.044-.3-.274-.516-.531-.516"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-marker-unfilled"><path d="M17.8 3.578c0-.248-.153-.4-.4-.4H6.5c-.248 0-.4.152-.4.4v17.046l5.325-3.737.135-.08a1 1 0 0 1 1.014.08l5.226 3.666zm2 17.527c0 .661-.347 1.231-.895 1.521a1.75 1.75 0 0 1-1.78-.102l-5.126-3.598-5.125 3.598-.06.039a1.84 1.84 0 0 1-1.73.084 1.7 1.7 0 0 1-.984-1.542V3.578c0-1.353 1.048-2.4 2.4-2.4h10.9c1.352 0 2.4 1.047 2.4 2.4z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-menu-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M21 4a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H3a1 1 0 1 1 0-2zm-4 7a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H3a1 1 0 0 1 0-2zm4 7a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H3a1 1 0 0 1 0-2z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-search-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M11 1c5.523 0 10 4.477 10 10 0 2.4-.846 4.604-2.256 6.328l3.963 3.965a1 1 0 0 1-1.414 1.414l-3.965-3.963A9.96 9.96 0 0 1 11 21C5.477 21 1 16.523 1 11S5.477 1 11 1m0 2a8 8 0 1 0 0 16 8 8 0 0 0 0-16"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-user-single-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 1a5 5 0 1 1 0 10 5 5 0 0 1 0-10m0 2a3 3 0 1 0 0 6 3 3 0 0 0 0-6m-.406 9.008a8.97 8.97 0 0 1 6.596 2.494A9.16 9.16 0 0 1 21 21.025V22a1 1 0 0 1-1 1H4a1 1 0 0 1-1-1v-.985c.05-4.825 3.815-8.777 8.594-9.007m.39 1.992-.299.006c-3.63.175-6.518 3.127-6.678 6.775L5 21h13.998l-.009-.268a7.16 7.16 0 0 0-1.97-4.573l-.214-.213A6.97 6.97 0 0 0 11.984 14"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-warning-filled-medium" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M9 11.75a1.25 1.25 0 1 1 0 2.5 1.25 1.25 0 0 1 0-2.5M9.413 4a1 1 0 0 1 1 1l-.003.083-.334 4A1 1 0 0 1 9.08 10h-.16a1 1 0 0 1-.996-.917l-.334-4a1 1 0 0 1 .914-1.08l.041-.002zM9 18A9 9 0 1 1 9 0a9 9 0 0 1 0 18"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-expand-image" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M7.498 11.918a.997.997 0 0 0-.003-1.411.995.995 0 0 0-1.412-.003l-4.102 4.102v-3.51A1 1 0 0 0 .98 10.09.99.99 0 0 0 0 11.092V17c0 .554.448 1.002 1.002 1.002h5.907c.554 0 1.002-.45 1.002-1.003 0-.539-.45-.978-1.006-.978h-3.51zm3.005-5.835a.997.997 0 0 0 .003 1.412.995.995 0 0 0 1.411.003l4.103-4.103v3.51a1 1 0 0 0 1.001 1.006A.99.99 0 0 0 18 6.91V1.002C18 .448 17.553 0 17 0h-5.907c-.554.001-1.002.45-1.002 1.003 0 .539.45.978 1.006.978h3.51z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-github" viewBox="0 0 100 100"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M48.854 0C21.839 0 0 22 0 49.217c0 21.756 13.993 40.172 33.405 46.69 2.427.49 3.316-1.059 3.316-2.362 0-1.141-.08-5.052-.08-9.127-13.59 2.934-16.42-5.867-16.42-5.867-2.184-5.704-5.42-7.17-5.42-7.17-4.448-3.015.324-3.015.324-3.015 4.934.326 7.523 5.052 7.523 5.052 4.367 7.496 11.404 5.378 14.235 4.074.404-3.178 1.699-5.378 3.074-6.6-10.839-1.141-22.243-5.378-22.243-24.283 0-5.378 1.94-9.778 5.014-13.2-.485-1.222-2.184-6.275.486-13.038 0 0 4.125-1.304 13.426 5.052a47 47 0 0 1 12.214-1.63c4.125 0 8.33.571 12.213 1.63 9.302-6.356 13.427-5.052 13.427-5.052 2.67 6.763.97 11.816.485 13.038 3.155 3.422 5.015 7.822 5.015 13.2 0 18.905-11.404 23.06-22.324 24.283 1.78 1.548 3.316 4.481 3.316 9.126 0 6.6-.08 11.897-.08 13.526 0 1.304.89 2.853 3.316 2.364 19.412-6.52 33.405-24.935 33.405-46.691C97.707 22 75.788 0 48.854 0" clip-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-orcid-logo" viewBox="0 0 40 40"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M12.281 10.453c.875 0 1.578-.719 1.578-1.578s-.703-1.578-1.578-1.578-1.578.703-1.578 1.578c0 .86.703 1.578 1.578 1.578m-1.203 18.641h2.406V12.359h-2.406z"/><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M17.016 12.36h6.5c6.187 0 8.906 4.421 8.906 8.374 0 4.297-3.36 8.375-8.875 8.375h-6.531zm6.234 14.578h-3.828V14.53h3.703c4.688 0 6.828 2.844 6.828 6.203 0 2.063-1.25 6.203-6.703 6.203Z" clip-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-springer-arrow-left"><path d="M15 7a1 1 0 0 0 0-2H3.385l2.482-2.482a.994.994 0 0 0 .02-1.403 1 1 0 0 0-1.417 0L.294 5.292a1 1 0 0 0 0 1.416l4.176 4.177a.99.99 0 0 0 1.4.016 1 1 0 0 0-.003-1.42L3.385 7z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-springer-arrow-right"><path d="M1 7a1 1 0 0 1 0-2h11.615l-2.482-2.482a.994.994 0 0 1-.02-1.403 1 1 0 0 1 1.417 0l4.176 4.177a1 1 0 0 1 0 1.416l-4.176 4.177a.99.99 0 0 1-1.4.016 1 1 0 0 1 .003-1.42L12.615 7z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-submit-open" viewBox="0 0 16 17"><path d="M12 0a2 2 0 0 1 2 2v5a.5.5 0 0 1-1 0V2a1 1 0 0 0-.883-.993L12 1H6v3a2 2 0 0 1-2 2H1v8a1 1 0 0 0 .883.993L2 15h6.5a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1H2a2 2 0 0 1-2-2V5.828a2 2 0 0 1 .586-1.414L4.414.586A2 2 0 0 1 5.828 0zm3.41 11.14c.25.25.25.66 0 .91a.636.636 0 0 1-.9-.01l-1.864-1.9.001 5.87a.64.64 0 0 1-.647.636.65.65 0 0 1-.647-.637l-.001-5.87L9.5 12.04a.627.627 0 0 1-.9.01.65.65 0 0 1 0-.91l2.942-2.951a.647.647 0 0 1 .914 0zM5 1.413 1.413 5H4a1 1 0 0 0 1-1zM11 3a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1H7.5a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1zm0 2a.5.5 0 0 1 0 1H7.5a.5.5 0 0 1 0-1z"/></symbol></svg>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</footer>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages message u-hide u-hide-print c-site-messages--nature-briefing c-site-messages--nature-briefing-email-variant c-site-messages--nature-briefing-redesign-2020 sans-serif "
|
||
data-component-id="nature-briefing-banner"
|
||
data-component-expirydays="30"
|
||
data-component-trigger-scroll-percentage="15"
|
||
data-track="in-view"
|
||
data-track-action="in-view"
|
||
data-track-category="nature briefing"
|
||
data-track-label="Briefing banner visible: Flagship">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages__banner-large">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages__close-container">
|
||
<button class="c-site-messages__close"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-category="nature briefing"
|
||
data-track-label="Briefing banner dismiss: Flagship">
|
||
<svg width="25px" height="25px" focusable="false" aria-hidden="true" viewBox="0 0 25 25" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
|
||
<title>Close banner</title>
|
||
<defs></defs>
|
||
<g stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
|
||
<rect opacity="0" x="0" y="0" width="25" height="25"></rect>
|
||
<path d="M6.29679575,16.2772478 C5.90020818,16.6738354 5.90240728,17.3100587 6.29617427,17.7038257 C6.69268654,18.100338 7.32864195,18.0973145 7.72275218,17.7032043 L12,13.4259564 L16.2772478,17.7032043 C16.6738354,18.0997918 17.3100587,18.0975927 17.7038257,17.7038257 C18.100338,17.3073135 18.0973145,16.671358 17.7032043,16.2772478 L13.4259564,12 L17.7032043,7.72275218 C18.0997918,7.32616461 18.0975927,6.68994127 17.7038257,6.29617427 C17.3073135,5.89966201 16.671358,5.90268552 16.2772478,6.29679575 L12,10.5740436 L7.72275218,6.29679575 C7.32616461,5.90020818 6.68994127,5.90240728 6.29617427,6.29617427 C5.89966201,6.69268654 5.90268552,7.32864195 6.29679575,7.72275218 L10.5740436,12 L6.29679575,16.2772478 Z" fill="#ffffff"></path>
|
||
</g>
|
||
</svg>
|
||
<span class="visually-hidden">Close</span>
|
||
</button>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages__form-container">
|
||
|
||
<div class="grid grid-12 last">
|
||
<div class="grid grid-4">
|
||
<img alt="Nature Briefing AI and Robotics" src="/static/images/logos/nature-briefing-ai-and-robotics-logo-e4d57f7fcd.svg" width="400" height="40">
|
||
<p class="c-site-messages--nature-briefing__strapline extra-tight-line-height">Sign up for the <em>Nature Briefing: AI and Robotics</em> newsletter — what matters in AI and robotics research, free to your inbox weekly.</p>
|
||
</div>
|
||
<div class="grid grid-8 last">
|
||
<form action="https://www.nature.com/briefing/ai_and_robotics" method="post" data-location="banner" data-track="signup_nature_briefing_banner" data-track-action="transmit-form" data-track-category="nature briefing" data-track-label="Briefing banner submit: Flagship">
|
||
<input id="briefing-banner-signup-form-input-track-originReferralPoint" type="hidden" name="track_originReferralPoint" value="AIAndRoboticsBriefingBanner">
|
||
<input id="briefing-banner-signup-form-input-track-formType" type="hidden" name="track_formType" value="DirectEmailBanner">
|
||
|
||
<input type="hidden" value="false" name="gdpr_tick" id="gdpr_tick_banner">
|
||
<input type="hidden" value="false" name="marketing" id="marketing_input_banner">
|
||
<input type="hidden" value="false" name="marketing_tick" id="marketing_tick_banner">
|
||
<input type="hidden" value="AIAndRoboticsBriefingBanner" name="brieferEntryPoint" id="brieferEntryPoint_banner">
|
||
|
||
<label class="nature-briefing-banner__email-label" for="emailAddress">Email address</label>
|
||
|
||
<div class="nature-briefing-banner__email-wrapper">
|
||
<input class="nature-briefing-banner__email-input box-sizing text14" type="email" id="emailAddress" name="emailAddress" value="" placeholder="e.g. jo.smith@university.ac.uk" required data-test-element="briefing-emailbanner-email-input">
|
||
|
||
<input type="hidden" value="true" name="N:ai_and_robotics" id="defaultNewsletter_banner">
|
||
<button type="submit" class="nature-briefing-banner__submit-button box-sizing text14" data-test-element="briefing-emailbanner-signup-button">Sign up</button>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
<div class="nature-briefing-banner__checkbox-wrapper grid grid-12 last">
|
||
<input class="nature-briefing-banner__checkbox-checkbox" id="gdpr-briefing-banner-checkbox" type="checkbox" name="gdpr" value="true" data-test-element="briefing-emailbanner-gdpr-checkbox" required>
|
||
<label class="nature-briefing-banner__checkbox-label box-sizing text13 sans-serif block tighten-line-height" for="gdpr-briefing-banner-checkbox">I agree my information will be processed in accordance with the <em>Nature</em> and Springer Nature Limited <a href="https://www.nature.com/info/privacy">Privacy Policy</a>.</label>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</form>
|
||
</div>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages__banner-small">
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages__close-container">
|
||
<button class="c-site-messages__close"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-category="nature briefing"
|
||
data-track-label="Briefing banner dismiss: Flagship">
|
||
<svg width="25px" height="25px" focusable="false" aria-hidden="true" viewBox="0 0 25 25" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
|
||
<title>Close banner</title>
|
||
<defs></defs>
|
||
<g stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd">
|
||
<rect opacity="0" x="0" y="0" width="25" height="25"></rect>
|
||
<path d="M6.29679575,16.2772478 C5.90020818,16.6738354 5.90240728,17.3100587 6.29617427,17.7038257 C6.69268654,18.100338 7.32864195,18.0973145 7.72275218,17.7032043 L12,13.4259564 L16.2772478,17.7032043 C16.6738354,18.0997918 17.3100587,18.0975927 17.7038257,17.7038257 C18.100338,17.3073135 18.0973145,16.671358 17.7032043,16.2772478 L13.4259564,12 L17.7032043,7.72275218 C18.0997918,7.32616461 18.0975927,6.68994127 17.7038257,6.29617427 C17.3073135,5.89966201 16.671358,5.90268552 16.2772478,6.29679575 L12,10.5740436 L7.72275218,6.29679575 C7.32616461,5.90020818 6.68994127,5.90240728 6.29617427,6.29617427 C5.89966201,6.69268654 5.90268552,7.32864195 6.29679575,7.72275218 L10.5740436,12 L6.29679575,16.2772478 Z" fill="#ffffff"></path>
|
||
</g>
|
||
</svg>
|
||
<span class="visually-hidden">Close</span>
|
||
</button>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
<div class="c-site-messages__content text14">
|
||
<span class="c-site-messages--nature-briefing__strapline strong">Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox.</span>
|
||
<a class="nature-briefing__link text14 sans-serif"
|
||
data-track="click"
|
||
data-track-category="nature briefing"
|
||
data-track-label="Small-screen banner CTA to site"
|
||
data-test-element="briefing-banner-link"
|
||
target="_blank"
|
||
rel="noreferrer noopener"
|
||
href="/briefing/ai-and-robotics/?brieferEntryPoint=AIAndRoboticsBriefingBanner">Sign up for Nature Briefing: AI and Robotics
|
||
</a>
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
</div>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<noscript>
|
||
<img hidden src="https://verify.nature.com/verify/nature.png" width="0" height="0" style="display: none" alt="">
|
||
</noscript>
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
<script src="//content.readcube.com/ping?doi=10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6&format=js&last_modified=2025-06-03" async></script>
|
||
</body>
|
||
</html> |